WASHINGTON — For years he was known as Dr. Tim, the psychologist who gave out advice on KDKA-TV. Later he was the congressman who specialized in mental health policy, tirelessly championing legislation for troubled families.

When Tim Murphy’s life and career unraveled over a few weeks this fall, the forceful presence utterly silent as statements were issued on his behalf, the disconnect between what he said publicly and what he did privately erupted for all to see.

The staunch family man had strayed from his marriage. The fervent anti-abortion politician urged a woman with whom he had an extra-marital relationship to get an abortion and dismissed his pro-life statements as the work of his staff. The man who advised parents on how to handle angry children was said to be an angry boss by current and former staffers.

Colleagues and friends struggled to reconcile the hardworking advocate for mental health with the character portrayed in emails, texts and comments from former staffers.

Advertise with us

Michael Fields, 76, of Seven Devils, N.C., knew Mr. Murphy before he went into politics when the congressman was a practicing psychologist and guest on former Pittsburgh public television station WQEX.

“I’m still getting over this. When I first heard about it early in the week, I almost thought it was fake news,“ Mr. Fields said. ”It's stunning to me. This is as clean-cut and earnest and as virtuous a guy as I think I've ever met. I just never suspected this of him.”

Mr. Fields was the station's general manager in the 1990s and said the two hit it off.

“I always thought, just as most everybody else in the region, that this guy was as clean and as honorable and as well-intentioned as anybody, “ Mr. Fields said. ”His whole campaign for the [Pennsylvania] Legislature was that he just seemed like the model person getting into politics for all the right reasons — ostensibly happily married, professional in practice. . . . He was the kind of person that a centrist or even a slightly left Democrat could admire as just a decent human being who, except on a few issues, would always come around and do the right thing."

Mr. Fields was still having trouble Friday processing the news about Mr. Murphy's affair and his swift political downfall.

Advertise with us

"It's very painful to watch. There aren’t many politicians — and I've known a lot — who I could say I really admired, and to see even Tim Murphy fall from grace is not a happy thing,” Mr. Fields said.

Congruence — consistency between how you feel and the way you act — fosters honesty and communication. ... People who are incongruent may claim they feel or believe one thing and then act in an altogether different manner. Essentially, they hide their identity from others, and sometimes even from themselves — “Overcoming Passive-Aggression: How to Stop Hidden Anger” by Tim Murphy and Loriann Oberlin

Mr. Murphy grew up with 10 siblings in Cleveland, where he attended Catholic elementary and secondary schools, watched political conventions on television and considered entering the priesthood. Instead he headed to Wheeling Jesuit College for his undergraduate degree, Cleveland State University for his master’s and then the University of Pittsburgh for his doctorate in psychology. He worked in private practice and at Mercy Hospital and appeared regularly on KDKA-TV as an expert on child psychology between 1979 and 1995 and viewers came to know him as “Dr. Tim.”

By the time he entered politics at age 44, Mr. Murphy already had established a lucrative private practice in child psychology and seemed to like his work so much that Bob Jubelirer, who was Republican leader when Mr. Murphy was in the state Senate, remembers wondering why he’d want to leave it behind for a career in public policy. He said he never asked.

“The fact is he made a decision to run. I never said to him, ‘Are you crazy? Why would you do this? You have a wonderful practice,’ ” said Mr. Jubelirer. It seemed clear that Mr. Murphy was intent on serving in Harrisburg and, later, Washington.

Advertise with us

What Mr. Murphy may have had in mind was this advice: “Do something worthy of your time and your talent.” That’s what he told graduates in a commencement address at Wheeling Jesuit University, the undergraduate alma mater that solidified his Catholic faith and allowed him get an early taste of being in the public spotlight by putting him onstage in the Caviar Club’s Shakespearean productions.

He urged graduates to consider the impact of their actions, serve the Lord through the “gospel of duty,” and do what he said Congress cannot. “We cannot legislate character, we cannot mandate conscience and we cannot litigate compassion. You have to do that, and you are called by our faith to do that,” he said.

