WASHINGTON — One of the longest-running streaks on Capitol Hill is seen as poised to keep going strong when all the ballots are counted in House races after Tuesday’s elections.

The Senate majority is viewed as only slightly less stable than the House, having changed hands once, in 1980, during a presidential year since the Eisenhower days. Even as Donald Trump appears to have some momentum in the presidential race, the GOP’s odds of holding the Senate have been seen as diminishing — at least somewhat.

Not since 1952, when Dwight D. “Ike” Eisenhower swept into the presidency and brought with him a Republican-controlled House, has the majority changed hands when Americans also elect a president. Instead, ever since, the House majority has only changed parties during midterm elections, beginning two years after Eisenhower’s victory, with the Democrats’ wave in 1954 that gave them a majority until the historic 1994 Republican wave during Bill Clinton’s first midterm election. The other party-changing moments, 2006 and 2010, also came in midterms.

And despite the most volatile presidential election in decades, the outcome in the House increasingly looks as if it will leave House Speaker Paul Ryan, R-Wis., with a slightly more narrow majority to navigate.

Advertise with us

The two most trusted, independent analysts — the Cook Political Report and the Rothenberg & Gonzales Political Report — have estimated that more than enough Republican-held seats are in play to give Democrats a chance at the majority. Cook’s analysis, overseen by David Wasserman, rates 40 Republican seats as competitive. Nathan Gonzales, running the Rothenberg analysis, puts about 35 Republican seats in play.

Democrats need a 30-seat gain for the majority, and if this were truly a wave election year, it wouldn’t be a stretch for them to win nearly every competitive race along with a few unexpected seats and claim the majority — that’s what happens in political waves.

But Mr. Wasserman and Mr. Gonzales conclude that the political undertow of Mr. Trump’s candidacy is mostly unique to his own brand. “The presidential race may be inducing whiplash, but the House battleground remains relatively stable in the final week,” Mr. Wasserman wrote. He gives Democrats a top level of netting 20 additional seats — but also an equal chance of just single-digit gains.

Mr. Gonzales’s last report gave Democrats a chance at gaining 15 seats, but also suggested single-digit gains were just as likely. (Mr. Gonzales’ former partner, Stuart Rothenberg, founded that report and now writes for The Washington Post.)

If these predictions hold up, House Republicans will end up in roughly the same shape as four years ago, when their 2012 nominee, Mitt Romney, presented a much more appealing figure in key swing districts than Mr. Trump does today. Back then, the GOP ended up with 234 seats.

Advertise with us

There are plenty of factors behind the Republican resiliency in these House races, but the biggest factor might just be an odd quirk among swing voters: They only tend to break sharply against one party’s congressional incumbents if the lawmakers are directly tied to an unpopular president.

That’s why midterm elections, over the last 25 years, have produced the biggest swings from one party to the other, like the 30 seats Democrats gained in the “six-year itch” midterm of George W. Bush’s presidency.

President Barack Obama’s first election in 2008 produced a large Democratic gain, of 21 seats, but his party already held majority and was just running up the score. The more normal result is the eight-seat gain Democrats made in 2012, which still left them 17 seats shy of the majority.

In both 1996 and 2000 the minority leader, Richard Gephardt, D-Mo., thought he had a chance at claiming the speaker’s gavel, but in each instance Democrats picked up fewer than five seats. Most agonizing of all was 2000, when Mr. Gephardt needed to win just six more Democratic seats to win. His party gained just two more districts, leaving the Republicans with a 221-seat majority, the smallest majority since the mid-1950s.

The most likely scenario for the House majority to switch hands during a presidential cycle seems to be when the party holding the White House also runs Capitol Hill, and that party loses the top-of-the-ticket race and craters down-ballot races. That’s what happened in 1952 when Eisenhower’s Republicans took charge after 20 years of Roosevelt-Truman run in the Oval Office.

Advertise with us

Mr. Trump would seem to be the perfect presidential nominee for House Democrats. House Minority Leader Nancy Pelosi, D-Calif., often calls him the “gift that keeps on giving” because of his intemperate remarks toward women and minorities as well as policy proposals that traditional Republicans consider dangerous.

Yet there seem to be limits to the gifts that Mr. Trump can give. Strategists in both parties privately say Democrats lack that dynamic today and that Mr. Trump’s sometimes outlandish statements make him so unique that it makes it more difficult to connect his views to others. Many Republican seats are also safe due to recent redistricting decisions regardless of who is at the top of the ticket.

