George Washington’s inauguration in New York City drew throngs of people who heard the humble hero of the American Revolution say that he would not take a salary as president, only expenses.
“He’s rich. He wants to make the statement that he is a public servant, that he is serving the people,” said Susan Dunn, a humanities professor at Williams College in Massachusetts.
“Before he resigned as commander in chief, the army wanted to make him king. He scolded them. Don’t say such a thing again. The whole idea is to separate from monarchy,” Ms. Dunn said. The first president emphasized that government “depends on how Americans behave. They all have to work together.”
In the nation’s 200-plus years since then, Americans have come to expect certain traditions will be followed by those who occupy the White House. While the transfer of presidential power has continued since Washington held the office, it hasn’t always been a smooth process.
President Donald Trump says he won’t attend the inauguration of Joseph R. Biden, the second Pennsylvania native elected to the position. Mr. Trump is hardly the first outgoing president to skip the event, which this time around will feature probably the most intense security ever gathered for the occasion.
Like his predecessors, Mr. Biden will try to seize his first moment as the nation’s leader to change its course. With the right tone and words, a new president can summon a country’s collective will.
Read More
“In 1789, Americans needed a humble president, not one hungry for power (like a king),” Ms. Dunn wrote in an email. By contrast, Franklin Delano Roosevelt struck a bold, resolute tone at the first of his three inaugurals, inviting every American to join in battling the Depression and forging the country’s future.
“In 1933, humility was the last thing Americans needed. They needed a hugely self-confident but empathetic president to lead them. And FDR also taught Americans about their interdependence. Not individualism, but social solidarity and cohesion,” Ms. Dunn said.

Fewer than 100 people attended Ronald Reagan’s second inaugural, Jan. 20, 1985; frigid temperatures forced the ceremony indoors to the White House grand foyer. The traditional parade was canceled. On Jan. 21, thousands attended a second ceremony inside the U.S. Capitol rotunda.
Bitter cold and a glaring sun — high overhead at noon — has often figured in the festivities. Some Americans recall watching John F. Kennedy shield Robert Frost’s eyes from wind and the sun’s glare so he could read “Dedication,” the poem he wrote for the occasion, but to no avail. Instead, Frost closed his eyes and recited “The Gift Outright” from memory.
Jack Torry, a retired journalist from Leesburg, Va., began covering Washington, D.C., in 1988 and shivered through his share of inaugurals. He’d never seen anything like the multitudes who watched Barack Obama take the oath of office on a frigid day in January 2009.
“They closed the bridges. It was a nightmare to get Downtown,” Mr. Torry recalled. The night before, he joined fellow journalists employed by Cox Media Group. “We all got in our jammies and slept in the Cox newsroom.” He also showered there the next morning before covering the ceremony.
“You had to get there hours before, so you left early. Security was just unbelievable,” he said.
The previous Pennsylvanian
The last time a Pennsylvania native was inaugurated, the sun shone on a pleasant day in March 1857. But James “Old Buck” Buchanan was ill with dysentery from drinking contaminated water at a Washington hotel.

“He really struggled at the inauguration to keep himself together. He is quite sick when he takes the oath of office,” said Michael Birkner, a Gettysburg College history professor who edited three books about the 15th U.S. president.
“His physician gives him brandy and some other unknown medication and he gets through the day,” Mr. Birkner added.
Next came a protocol gaffe. As Buchanan’s half-covered carriage, called a barouche, sped toward the Capitol, his aides realized they had failed to pick up a most important passenger: Franklin Pierce, the outgoing president.
“They had all of the military, all of the bands. They even had a float that was going to ride in front” of Buchanan’s carriage, Mr. Birkner said. “’Where’s Pierce,’ somebody says? Nobody had told Franklin Pierce that he was supposed to be riding with Buchanan.”
Buchanan’s aides simply forgot to invite President Pierce to ride with the president-elect.
Buchanan, whom Mr. Birkner noted scholars regularly rank in the basement of U.S. presidents, knew the U.S. Supreme Court’s Dred Scott decision, which he supported, would be made public a few days later. The majority opinion, written by Chief Justice Roger Taney, said all people of African descent, free or enslaved, were not U.S. citizens and had no right to sue in federal court.
Before taking the oath, Buchanan, who was born in Cove Gap, Franklin County, talked with Taney, a political ally.