The speech also touched on mental health policy. For years in Congress, he worked on the Families in Mental Health Crisis Act. Until last year, when it became law as part of the 21st Century Cures Act, Mr. Murphy would bring almost any conversation around to mental health.

Asked what he hoped to hear about in President Donald Trump’s inaugural address, Mr. Murphy talked about mental health policy. Asked why he opposes gun control legislation, he said he’d rather use resources to help the mentally ill. Asked at the State of the Union address about a seat left open to represent victims of gun violence, Mr. Murphy said the seat should have gone to someone who overcame mental illness.

Only those closest to him knew his concern about mental health was deeply rooted in his past. It became clear minutes before the House voted on his legislation when the normally stoic congressman spoke tearfully to his colleagues on the floor about the day in the early 1970s when a soft voice saying “Help,” drew him to the family bathroom, where he found his father on the floor bleeding from arteries he had cut in his arms.

Advertise with us

Mr. Murphy’s father survived the suicide attempt and lived to old age while his son’s interest in helping mentally ill grew, the congressman said last year.

But his childhood left its mark on him. In a September message to Shannon Edwards, a forensic psychologist with whom he had an extra-marital relationship, he wrote, “I've made some pretty big mistakes in my life. In relationships. And despite my ability to be a decisive leader in some areas, relationships are my fatal flaw. With family. With friends. And even though I know it's [sic] source in my long tolerance of my father’s alcoholic brutality, I’ve never been able to shake it off. I’ve cried it out. I've screamed it out. I've reasoned it away. And although I've broken free of most of it, the residue has curiously remained in my inability to love and be loved. The exception has always been with kids. I am close and open with my daughter and grandchildren. That's my only and truest and deepest and unequivocal love.”

He seldom talked about his early life or his relationship with his siblings, according to numerous friends, co-workers and associates interviewed for this story. Over the course of two self-help books interspersed with personal anecdotes, he mentions them only once, in the acknowledgements section of “The Angry Child: Regaining Control When Your Child Is Out of Control,” co-authored by Loriann Oberlin.

“As a family, we certainly had our share of fights, laughter, disappointments, and joy over the years. But the devotion of my parents to their children, and their faith in God, continues to inspire me and to help others overcome obstacles in their lives,” he wrote.

Ms. Oberlin said her working relationship with Mr. Murphy had both “good times and struggles,” such as when his legislative work became more demanding. At times, she said, ideological differences sparked “spirited” conversations, but she always respected Mr. Murphy’s expertise in his field.

Advertise with us

“While our political views and affiliations were and are different, I never doubted that Tim wanted to contribute good things to the mental health community,” she said. “Ninety-eight percent of everything Tim has taught me about psychology has been spot on.”

Infidelity is often less about sexual satisfaction and much more a barometer of other emotions, including hidden anger built upon unrealistic expectations, beliefs, or fears. — “Overcoming Passive-Aggression:”

The relationship between Mr. Murphy and Ms. Edwards was first exposed as part of her divorce proceedings from her husband, Jesse Sally, a sports medicine physician. Dr. Sally filed for divorce from Ms. Edwards in July 2016. Then, this past summer, his attorney filed a request with the courts to depose Mr. Murphy as part of that court action.

In a statement he released on Sept. 6, Mr. Murphy portrayed what had occurred as “an affair with a personal friend.”

The issue became more complicated with a report on a text message sent to Mr. Murphy by Ms. Edwards, which took him to task for an anti-abortion statement posted on Facebook from his office’s public account.

Advertise with us

“And you have zero issue posting your pro-life stance all over the place when you had no issue asking me to abort our unborn child just last week when we thought that was one of the options,” said the text from Ms. Edwards on Jan. 25, in the midst of an unfounded pregnancy concern.

A text from Mr. Murphy’s cell phone number that same day in response says, “I get what you say about my March for Life messages. I've never written them. Staff does them. I read them and winced. I told staff don’t write any more. I will.”