The Democratic Congressional Campaign Committee made a concerted push to field as many candidates as possible in suburban districts with high education levels, because those voters have been the most offended by Mr. Trump’s candidacy. Strategists believe that the declining amount of ticket-splitting would give Democrats a chance to win in places that seemed previously out of reach.

It has worked in limited fashion. The DCCC has put longtime GOP incumbents, such as Reps. Darrell Issa of California and John Mica of Florida, on the defensive like never before, in suburban districts that have turned away from Mr. Trump.

Meanwhile, younger Republicans in districts breaking heavily against Mr. Trump are still in the fight, such as Rep. Bob Dold, R-Ill., who represents the suburbs north of Chicago. Hillary Clinton is poised to win the district by more than 20 percentage points, according to both party estimates, maybe even 30 percentage points, but the DCCC has not put this race away and is spending feverishly down the stretch to win it.

Advertise with us

The problem seems to be many of those well educated suburban voters don’t believe their representatives, such as Barbara Comstock, R-Va., and Mike Coffman, R-Colo., are the same as Mr. Trump. Democrats have run relentless ads linking those two Republicans to Mr. Trump, and some Democrats believe that Mr. Trump has been a gateway to get voters to pay attention to positions taken by these Republicans that are more conservative than these swing districts would normally support.

Republicans privately concede those Trump attacks have done some damage to their candidates, but it’s mostly just energized liberal voters there. The independent-minded voter working in the Dulles Corridor IT sector, or in the eastern suburbs of Denver, has yet to be convinced that voting for Ms. Comstock and Mr. Coffman is a vote for Mr. Trump.

This could be bad news for House Democrats. A Hillary Clinton presidency might mean a bad 2018 midterm for them, digging the party deeper into the minority. And, as history shows, the presidential year of 2020 isn’t likely to produce a new House majority either, making it possible that their next real shot at the majority could be six years away — if Republicans hold the Oval Office by then.

In the Senate, the GOP’s effort to hold that chamber has always been a tough slog, even if it remained competitive at the top of the ballot. And sure enough, despite Mr. Trump not appearing to have dragged down his fellow Republicans too much (if at all), the GOP finds itself with what is seen as an increasingly uphill battle to retain the Senate, with a handful of days left.

On Thursday, some of the “toss-up” Senate races were viewed as getting a little friendlier for Democrats.

Advertise with us

Starting with Pennsylvania. Democrat Katie McGinty has led in the past nine polls here — including by 3 to 6 points in a trio of good polls released this week.

It’s seen as a little more difficult to push this into the light-blue column, though, for a couple of reasons: 1) Republican Sen. Pat Toomey has the advantages of incumbency, and 2) the presidential race here is tightening. And sure enough, a poll out Thursday from Quinnipiac University has him within 1 point — his closest result in 10 polls.

The second seat that is looking tough for the GOP is Nevada. Public polling there remains very competitive; Republican Rep. Joe Heck even led in one poll — from CNN — this week, and he was up by 7 points in an NBC-Wall Street Journal-Marist poll last week.

But Republicans, Democrats and those watching the race closely feel as if this one nominally favors Democrats and former Nevada attorney general Catherine Cortez Masto right now. It’s a state where Mr. Trump appears to be losing ground, and Democrats have done very well in all-important early voting — about on par with how they did in 2012, when Mr. Obama won the state by 6 points.

Of course, it bears noting that in that same 2012 election that Mr. Obama carried the state, appointed GOP Sen. Dean Heller also won, by 1 point. So it’s clear Mr. Heck still has a shot. But the numbers certainly don’t help him.

Advertise with us

Were Ms. Cortez Masto to win the seat, which retiring Senate Minority Leader Harry Reid is vacating, it would prevent Democrats from losing any seats in the 2016 election and make their path to a majority in the chamber significantly easier. From there, they would have to win only two of the five other seats we currently rate as “toss-ups,” or only one of the five if they can pull an upset and defeat Republican Sen. Marco Rubio in Florida, which we currently rate as “lean Republican” but is close.

The third “toss-up” seat that is giving Republicans heartburn right now is that of Sen. Roy Blunt, R-Mo. Two new high-quality, nonpartisan polls show Mr. Blunt leading Democratic Secretary of State Jason Kander by just 1 point. One of those polls even had Mr. Trump carrying the state by 14 points, and were Mr. Blunt to lose a state that Mr. Trump carried, it would be a particularly hard pill for the GOP to swallow.

It’s entirely possible that Republicans could still hold the Senate come Tuesday. But the races that are going to decide that just aren’t viewed as moving in the right direction for them right now.