WASHINGTON – Thomas Hardiman was a runner-up — for the second time in less than two years — in President Donald Trump’s very public selection process for Supreme Court nominee.
The 3rd U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals judge was passed over by Mr.Trump Monday night, just as he was last year.
President Donald Trump announced Monday evening that Judge Brett Kavanaugh of the Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit was his nominee to replace retiring Justice Anthony Kennedy.
Judge Hardiman, a 53-year-old Fox Chapel father of three, was listed as one of the top four contenders, and Monday some news organizations said he was one of two finalists, as he was in 2017.
In Pittsburgh, Judge Hardiman’s friends and former colleagues watched the nomination on television just as they did early last year when Mr. Trump was choosing between him and Neil Gorsuch to replace the late Justice Antonin Scalia. Mr. Trump holds nominations close to the vest, leaving even top aides in the dark until his televised announcements.
Other finalists for the nomination this time were Judge Amy Coney Barrett of the Court of Appeals for the 7th Circuit and Judge Raymond Kethledge of the Court of Appeals for the 6th Circuit.
Read More
Hours before Mr. Trump announced his pick, U.S. Sen. Bob Casey, D-Pa., had already pledged his opposition, saying he cannot support a “corrupt’ process that began with the president choosing finalists from a list of 25 candidates presented to him by the Federalist Society, a right-leaning group of legal professionals funded by the conservative Heritage Foundation, which the senator says is “hell bent on handing health care over to insurance companies, crushing unions … and promoting policies that will leave the middle class further behind.”
Mr. Casey previously supported Judge Hardiman’s nomination to the 3rd Circuit.
“He is a good man. I like him,” Mr. Casey told reporters Monday during a visit to Braddock to discuss infrastructure. “But this is really about the process and whether or not the corporate right is going to be in charge of picking the Supreme Court in a nomination that is likely to tip the scales substantially.”
Republicans want to act quickly to fill Justice Kennedy’s seat ahead of the November midterm elections. Democrats have expressed concern that Mr. Trump’s goal has been to find a nominee to help overturn the landmark abortion rights case, Roe v. Wade.
Judge Hardiman grew up in Waltham, Mass. His father operated a cab and school transportation company, and Judge Hardiman has long shared stories of driving a cab for his father summers during college. Although his mother attended college, Judge Hardiman was the first in his family to graduate.
He is married to the former Lori Zappala, a member of the prominent Democratic family that includes Allegheny County District Attorney Stephen A. Zappala Jr. and former state Supreme Court Chief Justice Stephen A. Zappala.
He would have become the only justice without an Ivy League education had he been nominated and confirmed. That was considered a plus for those who have criticized the Supreme Court as being an insular and elite group who lack exposure to the kind of academic and economic diversity more often seen outside the ivies.
Judge Hardiman graduated from the University of Notre Dame and Georgetown Law. He worked in the Washington, D.C., office of Skadden, Arps, Slate, Meager & Flom before moving to Pittsburgh in 1992 to join Cindrich & Titus. He later became a partner in the Pittsburgh office of Reed Smith LLP and served there until President George W. Bush nominated him to serve on the Western District of Pennsylvania and later to the 3rd Circuit.
Correction, posted July 9, 2018: In an earlier version of this story, the circuit court on which Mr. Hardiman serves was misstated in the line about Sen. Casey’s previous support.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.