WASHINGTON — With four ruffles and flourishes from the Coast Guard Band, 41 tolls in a low C from the 12-ton bourdon bell atop the Washington National Cathedral, and a final burst of “Hail to the Chief,’’ the capital bid a final adieu to a man whose presidency itself was a farewell — the last breath of a time he described as “kinder, gentler’’ and of a generation of leadership rooted in the certainties of World War II and in the tensions of the Cold War.
In a funeral rite of poignancy and power, Washington came together to celebrate the life of George Herbert Walker Bush — the last president to know Japan and Germany as both adversary and ally, the last representative of the Eastern Republican aristocracy, the last tie to the brand of conservatism that deplored deficits and embraced free trade. And in saluting the 41st president, a weary and wary capital achieved a brief moment of unity.
In the front pews were five chief executives, a portrait gallery of our politics, from the dour and dutiful Jimmy Carter, whose presidency ended nearly four decades ago, to the impulsive and intuitive Donald J. Trump, whose presidency was skewered gently but unmistakably by Mr. Bush’s eulogists, though with less restraint from the Greek chorus of Bush family retainers who filled the seats of Washington’s most solemn gathering place.
It was a day like no other in contemporary Washington, beginning just after dawn when the faithful began to gather in a Washington hotel lobby, the women once beautiful wearing the brush strokes of the years, the men once powerful bent with age. For two hours the vestibule of the old Omni Shoreham Hotel — where balladiers once crooned about the Watergate crimes of Richard Nixon — was a mess of hugs and handshakes, earpieces and hairpieces, all provided by the wan and worn and by with those with walkers.
From start to finish, it was a salute, a tattoo blast, to Mr. Bush, his much understated style, his often unappreciated legacy. “George H.W. Bush was America’s last great soldier-statesman, a 20th-century founding father,’’ Bush biographer Jon Meacham, who traveled to Kennebunkport, Maine, to read chapters of his book to the ailing former president, said in a eulogy.
For this was the last gathering of Washington’s old guard, a day both somber and celebratory but mostly evocative of a time and a style of politics conducted by people who started in the era of black-and-white television but who seldom engaged in the crude, reductive politics of black-and-white.
‘”It's like being back in the 1990s,’’ said presidential historian Michael Beschloss, ‘’and wishing we could stay there.’’
In every element Mr. Bush’s funeral reflected his interests and his inclinations. There was a prince (Charles, of the United Kingdom), a king (Abdullah II, of Jordan), senators, members of the House, every living Supreme Court justice. And there were presidents, including Hashim Thaci of Kosovo, here to salute Mr. Bush for his 1992 letter threatening Serbia’s Slobodan Milosevic if he mounted military action inside Kosovo, then an enclave of Serbia.
In one row, along with Mr. Thaci, sat the former president of Mexico, the chancellor of Germany, the president of Poland and the Solidarity leader Lech Walesa. Behind them sat former Prime Minister John Major of Great Britain, and a Bush golf putt away sat most of the Trump cabinet. The seating arrangements spoke volumes. Four vice presidents, from Dan Quayle to Mike Pence, sat together. Justice Brett Kavanaugh sat beside retired Justice Anthony Kennedy, whom he replaced on the high court. Mr. Trump, who entered solemnly, holding hands with his wife, sat four seats from Hillary Rodham Clinton, whom he defeated for the White House two years ago. The president shook hands crisply with former President Barack Obama and with Michelle Obama but not with the Clintons.
At the center of the proceedings was a man who was no longer there. His coffin, draped in the flag of America’s military warriors, rested alone on the altar — and the center of the whispered pewside conversation, as at the eulogies delivered from the pulpit, were the achievements of Mr. Bush: the first Gulf War, the fall of Communism, the extension of the civil-rights commitment to disabled Americans.
Through it all there blared the notion that this assemblage was, as Gov. Haley Barbour of Mississippi, a former Republican national chairman, put it in an interview, “here to mark the end of an era.’’
George H. W. Bush is honored in Washington before his final trip to Texas.
Mr. Bush was the last president who was preoccupied with budget discipline; the last president who believed in the sanctity of international institutions; the last president without an ego; the last president who knew the lyrics of Frank Sinatra ballads; and the last president who knew H.L. Stimson, who served in the cabinets of William Howard Taft, Herbert Hoover, Franklin Roosevelt and Harry Truman.
Indeed, Mr. Bush, who served under Richard Nixon, Gerald Ford and Ronald Reagan and was elected to the House in the Lyndon Johnson years, may be the lineal political descendant of Mr. Stimson, who first encountered the young George Bush at the 1942 commencement of their shared alma mater, Phillips Academy Andover.
Mr. Bush’s ideology was service, his style was prudence.
“He listened, he asked very good questions, but never did he question the decisions he made,’’ said Roger Porter, who was assistant to the president for economic and domestic policy and who now teaches a course on the American presidency at Harvard. “That was because he was very cautious and careful.’’
