WASHINGTON — Boisterous protests led to nearly 200 arrests and delayed the start of a long and spirited Senate committee debate over Republicans’ last-ditch effort to reformulate health care, but in the end, it was a soft-spoken voice from Maine that looked to be halting the effort.

At 5:11 p.m. Monday as the Senate Finance Committee ramped up a third hour of debate on the bill, moderate Republican Sen. Susan Collins of Maine issued a written statement opposing the legislation many viewed as her party’s last chance to overhaul national health care this year.

With Republicans’ narrow 52-48 majority and solid Democratic opposition, three GOP “no” votes are enough. Republican Sens. John McCain of Arizona, Rand Paul of Kentucky and Texas’ Ted Cruz have said they oppose the measure, though Cruz aides said he was seeking changes that would let him vote yes.

The Senate must vote this week for Republicans to have any chance of prevailing with their narrow margin. Next Sunday, protections expire against a Democratic filibuster, bill-killing delays that Republicans lack the votes to overcome.

Advertise with us

It was unclear if Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell, R-Ky., would have a roll call if he knew it would lose. No. 3 Senate GOP leader John Thune of South Dakota conceded that the measure’s prospects were “bleak.”

Ms. Collins announced her decision shortly after the nonpartisan Congressional Budget Office said “millions” of Americans would lose coverage under the bill and projected it would impose $1 trillion in Medicaid cuts through 2026.

Ms. Collins said her opposition stems from concerns about devastating changes and cuts to Medicaid, opportunities for states to weaken protections for pre-existing conditions, and warnings from insurers and providers that that the legislation could increase premiums while reducing coverage.

Proponents including Rick Santorum, the former Republican U.S. senator from Pennsylvania, appeared as witnesses to defend the bill before the Senate Finance Committee Monday. Mr. Santorum helped originate the bill and found sponsors in Republican U.S. senators Lindsey Graham of South Carolina, Bill Cassidy of Louisiana, Dean Heller of Nevada and Ron Johnson of Wisconsin.

“The important purpose here is to make sure we have a system that works for America,” Mr. Santorum testified Monday.

Advertise with us

Pennsylvania Secretary of Health and Human Services Teresa Miller said the country already does. Pennsylvania’s uninsured rate went from 10 percent to 5.6 percent under the Affordable Care Act, she said, while allowing that changes needed to be made to the individual markets.

The Senate Health Education Labor and Pensions (HELP) Committee had been working on a bipartisan solution earlier this month when the Graham-Cassidy plan emerged and derailed it.

“I was optimistic,” Ms. Miller testified Monday. “For the first time in this debate it appeared that senators from both sides of the aisle were focusing on the problem — the need to stabilize the individual market — and finding a solution to that problem rather than using it as an excuse to repeal the Affordable Care Act entirely.”

The Graham-Cassidy plan would give states flexibility to create their own insurance programs using block grants that would result in less federal funding for 13 states, including Pennsylvania.

“When you have flexibility without funding that’s not flexibility at all, “ testified former Obama administration Medicaid official Cindy Mann.

Advertise with us

Ms. Miller said the proposed changes would force states like Pennsylvania to either reduce services, reduce the number of people covered by them or reduce payments to providers. None of those are good solutions, she said.

Mr. Cassidy, who is a member of the committee and served as a witness Monday, challenged her on that.

“Ms. Miller keeps speaking as if there’s only three ways to lower cost. She’s absolutely wrong. You could actually put in policies” that reduce costs by reducing market concentration in places where one hospital system has a virtual monopoly.

U.S. Sen. Tim Scott, R-S.C. said the bill gives citizens what they want: local control and local accountability.

“Throughout the entire country people say their local and state politicians have their confidence more than their federal politicians. This seems like a no-brainer to give the money to the states to provide the very important opportunity to carve out strong, reliable, affordable health care options for their citizens that they see at the Piggly Wiggly, at the Walmart, at the grocery stores that they see every single night,” he said.

Advertise with us

U.S. Sen. Bob Casey, D-Pa., said the legislation is being pushed through quickly after a single hearing in “a process that isn’t in any way commensurate with the gravity of the challenge and the scope of this legislation.”

Mr. Casey, who also serves on the HELP Committee, prefers its approach.

“Some of the best bipartisan work on health care maybe in a decade was moving towards a consensus,” when Republicans introduced the Graham-Cassidy bill. “We should return to that, get that done and then, I hope, move on to other issues.”

Other committee Democrats lamented changes states might make in coverage for drug treatment, nursing homes, mental health and more.

“I feel strongly about state flexibility if it’s the flexibility to do better, not to do worse,” said U.S. Sen. Ron Wyden, D-Oregon.

Advertise with us

Mr. Graham said that under his bill states don’t have to make cuts to any of those programs if they don’t choose to.

“We repeal the individual mandate and the employer mandate, but you can reimpose it in your state if you like. If you want to go to a single payer system in Oregon you can, but you’re not going to drag me with you,” he said.

U.S. Sen. Pat Toomey, R-Pa., has not taken a position on the Graham-Cassidy bill. Constituents turned out to his district office in Pittsburgh Monday to urge him to vote against it.

Libby Powers, 29, of Sewickley, who uses a wheelchair because she has suffered from spina bifida, said she came out to speak for the people who can’t speak for themselves.

“I’m getting very sick and tired of fighting for something that is a human-right and not a privilege,” said Ms. Powers, who also has depression and anxiety.

Advertise with us

Protests also erupted in the Capitol Hill hearing room and the adjacent hallway forcing a brief delay in testimony while police escorted out people shouting “No cuts to Medicaid. Save our liberty.”

At one point Committee Chairman Orinn Hatch, R-Utah, told them, “If you want a hearing you better shut up.”

Capitol Police arrested 181 demonstrators in all. Fifteen of them, who refused to leave the hearing room, were charged with disruption of Congress. In the hallway, 166 were arrested on the charge of “crowding, obstructing or incommoding” in violation of D.C. Code. Twenty-three of them also were additionally charged with resisting arrest.

“Let’s have a civil discussion,” Mr. Hatch implored later as he called the panel to order for the second time.

“If this hearing is going to devolve into a sideshow or function simply for putting partisan points on the board there’s no reason for us to be here,” he said. “It hasn’t gotten there yet but it’s close.”

The Associated Press and Jessica Federkeil contributed. Washington Bureau Chief Tracie Mauriello: tmauriello@post-gazette.com; 703-996-9292 or on Twitter @pgPoliTweets.