The congressman has been lauded by the Family Research Council for his stance on abortion, as well as for family values, generally. He also has been endorsed by LifePAC, which opposes abortion rights, and is a member of the House Pro-Life Caucus, an affiliation that is often cited by his office.

The resulting controversy led Mr. Murphy first to say Wednesday he would not seek re-election, then Thursday to announce he would resign later this month.

It’s sometimes okay to be angry, but it’s never okay to be mean. — “The Angry Child: Regaining Control When Your Child Is Out of Control”

Advertise with us

Some Republican staffers in Harrisburg remember Mr. Murphy as difficult and arrogant, and a prominent Democrat once publicly referred to him as “a selfish, ruthless politician who tries to come across as a goody-two-shoes.”

Former staffers at both Mr. Murphy’s D.C. office and his district office in Mt. Lebanon described a difficult work environment.

A man who worked in the district office said that it was not uncommon for Mr. Murphy to bully staff members, belittle them for the quality of work and even mock them for physical attributes such as height and size.

Much of the staff frustration had to do with Mr. Murphy constantly changing his mind about tasks they were to perform, former staffers said.

Mr. Murphy would be curt with staff, they said, and regularly hang up on them during phone calls — or speak down to them like children.

Advertise with us

One former D.C. staffer defended the congressman.

“It was certainly an intense working environment and some people did not adjust well to it, but for others who enjoyed the frenetic pace and doing significant legislative policy work, it was rewarding. Some people thrive under that kind of pressure and other people do not,” he said.

“I acknowledge that it could be a challenging work environment, and it was for me at times. He would express frustration with me, but I just let him get it out of his system and then we would proceed,” he said. “There were worse bosses before Tim Murphy and there will be worse bosses after Tim Murphy.”

Mr. Murphy’s anger also appeared when he felt threatened politically, said Jim Roddey, former chairman of the Allegheny County Republican Party. He could channel that anger into hard work and determination that — combined with redistricting that weighed heavily in his favor — easily stamped out competition.

“He got paranoid any time somebody challenged him, but he always won by big margins,” Mr. Roddey said. “He would be so upset that someone would have the audacity to challenge him when he knew that he was the best possible congressman that the district could have.”

Advertise with us

Mr. Murphy couldn’t let that happen even if it meant campaigning 24 hours a day, and sometimes it seemed like that’s what he did, Mr. Roddey said.

“He was proud of the number of doors he could knock on. He was really driven to win,” Mr. Roddey said.

Mr. Jubelier knew him as a hard worker and a respected expert on mental health.

“Whenever you go into caucus there are people who will speak and nobody pays attention, and when other people speak things are quiet and everybody pays attention. When Tim spoke about his expertise people paid attention,” said Mr. Jubelirer, now a Harrisburg lobbyist.

He got lawmakers in Harrisburg to listen up, and later those in Washington.

Advertise with us

“He’s interested in issues most people aren’t. Mental health is something that most legislative-oriented human beings aren’t interested in, and I admire him for that,” said former Lt. Gov. Bill Scranton. “This country is not very good at dealing with public mental health issues, and I think he made a major contribution to that.”

But the personal overcame the professional.

Mr. Murphy's resignation took Capitol Hill by surprise Thursday, as lawmakers and staffers — who gave uncomfortable, short statements earlier in the day about the congressman’s previous intentions to retire — were suddenly alerted of his change in plans. Colleagues did not step up to comment on the resignation, nor discuss Mr. Murphy.

Late that day, House Speaker Paul Ryan’s statement was all anyone had. There were no details of what Mr. Murphy’s resignation letter contained. There wasn't a news conference, or a statement from Mr. Murphy himself.

His career in Congress ended in silence.

Advertise with us

Post-Gazette librarian Angelika Kane contributed. Staff Writers Paula Reed Ward, Jonathan D. Silver, Chris Potter and Julian Routh contributed.

CORRECTION: A previous version of this article wrongly attributed Former Lt. Gov. Bill Scranton’s quotes to his father, the late former governor of the same name.