After The Washington Post on Sunday published an extraordinary phone call between President Donald Trump and Georgia Secretary of State Brad Raffensperger many observers shared one question: Did the president break the law?

During that hourlong call Saturday, Mr. Trump urged Mr. Raffensperger to “find” enough votes to overturn his defeat in the state and threatened him with vague legal consequences — essentially encouraging his fellow Republican to fix the election results.

As the sole Democrat on Georgia’s state election board urged Mr. Raffensperger on Sunday to investigate the president over the call, some lawyers and legal scholars say Mr. Trump’s actions indeed appeared to violate both state and federal criminal statutes.

On social media, much of the conversation among legal observers and Trump critics revolved around a federal statute, 52 U.S. Code 20511, that makes it a crime to “knowingly and willfully” deprive or defraud a state’s residents of a free or fair election or to attempt to do so.

Advertise with us

Eric Holder, the attorney general under President Barack Obama, shared the text of that statute on Twitter on Sunday. “As you listen to the tape consider this federal criminal statute,” he wrote.

The question, according to Justin Levitt, a law professor at Loyola Marymount University, is whether Mr. Trump was “knowingly and willfully” pressuring Mr. Raffensperger to count nonexistent votes when he told the GOP official, “I just want to find 11,780 votes.”

In other words: Does Mr. Trump actually believe that 11,780 ballots in his favor were cast but not counted?

Considering that two recounts, an audit and several judges have upheld President-elect Joe Biden’s win in Georgia, Mr. Levitt said it is clear Mr. Trump was not actually pushing for an “honest tally” of the votes.

“Either the president was engaged in the commission of a felony,” Mr. Levitt said, “or he has lost his hold on reality such that he can no longer distinguish fact from the fictions he has been fed.”

Advertise with us

Michael R. Bromwich, a former Justice Department inspector general, put it more bluntly on Twitter: “His best defense would be insanity.”

Since 52 U.S. Code 20511 was adopted as part of the National Voter Registration Act of 1993, it has been used sparingly by federal prosecutors. It was used in 2005 to go after Milwaukee grandmother Kimberly Prude, who voted illegally in the city while still on probation. But Mr. Levitt said there is no precedent to use it against someone of Mr. Trump’s stature.

Other legal scholars said Mr. Trump possibly violated 18 U.S. Code 241, which makes it illegal to participate in a conspiracy against people exercising their civil rights. That longstanding statute has been used frequently to prosecute acts of voter intimidation, especially those committed by the Ku Klux Klan against Black voters.

But charging Mr. Trump under that code would require prosecutors to show that someone else on the phone call was also aiding and abetting a scheme, Mr. Levitt said.

Additionally, Mr. Trump’s apparent threat of criminal consequences if Mr. Raffensperger failed to act could be seen as an attempt at extortion, The Post reported.

Advertise with us

On the state level, Mr. Trump’s call could also have violated a Georgia statute.

Leigh Ann Webster, a criminal defense attorney in Atlanta, told The Post that in Georgia, Mr. Trump could run afoul of a state law that makes it illegal to cause someone else to partake in election fraud — by soliciting, requesting or commanding it.

That’s the same statute cited Sunday by David J. Worley, the Georgia election board member who asked Mr. Raffensperger to investigate Mr. Trump. In his email to Mr. Raffensperger, Mr. Worley said “probable cause” may exist to find violations of that law.

“It’s a crime to solicit election fraud, and asking the secretary to change the votes is a textbook definition of election fraud,” Mr. Worley said in an interview with The Post.

The argument may be more straightforward compared to a potential federal case. Under the Georgia statute, Ms. Webster said the crime would be merely asking someone else to partake in one of several forms of election fraud, including interfering with the secretary of state’s handling of an election.

Advertise with us

But because such matters at the state level have rarely been interpreted in court, “none of this is bulletproof,” she said.

And whether Mr. Trump broke federal state law, it’s a different question of whether any prosecutor would try to charge him.

Until Mr. Biden is sworn in on Jan. 20, legal scholars say there is virtually no chance of federal charges being filed. Besides the short time frame, Mr. Levitt said, the Justice Department maintains a long-standing principle that a federal prosecutor may not prosecute a sitting president.

No such principle exists once a commander in chief is out of office. Yet under a Biden administration juggling a bevy of competing priorities, going after Mr. Trump in the courts could be a politically fraught choice.

Trevor Potter, a Republican and former Federal Election Commission chairman who was appointed by President George H.W. Bush, told The New York Times “there is a good argument” that Mr. Trump had been pushing for a fraudulent vote count during the call.

Advertise with us

“But even if the Biden Justice Department thinks they have a good case, is that how they want to start off the Biden presidency?” Mr. Potter said. “That is a policy decision.”

Updated Jan. 4, 2021, 5:59 p.m.