WASHINGTON — Before U.S. Rep. Tim Murphy was known as a cheating husband and a pro-lifer who nonetheless urged a mistress to get an abortion, he was known as a champion of the mentally ill, who helped both as a practicing psychologist and as the architect of a bill that expanded care.

He can go back to that reputation or even create a better one if he makes the right decisions, but staying silent won’t help, specialists in crisis communication say.

To do that he has to take the right steps, said Mike Paul, president of Reputation Doctor LLC, a New York City communications company.

The Upper St. Clair Republican started that at 6 p.m. Wednesday in a written statement that said he will not seek re-election in 2018, and that in the coming weeks “I will take personal time to seek help as my family and I continue to work through our personal difficulties and seek healing.”

Advertise with us

That’s a start but not enough, said Larry Parnell, an expert in crisis communications who runs George Washington University’s graduate program in strategic public relations.

“People want to know what happened, whose fault it was and what you’re going to do to prevent it from happening again. When in the court of public opinion, you have to say ‘This is what’s going on. This is everything in my closet. I’m going to make it right and I apologize,” Mr. Parnell said.

And, Mr. Paul, added, the apology has to be sincere enough to make people say: “Hey. That was really hard for him to own that. It sounded honest to me. I don’t think he’s going to make that mistake again.”

The statement issued Wednesday offers neither an apology nor an explanation.

It may suffice for a short time among constituents who understand the congressman is working through the issue with his family, but eventually they’re going to want more, said political scientist Chris Borick of Muhlenberg College.

Advertise with us

“If you own up and say how awful you’ve been people tend to be a little more forgiving than if you hedge and deflect and take a route that makes you look a whole lot less sympathetic or even human,” he said.

People are more forgiving than it seems, but they aren’t forgetful, he said.

“When people see Mark Sanford they they think about the Appalachian Trail, but that hasn’t prevented him from having a pretty successful career afterward,” Mr. Borick said. He was referring to the former South Carolina governor who claimed to be hiking but was actually in Argentina with his mistress. Mr. Sanford is now a congressman.

Transgressions can diminish in prominence if accomplishments outweigh them, said Mr. Paul, who offered President Bill Clinton’s affair with Monica Lewinski as an example.

“Everyone said, ‘He’s done. He’s cooked.’ He was impeached. But he is now considered from a legacy perspective as one of our better presidents and he’s having an even stronger career post-White House than when he was in there,” Mr. Paul said.

Advertise with us

For now, Mr. Murphy has to focus on the 14 months until his term ends.

In his statement, the congressman said he plans to keep working on mental health reform and on issues affecting Southwestern Pennsylvania, but Mr. Borick said his influence will be limited.

“He’s still a vote, and that’s important for his party and for the president, but he’s not going to be able to exert much sway even within his own party. In many ways he’s a dead man walking,” Mr. Borick said.

Mr. Paul and Mr. Parnell are more optimistic.

With a sincere apology and a laser focus on his core legislative priorities, he can still be effective, they said.

Advertise with us

“He has the opportunity to alter or improve his legacy. He can still hold hearings and advance agendas and drive initiatives,” Mr. Parnell said. “What he shouldn’t do is fade away. That’s a missed opportunity.”

Washington Bureau Chief Tracie Mauriello: tmauriello@post-gazette.com; 703-996-9292 or on Twitter @pgPoliTweets.