U.S. Sen. Pat Toomey’s decision to ditch the political arena in 2022 and seek private employment has opened the floodgates for insiders and experts to speculate about who should run to replace him.
Mr. Toomey said Monday that he suspects there will be “a number of candidates” who enter the field — and that’s not counting the many who will see an opening to run for Pennsylvania governor, a pursuit that the Republican ruled out.
To longtime GOP strategist Charlie Gerow in Harrisburg, Mr. Toomey is underestimating the circus that’s about to roll into town.
“Right now, it’s the Harrisburg phone directory that’s envisioning themselves as either governor or senator,” Mr. Gerow said.
Probably half the congressional delegation, a third of the state Legislature and various county commissioners, business people, academics and attorneys are mulling whether they should enter one of the contests, Mr. Gerow said.
Though it’s far too early to narrow a field that’s anything beyond speculative, party officials and Pennsylvania political gurus have begun developing their wish lists, starting with names that — in many cases — have been rumored for years.
Mr. Toomey’s vacancy on the Senate ticket hasn’t yet revealed consensus favorites for the GOP.
Insiders have cited several Republican congressmen — from Fred Keller, R-Snyder, and Guy Reschenthaler, R-Peters, to Dan Meuser, R-Schuylkill, Mike Kelly, R-Butler, and Glenn “G.T.” Thompson, R-Centre — as potential candidates, as well as Scott Brady, U.S. attorney for the Western District of Pennsylvania, and William McSwain, U.S. attorney for the Eastern District.
On the Democratic side, names that have emerged include Lt. Gov. John Fetterman, Attorney General Josh Shapiro — if he doesn’t run for governor — and four first-term congresswomen from the southeast, Susan Wild, D-Lehigh, Mary Gay Scanlon, D-Delaware, Chrissy Houlahan, D-Chester, and Madeleine Dean, D-Montgomery. Political aficionados also cite state Treasurer Joe Torsella and U.S. Reps. Matt Cartwright, D-Lackawanna, and Conor Lamb, D-Mt. Lebanon, as possibilities.
Christopher Borick, director of Muhlenberg College’s Institute of Public Opinion, said a successful statewide candidate in Pennsylvania is not an “ideologue,” but a moderate.
“Other than the president, and then [former U.S. Sen. Rick] Santorum in 2000, those polarizing Republican figures haven’t done well in the state,” Mr. Borick said. “Who’s done well over time? People like [former Pennsylvania Gov.] Tom Ridge ... and it’s a different world from when Ridge and [former U.S. Sen.] John Heinz were winning elections.”
Mr. Gerow said the chief characteristic of a successful Senate candidate here is one who can raise “tons of money” for a campaign. Republicans want to field someone who is not extremely conservative, but right of center with broad appeal, he added — saying Mr. Toomey fit that bill.
“The most important thing is that in order to govern, you have to win an election,” Mr. Gerow said. “I look for the conservative candidate who’s most viable. That’s why I supported Pat Toomey from the beginning.”
The problem facing moderate Republicans, Mr. Borick said, is that any candidate has to pass through a GOP primary with a growing number of fairly ideological and engaged voters, many of whom are now “firmly in the Trump camp.”
The model for Democrats, meanwhile, is U.S. Sen. Bob Casey, who has won three times in Pennsylvania and holds on to legacy Democrats while getting progressive support, Mr. Borick said.
Chad Baker, executive committee member of the state Democratic Party and chair of the York County Democrats, said Mr. Fetterman tops his list for the Senate given his “favorability throughout the Commonwealth.” Mr. Fetterman — who was elected lieutenant governor in 2018 — ran unsuccessfully for the Senate in 2016, losing to Katie McGinty in the primary.
Mr. Baker also noted that Pennsylvania has never elected a woman to the U.S. Senate, and that the congresswomen from the southeast “have made names for themselves in Congress and would be fantastic senators for the state.”
Mr. Lamb, who first has to win his own re-election race against Republican Sean Parnell this November before considering higher office, is “level-headed” and has a military background that would do well in a state with so many veterans, Mr. Borick said. He is someone whom a lot of national Democrats are keeping an eye on, he added.
With Mr. Toomey out of contention for Pennsylvania governor, Republicans are anticipating bids from a list of officials, including former gubernatorial candidates Scott Wagner, Laura Ellsworth and Paul Mango, former lieutenant governor candidate Jeff Bartos, state Senate Majority Leader Jake Corman, former state House Speaker Mike Turzai and former U.S. Rep. Charlie Dent, among others.
Sam DeMarco, chair of the Republican Committee of Allegheny County, said he hadn’t heard directly from any candidate expressing interest, but that he’d consider Mr. Turzai, Mr. Thompson and state Sens. Mike Regan, R-York, and Doug Mastriano, R-Franklin, as viable options — as well as Mr. Mango, who “has the money to come back and say, ‘You guys screwed up with [Scott] Wagner last time, how about me?”
Mr. Wagner emerged from the GOP gubernatorial primary in 2018 and lost to Gov. Tom Wolf in the general election.
Democratic wish lists are headlined by Mr. Shapiro and Mr. Fetterman — if they don’t pursue the Senate.
For governor, Mr. Baker said Mr. Shapiro tops his list.
“He is well liked throughout the state, has worked diligently for underrepresented individuals in Pennsylvania through his role as AG, and he has the name recognition going into the race that will be critical,” Mr. Baker said.
Rick Thomas, chair of the Union County Democratic Party, said Mr. Shapiro “seems to have a pretty solid base to support him.”
“Obviously, much will be determined after the election next month, so all bets are off until we see how that plays out,” Mr. Thomas said.
“Ask me again around Dec. 1,” Mr. Thomas added in an email, with a smiley face emoji.
Julian Routh: jrouth@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1952, Twitter @julianrouth.







Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.