Third-party candidates pride themselves on overturning the bipartisan consensus. And Green Party presidential candidate Jill Stein may yet overturn the consensus that this excruciating presidential election is finally over.
No need to thank her.
“[T]he unexpected results of the election and reported anomalies need to be investigated before the 2016 presidential election is certified,” Ms. Stein said in a Wednesday statement seeking a recount of votes in Pennsylvania, Wisconsin and Michigan. “We deserve elections we can trust.”
It’s not that Ms. Stein believes she won. Her campaign is seeking a recount because “we do not have confidence in the integrity of the election results,” said campaign manager David Cobb in a Facebook address Wednesday. “Cyber experts have shown us that it is absolutely possible to hack these systems. ... It is our hope that we are able to literally get our hands on [voting machines] to find out whether or not we can have confidence in the reported results.”
The campaign launched an online fundraising effort on Wednesday seeking $2.5 million by Friday evening and as of Thanksgiving afternoon, Ms. Stein had raised just over $3.7 million toward a newly updated goal of $4.5 million, according to a tracker on her campaign website. She needs the funds to post bonds necessary for the recounts. The deadline for contesting Pennsylvania’s election results is Monday.
The effort follows a report, published in New York magazine Tuesday, that some election lawyers and computer experts suspect election returns “may have been manipulated or hacked” in the three Rust Belt states. In some areas, they detected a pattern in which Democrat Hillary Clinton fared worse in precincts where votes were recorded electronically, without a paper trail to confirm the digital record is correct.
Two-thirds of Pennsylvania counties, including vote-rich Allegheny and Philadelphia, use such paper-free machines. Experts have demonstrated such machines can be hacked even without being hooked up to the internet. As the Post-Gazette reported in September, many have worried that Pennsylvania, a crucial battleground, could be especially prone to hacking fears as a result.
Adding to such fears this year have been widely publicized hacks of Democratic Party email servers, and apparent efforts to penetrate state voter-registration databases.
The basis for this week’s concerns, however, appear to be purely circumstantial. One of the experts in the magazine report, University of Michigan computer scientist J. Alex Halderman, wrote separately that machines had “probably not” been hacked, but the only way to be sure was “to closely examine the available physical evidence.”
Mr. Halderman and others reportedly urged the Clinton campaign to press for recounts this week. The campaign has so far declined, and Democrats seemed dubious about the notion on Wednesday.
“If there were something to do here, there are a lot of us who would be jumping on it,” said Adam Bonin, a Philadelphia election law attorney who represents Democrats.
Mr. Bonin said that while every election has “little hitches and glitches, I haven’t seen anything which would cause me to question the results.” Nor, he said, “have I ever seen evidence that would lead me to call the machines into question.”
“I’m sympathetic to the notion that we should move to a system where there is a more auditable balloting process,” he said. But “You can’t just go on a fishing expedition. You have to have allegations of specific fraud, or machines that didn’t accept votes.”
On Facebook, Mr. Cobb told followers that “there were some pretty significant anomalies” on Election Day, although he didn’t identify where they took place.
Carl Romanelli, the Stein campaign’s Pennsylvania field coordinator, said he wasn’t aware of such problems here.
“I haven’t spoken with party representatives about complaints that may have come in,” he said. But “voter integrity is one of our huge issues, and the Stein campaign appears to be taking the lead on making sure the public can trust its elections.”
“I don’t want anyone to get the impression that this is about affecting the outcome of the election,” he added.
It’s highly unlikely that a recount would do so in Pennsylvania, where President-elect Donald Trump leads by roughly 70,000 votes. When the Greens joined a challenge of Ohio’s 2004 presidential results, the recount narrowed George W. Bush’s win by only about 300 votes.
But Audrey Glickman, the secretary-treasurer of VoteAllegheny, said a challenge would be “a good thing.” The group has long pressed for the adoption of “optical scanner” machines, in which voters mark preferences on ballots that are scanned by machine and retained for verification.
“We’re glad people are focusing on this,” Ms. Glickman said. “At the same time, I worry that if Trump comes out as the winner, people will say these concerns aren’t real. We need to have a ballot that the voter knows is correct and stuffed into a box, where it can be checked.”
Chris Potter: cpotter@post-gazette.com or 412-263-2533.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.