In a tweet on Wednesday, President Donald Trump raised the prospect of retaliating against NBC over a news report, asking “at what point is it appropriate to challenge their License?”

Can he do that?

Probably not, in part because the NBC network he attacked has no licenses (which are issued to TV stations) and in part because the federal government cannot legally police political speech.

“He can file a complaint like anybody else and say that NBC engaged in lying and misrepresentation to the public, and there ought to be a license revocation,” said Peter Tannenwald, a veteran communications lawyer. “The problem with that is we have a First Amendment, and I don’t think it’s illegal to lie.”

Advertise with us

That would be the First Amendment to the U.S. Constitution, which guarantees freedom of speech. Broadcasters were quick to point that out.

“The founders of our nation set as a cornerstone of our democracy the First Amendment, forever enshrining and protecting freedom of the press,” said Gordon Smith, the former Republican senator from Oregon who now is president of the National Association of Broadcasters, a trade group. “It is contrary to this fundamental right for any government official to threaten the revocation of an FCC license simply because of a disagreement with the reporting of a journalist.”

A station could be deemed unfit and have its license stripped if it were telling lies and spreading fake news, as Trump claims. But Harold Feld of the consumer group Public Knowledge says that’s tough to prove.

“The reality is it is just about impossible to make that showing,” he said. “All this stuff is opinion.”

Feld said he can recall just two instances in the past 20 years when there has been a renewal challenge. One involved an owner of radio stations who was convicted of child molestation, and the other when someone died as part of a radio station’s contest. Both lost their licenses.

Advertise with us

Although yanking a license is rare, just the threat could put pressure on NBC’s news coverage.

“The words ‘license renewal’ are ones which have had a chilling effect in the past on broadcasters,” said lawyer Floyd Abrams, an expert on the First Amendment, citing Richard Nixon’s attempts to sway news coverage as president. “The threat, however unlikely, is one that broadcasters will have to take seriously.”

In 1972, President Richard Nixon urged his lieutenants to interfere with the renewal of the Washington Post’s licenses for Florida TV stations. The company’s stock price took a hit, and defending the licenses cost the company more than $1 million in legal fees over 2½ years, publisher Katharine Graham wrote in her memoir in 1997.

“Of all the threats to the company during Watergate - the attempts to undermine our credibility, the petty slights, and the favoring of the competition - the most effective were the challenges to the licenses of our two Florida television stations,” Graham wrote.

Still, there are barriers of procedure and precedent.

Advertise with us

“Not how it works,” tweeted Jessica Rosenworcel, a member of the Democratic minority at the Federal Communications Commission, which oversees broadcast licenses. On Page 12 of a 33-page FCC guide to broadcast regulation, it says, “The Constitution’s protection of free speech includes that of programming that may be objectionable to many viewer or listeners. Thus, the FCC cannot prevent the broadcast of any particular point of view.”

That’s been the case in practice.

As for the license challenge process that exists, it doesn’t impinge on political speech. Stations get FCC licenses for up to eight years, which then need to be renewed. Challenges can be filed, but renewal is all but automatic.

FCC Chairman Ajit Pai is a Trump appointee, but experts say he can’t pull a license just because he feels like it. Renewals come up every eight years, and challenges are heard by an administrative law judge.

The judge’s decision can be overruled by political appointees at the FCC, however. And the agency could start a special proceeding to revoke a license, said Erwin Krasnow, former general counsel of NAB.

Advertise with us

Even so, Krasnow said a challenge is unlikely because of the First Amendment and because the Communications Act governing the FCC doesn’t allow for censorship.

Pai’s past statements also suggest he wouldn’t use the agency’s powers to regulate news coverage. In a September speech, he noted that, while people want the FCC to take action against cable news channels like Fox News, MSNBC or CNN because they disagree with the coverage, “these demands are fundamentally at odds with our legal and cultural traditions.”

Feld, who is a frequent critic of Pai, said the chairman is a fan of deregulation and “the last person in the world who would want to revive the license challenge process.”

“NBC can sleep easy knowing Ajit Pai is chair,” Feld added.

License loss “is never going to happen,” said Andrew Jay Schwartzman, a Washington communications lawyer. “Trump’s threats are meaningless as a legal proposition.”

Advertise with us

One more layer insulates NBC News from the president’s threat-corporate structure. NBC is owned by Comcast Corp., the cable giant. While NBC programming is broadcast nationwide on more than than 200 TV stations, just 10 are owned and operated by Comcast. The remainder of the stations are owned by independent businesses, known as affiliates.

The FCC’s ability to reach through these relationships and get at the networks is limited. For instance, after congressional hearings and other brouhaha surrounding the exposure of singer Janet Jackson’s breast at the Super Bowl in 2004, the FCC fined 20 stations owned by CBS’s corporate parent at the time. The network itself wasn’t penalized. Courts later threw out even the stations’ fines.

The Associated Press contributed.