But in his eulogy to his father and predecessor, former President George W. Bush spoke of the private George H.W. Bush, “a man constantly in motion,’’ his son said, a man born “with just two settings, full throttle — then sleep.’’ But in his decline he was a man who liked to sit on the back porch of his seaside summer retreat on a Maine promontory. “The horizons he saw,’’ the younger Mr. Bush said, ‘’were bright and beautiful.’’
George W. Bush: Learning courage from his father
It was the first time since Richard Nixon didn’t speak at the funeral of Lyndon Johnson that a sitting president didn’t eulogize one of his predecessors. Even Bill Clinton, who objected strenuously to the Vietnam policies of Mr. Nixon and whose wife, the former Hillary Rodham, was a staff member of the House committee that recommended presidential impeachment, eulogized the 37th president, saying a quarter-century ago that “the enduring lesson of Richard Nixon is that he never gave up being part of the action and passion of his times.’’
Indeed, the Bush family was determined that Mr. Trump — who during the 2016 GOP nomination fight ridiculed former Gov. Jeb Bush of Florida as being “low energy’’ and mocked Mr. Bush’s “thousand points of light’’ rhetoric and nonprofit voluntarism foundation — play as minor a role as possible in the rites. But, at midsummer, as funeral plans were developing only yards from where Mr. Bush’s condition was deteriorating in his Maine summer home, the Bush circle acknowledged that the funeral was less in their hands than in the hands of the Defense Department and that Mr. Trump would be invited.
“It was very important as a symbol that the president be here — because of the importance of the institution to President Bush,’’ said Republican Sen. Rob Portman of Ohio, a top aide to Mr. Bush and the budget director and chief trade ambassador to his son. “I’m glad he was invited and glad he is there.’’
Mr. Bush asked Brian Mulroney three years ago to speak at his funeral, and the former prime minister of Canada spoke warmly of his fishing companion and his partner in the acid rain agreement and the North American Free Trade Agreement, characterizing the 41st president as “a highly accomplished man who also had a delightful sense of humor and was a lot of fun.’’
Mr. Mulroney said that the United States in that period, at the end of the 1980s and the dawn of the 1990s, had special credibility. “Let me tell you that when George Bush was president of the United States of America, every single head of government in the world knew they were dealing with a true gentleman, a genuine leader — one who was distinguished, resolute and brave.’’
Much of the rhetoric at the Bush funeral dealt with the president’s legacy and with the notion that he was insufficiently appreciated when he was swept out of office by Mr. Clinton in 1992.
“Fifty or a hundred years from now, as historians review the accomplishments and context of all who have served as president,’’ Mr. Mulroney said, “I believe it will be said that, in the life of this country — which is in my judgment, the greatest democratic republic that God has ever placed on the face of this earth — no occupant of the Oval Office was more courageous, more principled and more honorable than George Herbert Walker Bush.’’
Everywhere in the crowd were political figures with their own stories, much like the one former Sen. Gary Hart shared when he wrote this week to the Bush team of winning the New Hampshire primary in 1984 and then looking toward the next contest, the Maine caucuses. Mr. Bush, a Republican, offered the Democratic candidate for president the use of his vacation home in Kennebunkport, Maine. “Instinctively,’’ Mr. Hart said, “he put hospitality over politics.’’
A hand-written note was left at the memorial spot for Mrs. Bush at Kennebunkport, along with two holiday candy canes assembled in the shape of a heart, hours after Mr. Bush’s death was announced: “Knowing that your beautiful wife will be there to greet you makes today a little bit easier for us all.’’ Wednesday Gate C41 at George H.W. Bush International Airport in Houston was decorated with a portrait of the 41st president. Aboard the aircraft carrier USS George H.W. Bush a thousand points of light spelled out “GHWB41.’’
Mr. Bush had been ridiculed by Democratic Gov. Ann Richards of Texas as “being born with a silver foot in his mouth’’ and (by himself) for lacking “the vision thing’’ that had been a big element of the enduring appeal of John F. Kennedy. He liked show-business personalities but disdained the show-business elements of the modern presidency.
It was clear throughout Wednesday proceedings that Mr. Bush was a figure from the past, his story melting into history. Yet this is how deeply embedded in American civic life was Mr. Bush, for it may be said that he can be considered the last man who shook the hand of a man who shook the hand of a man who shook the hand of a man who shook the hand of a man who watched Abraham Lincoln’s casket pass by.
But Wednesday Mr. Bush was praised for the very noblesse-oblige qualities that were part of his downfall in the 1992 election; was saluted for having a vision of a “new world order’’— his phrase — after the fall of Communism and the crumbling of the Berlin Wall; and was celebrated in every manner of the media, new and old.
And yet his life, and then his death, were but the latest affirmation of the sobering wisdom of Thomas Gray, whose 1750 “Elegy in a Country Churchyard’’ was revered by Abraham Lincoln (who thought his own life could be summarized by Gray’s meditation on “the short and simple annals of the poor’’) and whose verdict applies to all presidents, along with the men and women they seek to lead:
The boast of heraldry, the pomp of pow'r,
And all that beauty, all that wealth e'er gave,
Awaits alike th' inevitable hour.
The paths of glory lead but to the grave.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.