Sen. Kirsten Gillibrand of New York argued that former Vice President Joe Biden was referring to women implicitly when he wrote in a 1981 op-ed opposing a child care tax credit that it would cause the "deterioration of family," despite never specifically mentioning women in the piece.
In an interview with CNN's Brooke Baldwin on "Newsroom," Ms. Gillibrand again attempted to claim that Mr. Biden had said women working outside the home would cause the deterioration of family life in America. When Ms. Baldwin pointed out that Mr. Biden never said those words -- and said in a floor speech that he didn't care if men or women chose to stay home and care for their children -- Ms. Gillibrand said she didn't accept that.
"I think he's full of BS when he says that," Ms. Gillibrand said. "Because the truth is who works outside the home in '80s, '90s, today? If you have two parents in a family, it's typically the woman who stays at home. Even today less than 5% of two-parent households is the woman not the one to stay at home."
She added, "So the truth is he could only be referring to women, because that's the reality when he wrote it and it's still the reality today."
Mr. Biden did not specifically say women working outside the home in his 1981 op-ed on the tax credit, which he criticized as helping to subsidize well-off families and parents instead of lower-incomes families who truly needed it.
"Too many Americans -- especially members of my generation -- go out of their way to avoid individual responsibility for themselves and for their families," he wrote.
Read More
Ms. Gillibrand first made the misleading claim during the Democratic presidential debate hosted by CNN on Wednesday.
"When the Senate was debating middle-class affordability for child care he wrote an op-ed," Ms. Gillibrand said. "He voted against it -- the only vote. But he wrote an op-ed that he believed that women working outside the home would 'create the deterioration of family.' He also said that women who were working outside the home were quote avoiding responsibility."
Mr. Biden was indeed the sole senator to vote against the tax credit in 1981 for people earning more than $30,000, or $88,000 today. While the op-ed was titled "Congress Is Subsidizing Deterioration Of Family," Mr. Biden never wrote that women working outside of the home created the deterioration of the family or avoided responsibility for their children.
"I consider it legitimate and necessary for the government to encourage single parents on limited incomes to get off of welfare and into the job market, or to help families of modest means to adequately provide the material necessities of child-rearing," Mr. Biden wrote. "But what I do not accept as legitimate is social policy that encourages a couple making $30,000, $40,000, $50,000 or more a year to evade full responsibility for their children by granting them a tax credit for day-care expenses."
"I do not believe it fair to ask a family of marginal income, choosing to provide the primary care for their children, to subsidize an upper income family's day care," he added.
In a 1981 floor speech on the matter, Mr. Biden added that he had no problem with women working.
"I have no objection to the fact that if a mother and a father want to get together and say, 'Hey, by the way, Joe, you take care of the child and I am going to pursue my career,' that is fine. That is a personal decision, and I am all for it," he said.
In the debate on Wednesday, Mr. Biden brushed off suggestions that his position was anti-woman.
"In the very beginning, my deceased wife worked when we had children. My present wife has worked all the way through raising our children," he said in response to Ms. Gillibrand.
"I wrote the Violence Against Women Act. Lilly Ledbetter. I was deeply involved in making sure there were equal pay amendments. I was deeply involved on these things. I came up with the 'It's On Us' proposal to see to it that women were treated more decently on college campuses."





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.