COLUMBUS — As with his other public appearances, Norfolk Southern CEO Alan Shaw started his testimony on Tuesday before an Ohio Senate committee with an apology for the catastrophic train derailment in East Palestine on Feb. 3.
“I am deeply sorry for the impact this derailment has had on the people in the region,” he said. “I am determined to make it right.”
Ohio state Sen. Kristina Roegner, a Republican, accepted the apology.
“Thank you for that, but just important is looking forward, making sure that this doesn't happen again anywhere in our state or in our country,” she told him during a hearing of the Senate Select Committee on Rail Safety.
The CEO met with Gov. Mike DeWine on Monday in advance of Mr. Shaw's appearance before lawmakers.
“Norfolk Southern is here for the long haul,” he said.
Read More
He told the committee that Norfolk Southern is a safe railroad company and that its safety record had improved over the past year before the derailment and the subsequent fire and spill of hazardous materials.
He said the company has been installing additional wayside detectors like the one that detected the overheated wheel bearing on the train's 23rd car, which has been largely blamed for the derailment. The detectors are being installed at more frequent intervals along the track even as he said the wayside detector that flagged the original problem, as well as the crew's subsequent response to the warning, worked as they were supposed to.
“By that time, regrettably, the bearing had already failed and the train was in the process of derailing,” he said.
He said the National Transportation Safety Board has focused on that specific car, which is not owned by Norfolk Southern. A failure in that car's venting system has also been blamed.
“I firmly believe that enhancements in safety throughout the rail industry are going to require industry-wide response, which includes car owners, our valuable customers, car builders,” Mr. Shaw said.
He endorsed some of the increased safety requirements included in pending legislation at the federal level and some of what state lawmakers included in the just-passed two-year transportation budget.
But a requirement that every freight train have at least a two-person crew on board wasn't among them.
“At this point I have not seen data that provides a direct link between crew size and derailments,” he said. There was a two-person crew and a trainee on the East Palestine train.
Some committee members noted that the same train and others like it carrying hazardous materials travel through some of the state's most densely populated regions.
“All the things you are talking about are mechanical and are things that can help, no question about it, but they can also be subject to failure.” Sen. Paula Hicks-Hudson, a Democrat, said.
She asked Mr. Shaw whether the railroads would consider rerouting trains carrying hazardous materials around cities like Toledo or over sensitive waters like Sandusky Bay.
She did not get a direct answer.
“It's disappointing when you've got a chance to really set the record straight and clearer, and I don't think it was anything that would have hurt the lawsuit for the company,” Ms. Hicks-Hudson said afterward.
Beyond lawsuits filed by those directly affected by the derailment. Norfolk Southern has been sued in federal court by Ohio Attorney General Dave Yost. The lawsuit argues the derailment was avoidable and a result of the company putting profits ahead of safety.
The company has shed as much as 40% of its work force in recent years.
Mr. Shaw repeatedly said he has visited East Palestine, honoring first-responders and even holding a well-attended Easter egg hunt in a local park. He said the company has made an initial investment of $30 million, adjusted its cleanup plans to respond to local residents' wishes, and support for impacted local businesses. He said he personally contributed $450,000.
The company boasts 2,700 employees in Ohio who handle 450,000 loaded freight cars and its investment of $2.6 billion into its lines.
The Block News Alliance consists of the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette, The Blade of Toledo, Ohio, and television station WDRB in Louisville, Ky. Jim Provance is a reporter for The Blade.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.