In the court of public opinion, a “sorry” counts for something.
But just how much an apology matters in the face of sexual assault allegations has been the subject of a debate in recent weeks. As the list grows of prominent men accused of committing sexual indecencies — Minnesota Sen. Al Franken is the most recent — so do the critiques of how they respond.
So what makes a good apology?
Karina Schumann, an assistant professor in the University of Pittsburgh’s Department of Psychology who has done extensive research on the art of apologizing, said an effective apology takes full responsibility for one’s actions, acknowledges the harm done to the victims and offers a sincere recommitment to a moral standard.
When the first wave of allegations came out against movie producer Harvey Weinstein in October, he reacted with a statement that shifted the blame from his actions in the first paragraph, Ms. Schumann said.
Here's Harvey Weinstein's full statement regarding the @nytimes story about his decades of sexual harassment https://t.co/MoMCYpFAQM pic.twitter.com/83LG3aeu2b
— BuzzFeed Entertainment (@BuzzFeedEnt) October 5, 2017
Though he says it is no excuse, noting that he came of age in the ‘60s and ‘70s is an attempt to situate his behavior “in growing up in a context where this is OK, and that he’s just a product of the culture he was raised in,” Ms. Schumann said.
Read More
According to the professor, Mr. Weinstein also tried to deflect attention from his actions by mentioning the positive things he is involved with.
“This is really his attempt to make him seem like he’s an ally of women and put a positive spin on himself,” she said. “He is trying to make himself seem more moral, which is inconsistent with his more general behavior of sexually offending women. But this attempt just comes across as manipulative.”
Comedian and actor Louis C.K.’s apology for committing sexual misconduct toward five women was credited for being direct and sincere, but panned by critics who took issue with his attempt to shift blame.
Read Louis C.K.'s full statement: "There is nothing about this that I forgive myself for" https://t.co/Z8VhBRVxIC pic.twitter.com/kwJNmC8XY7
— Hollywood Reporter (@THR) November 10, 2017
Ms. Schumann said the comedian was right in admitting the stories are true, but that some aspects of his tone came across as annoying and obnoxious — like stating he had power over women because he was “widely admired.”
The problem for celebrities, Ms. Schumann said, is that their apologies are almost never seen as sincere because of their public status.
“They’re really working uphill in that way,” she said. “They’re up against harsh odds in trying to communicate sincere remorse.”
Actor Kevin Spacey didn’t come close in his apology for allegedly sexually assaulting multiple men, Ms. Schumann said.
— Kevin Spacey (@KevinSpacey) October 30, 2017
The professor said Mr. Spacey didn’t accept responsibility, created excuses for his actions and used the opportunity to point sympathy toward him.
Mr. Franken, who issued a statement right after he was accused Thursday of groping a woman while she was asleep and forcibly kissing her during a USO tour, came closer to what Ms. Schumann considers a well-crafted statement of apology.
NEW FRANKEN STATEMENT pic.twitter.com/c3puSkK9Ts
— Sam Stein (@samstein) November 16, 2017
Ms. Schumann said Mr. Franken’s apology comes across as sincere — most notably his use of the core words “sorry” and “apologize,” and the fact he indicates it doesn’t matter what his intentions were, just that he embraces the blame for his offenses.
“He acknowledges the harm and the intensity of the harm, the suffering and consequences of his actions for the victimized group. Not just for the victim herself, but women more generally,” Ms. Schumann said. “In doing that, he’s communicating an understanding of the extent to which his actions had an impact.”
That Mr. Franken didn’t push the blame onto his victim, society or a certain context makes his apology more powerful, Ms. Schumann said. Doing so is a common tactic used by perpetrators to justify their wrongdoings, and according to the professor, an approach that tainted many other apologies by celebrities recently.
Ms. Schumann said none of the recent apologies were perfect, but that Mr. Franken’s was the least defensive and hit upon the most positive aspects of saying sorry.
Julian Routh: jrouth@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1952, Twitter @julianrouth.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.