WASHINGTON — Contradicting previous White House explanations, President Donald Trump declared Thursday he had planned to fire FBI Director James Comey all along, regardless of whether top Justice Department officials recommended the stunning step. His assertions — differing from what White House officials had been saying for days — came as Mr. Comey’s temporary replacement joined in, contradicting other administration statements on the snowballing controversy.
Meanwhile, Mr. Comey believes that a one-on-one dinner with Mr. Trump seven days after the inauguration, in which the president asked if Mr. Comey would pledge loyalty to him — a promise the FBI director declined to make — was a harbinger of his firing, according to two people who have heard Mr. Comey’s account of the conversation.
In an interview with NBC News, Mr. Trump also said he’d asked Mr. Comey point-blank if he was under investigation and was assured three times he was not. Mr. Trump was seen as showing no concern that the request might be viewed as interference in an active FBI probe into his 2016 campaign’s possible ties to Russia’s election meddling.
“I said, ‘If it’s possible, would you let me know am I under investigation?’ He said, you are not under investigation,” Mr. Trump told NBC. He said the discussions happened in two phone calls and at a dinner in which Mr. Comey was asking to keep his job.
Mr. Comey has not confirmed Mr. Trump’s account.
The White House initially cited a Justice Department memo criticizing Mr. Comey’s handling of last year’s investigation into Hillary Clinton’s emails as the impetus for Mr. Trump’s decision. But Mr. Trump on Thursday acknowledged for the first time that the Russia investigation — which he dismissed as a “made-up story” — was also on his mind as he ousted the man overseeing the probe.
Read More
The shifting accounts of the decision to fire Mr. Comey, whom Mr. Trump derided as a “showboat” and “grandstander,” added to a mounting sense of uncertainty and chaos in the West Wing, as aides scrambled to get their stories straight and appease an angry president. Not even Vice President Mike Pence was spared the apparent embarrassment of having told a version of events that was later discredited by Mr. Trump.
The White House’s explanations were viewed as continuing to crumble throughout the day Thursday. On Capitol Hill, acting FBI Director Andrew McCabe strongly disputed the White House’s assertion that Mr. Comey had been fired in part because he had lost the confidence of the FBI’s rank-and-file.
“That is not accurate,” Mr. McCabe said. “Director Comey enjoyed broad support within the FBI and still does to this day.”
Unfazed, White House spokeswoman Sarah Huckabee Sanders insisted she had heard from “countless” members of the FBI who welcomed the president’s decision.
Mr. McCabe promised lawmakers that he would inform them if the bureau’s investigation into possible ties between Mr. Trump campaign associates and Russia faces any political interference from the White House.
He also pointed out the remarkable nature of Mr. Trump’s version of his conversations with Mr. Comey. Mr. McCabe told a Senate panel it was not “standard practice” to tell an individual whether they are or are not under investigation.
Previous presidents have made a public show of staying out of legal matters, so as not to appear to be injecting politics. Mr. Trump’s comments demonstrated his deviation from that practice.
The ousted director himself is said to be confident that his own version of events will come out, possibly in an appearance before Congress, according to an associate who has been in touch with him since his firing Tuesday.
Mr. Trump and Mr. Comey’s relationship was strained early on, in part because of the president’s explosive and unsubstantiated claims that then-President Barack Obama wiretapped Trump Tower. Mr. Comey found the allegations confounding, according to his associate, and wondered what to make of what he described as strange thoughts coming from his new boss.
The president was no kinder to Mr. Comey on Thursday, calling him names and saying he’d left the FBI in “virtual turmoil.” He said that while he received a scathing assessment of Mr. Comey’s performance from Deputy Attorney General Rod Rosenstein on Monday, that memo was not a catalyst for his dramatic decision as the White House had said earlier.
“I was going to fire Comey,” Mr. Trump said. “Regardless of recommendation I was going to fire Comey.”
Mr. Trump also described a dinner conversation with Mr. Comey in which the director asked to have the meeting and the question of loyalty never came up. It was not clear whether he was talking about the same meal, but they are believed to have had only one dinner together.
That’s far different that the White House’s initial account in the hours after Mr. Comey’s firing. Multiple officials, including Mr. Pence, said the president was acting at the behest of Mr. Rosenstein — who reportedly threatened to resign over the way the Comey dismissal was attributed in part to the memo he wrote — and Attorney General Jeff Sessions.
But it quickly became clear that the president had been stewing for days over the Russia investigation and Mr. Comey’s refusal to defend him in appearances before lawmakers. By Wednesday afternoon, the officials, like Mr. Trump, were saying he had in fact been considering ousting the FBI director for months because of a lack of confidence in his ability to lead the agency.
And the Russia investigation was still on his mind.
“In fact when I decided to just do it, I said to myself, I said you know, this Russia thing with Trump and Russia is a made-up story, it’s an excuse by the Democrats for having lost an election that they should have won,” he said.
Ms. Sanders attributed the disconnect in the week’s explanations to the fact that she had not directly asked Mr. Trump when he’d made the decision to fire Mr. Comey until shortly before Thursday’s press briefing.
The White House tried to move past the controversy, announcing that the president had signed an executive order creating a voter fraud commission and another on cybersecurity. Mr. Trump signed the orders privately and was not seen in public apart from his TV interview with NBC.
Mr. Trump had kept his decision to fire Mr. Comey from all but his closest advisers. Many in the White House were ill-prepared for the outraged response from Democrats and open concern from some Republicans.
“The challenge they have is that the president sometimes moves so rapidly that they don’t get a team around that gets it organized,” said Newt Gingrich, the former House speaker and a Trump ally. “They need to decide what they’re going to say and they need to stick with it. Random change isn’t helpful.”
White House officials and others insisted on anonymity in order to disclose private conversations and internal deliberations.
The White House said Mr. Trump is weighing options for replacing Mr. Comey, a decision that could have broad implications for the future of the Russia investigation.
Some senior officials have discussed nominating Rep. Trey Gowdy, the South Carolina Republican who ran the House committee that investigated then-Secretary of State Clinton’s actions in connection with the 2012 attack on a U.S. compound in Benghazi, Libya.
Mr. Trump’s advisers have repeatedly tried to downplay the Russia-election matter, with Ms. Sanders saying Wednesday the FBI was “doing a whole lot more than the Russia investigation.”
But Mr. McCabe characterized the investigation as “highly significant” and assured senators Mr. Comey’s firing would not hinder it.
“You cannot stop the men and women of the FBI from doing the right thing,” he declared. He said there has been no White House interference so far.
Days before he was fired, Mr. Comey requested more resources to pursue his investigation, U.S. officials have said. Mr. McCabe said he was not aware of any such request and said the Russia investigation is adequately resourced.
It was unclear whether word of the Comey request, said to have been put to Mr. Rosenstein, ever made its way to Mr. Trump.
The chairman and top Democrat on the Senate intelligence committee abruptly left the hearing Thursday to meet with Mr. Rosenstein, who is Mr. McCabe’s boss. The senators said later that the Russia investigations were discussed but Mr. Comey’s firing was not.
The New York Times and CQ-Roll Call contributed.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.