When it comes to political slam dunks, the annual presidential turkey pardon is among the easiest there is.

Go in front of the cameras. Stand beside a live turkey. Say a few honorary words. Toss in a couple cringeworthy jokes. Wish the bird a healthy life. Rinse, repeat, see you next year.

But if there’s any president who could change the course of the decades-long tradition, it’s Donald J. Trump. Often testing the boundaries of political norms, Mr. Trump can make even the simplest action a spectacle.

In time for Thanksgiving, here’s a look back at how Mr. Trump’s predecessors have handled one of the White House’s weirder traditions:

Advertise with us

Harry Truman

There’s much speculation that the tradition of pardoning a turkey started in 1947 with President Harry Truman, but he was simply the first to receive one from the National Turkey Federation and the Poultry and Egg National Board. Even the Truman Library disputes those rumors, saying it found no evidence that he pardoned the turkeys he received as gifts. Instead, “Truman sometimes indicated to reporters that the turkeys he received were destined for the family dinner table.” Tensions were high, though: Truman was gifted the birds by the poultry industry because growers were upset over the government encouraging “poultryless Thursdays.”

Read More

President Harry Truman inspects a turkey presented to him on Nov. 16, 1949. (Associated Press)

John F. Kennedy

President John F. Kennedy pardoned a turkey during his time in office, but it wasn’t official. The bird, wearing a sign reading “Good Eating Mr. President,” was spared by Mr. Kennedy on Nov. 18, 1963, just days before the president was assassinated. Mr. Kennedy reportedly said “we’ll let this one grow” before having it sent to a farm.

President John F. Kennedy reaches out to touch a turkey presented to him at the White House in 1963. (Associated Press)

Ronald Reagan

Advertise with us

Probably the most awkward turkey-related presidential moment of all time happened to Ronald Reagan, who didn’t get a full sentence out at the ceremony before the bird tried to flap away. Mr. Reagan — who admitted that he “maybe came in too fast” — made matters worse by making a lighthearted joke met by awkward silence. “Look, I had the chance to shoot a bunch of you the other day and I didn’t,” he said to the bird.

George H.W. Bush

The official tradition of pardoning a turkey began with George H. W. Bush, who spared a lucky bird in 1989. With animal rights activists protesting closeby, Mr. Bush remarked, “‘Reprieve,’ ‘keep him going,’ or ‘pardon’: it's all the same for the turkey, as long as he doesn't end up on the president's holiday table.” There was no looking back after this.

President George H. W. Bush pardons the first turkey on Nov. 14, 1989. (Bush Presidential Library and Museum Collection)

Bill Clinton

The turkey pardon took on new life during Bill Clinton’s presidency. In 1999, Mr. Clinton became the first president to give a name to the National Thanksgiving Turkey, calling the 50-pound bird “Harry” in honor of Mr. Truman. “So before I feast on one of the 45 million turkeys who will make the ultimate sacrifice, let me give this one a permanent reprieve, and tell you all that he will soon be on his way to the wonderful petting zoo at Fairfax County, Virginia, where he can enjoy his golden years,” Mr. Clinton said.

Advertise with us

George W. Bush

George W. Bush’s eight turkey ceremonies were less memorable than the other public aspects of his presidency, but people often remember Marshmallow and Yam, the pair of turkeys pardoned in 2005. Rather than retiring to Frying Pan Park in Virginia, Marshmallow and Yam were the first turkeys to be sent to Disneyland, serving as honorary grand marshals at the Thanksgiving Day Parade. “Marshmallow and Yam were a litte skeptical about going to a place called ‘Frying Pan Park.’ I don't blame them,” the president said. In his final Thanksgiving as president, Mr. Bush struck a remniscent tone about his tenure before pardoning a turkey named Pumpkin.

Barack Obama

There were more audible groans during Barack Obama’s turkey pardons than during any of his predecessors’. That’s because his jokes were corny and his puns were plentiful — and he was proud of it, smirking after each instance. But some were worthy of credit, most notably: "When somebody at your table tells you that you've been hogging all of the side dishes, you can't have any more, I hope that you respond with a creed that sums up the spirit of a hungry people: 'Yes, we cran.'"

Julian Routh: jrouth@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1952, Twitter @julianrouth.