Long before the inaugural, Buchanan “was lobbying Supreme Court justices to do what he wanted them to do. This is not unprecedented. Lyndon Johnson did this with Abe Fortas. That doesn’t make it right,” Mr. Birkner said. “That was a very big deal at the time because slavery was the No. 1 issue in the country.”
A northerner with Southern sympathies, Buchanan took meals at a Washington, D.C., boarding house with Southern congressional leaders, including his closest friend and political ally, William R. King, a slave-owning senator from Alabama.
“If you are sitting with just one side, obviously you are going to get just one view,” Mr. Birkner said, adding that Buchanan “had a very benign view of slavery — slavery was actually good for Blacks. He thought the fanatics in the society were not the fire-eating Southerners but the abolitionists.”
Spectacle and soap opera
Nearly half a century earlier, after the contentious election of 1800, John Adams and Thomas Jefferson — once friends — parted ways. That election was preceded by four years of mudslinging. On the day of Jefferson’s inauguration, Adams left town early in the morning to return to his Massachusetts home.
Public inaugurations are always about who sits where, speeches and which Bible the president-elect chooses. Often, bitter tensions simmer beneath the spectacle, depending on the combatants and the depth of their hostility.
John Quincy Adams, a one-term president and son of John Adams, skipped the inauguration of his successor in March 1829 because he “did not believe that Andrew Jackson was qualified to be president of the United States,” Mr. Birkner said.
After the Civil War ended in 1865, Andrew Johnson and Gen. Ulysses S. Grant “had a falling out over how to treat the defeated South. Grant realized that Johnson was up to no good. Grant broke with Johnson and became a Republican candidate in 1868,” Mr. Birkner said.

At Grant’s 1869 inauguration, Johnson — the first president to be impeached — was absent. “Johnson felt it was not his place to be there,” Mr. Birkner said.
President Harry S. Truman and Dwight D. Eisenhower had worked closely together and admired each other. Eisenhower led Allied military forces during World War II, winning Truman’s respect and admiration. Truman asked the five-star general in 1950 to lead NATO forces in Europe and make them an effective deterrent to Soviet aggression.

Eisenhower liked Truman for his “forthrightness and decision character. He was a man who faced up to his obligations and met them without temporizing,” the historian said.
Truman did not seek re-election in 1952 but he was president when Eisenhower, while campaigning, sharply attacked his domestic and foreign policies. “Truman’s handling of the Korean War was the essential element of Ike’s criticisms,” Mr. Birkner said.
After Eisenhower was elected president in 1952, the two men rode to the Capitol on Jan. 20, 1953, chatting awkwardly about the crowd, the weather and an orderly transition.
“These are two estimable political American characters who get into a spat. They won’t let it go. It was not like [Herbert] Hoover and Roosevelt in 1933 with completely dead air. Roosevelt kept waving to people and Hoover stared straight ahead,” Mr. Birkner said.
But back to that 1953 car ride.
“Eisenhower asks Truman why it was that his son, John, in the military stationed in Korea, had been ordered back for the inauguration,” the historian said.
President Truman replied that he had insisted John Eisenhower be flown to the U.S. to see his father sworn in to the nation’s highest office.
Dwight Eisenhower mustered a guttural thank you. A few days later, he sent a note expressing appreciation for the president’s kindness.
Still, a decade passed before the two reconciled, in 1963.
“They were seated next to one another at JFK’s funeral. They exchanged somewhat awkward greetings,” Mr. Birkner said. “They agreed, ‘We’re old guys. We could actually make this work.’ ”
Marylynne Pitz at mpitz@post-gazette.com or on Twitter:@mpitzpg




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.