Yes, OK, just about anything can happen this election. And sure, Donald Trump’s hopes depend on appealing to disaffected Pennsylvania Democrats. Even so, Gabe Kramer isn’t exactly a swing voter: He’s a registered Democrat in Squirrel Hill, one of the state’s most liberal enclaves. He’s also a union organizer whose wife, Erin, is a progressive activist.

So he was surprised to get a mailer — all the way from the New York Republican State Committee — urging him to support Donald Trump. The mailer laments failing schools and dangerous neighborhoods while warning, “Hillary won’t change a thing.”

“It talks about Trump ‘reigniting our cities,’ which, if you think about it, literally is a troubling message,” Mr. Kramer said. “When I got it, I wondered, ‘Why me? And why is it coming from New York?’”

“I’ve never seen that before,” Sam Hens-Greco, the Democratic ward chairman representing Mr. Kramer’s neighborhood, said of the out-of-state party mailing. Mr. Hens-Greco said he hadn’t received one but knew of another voter in his ward who had.

Advertise with us

Dave Scholnick was also surprised to get a mailer. He’s not just a registered Democrat but a South Philadelphia activist whose organization, For Pennsylvania’s Future, aids efforts to elect Ms. Clinton.

“My area of Philadelphia is home to African-Americans, Hispanics — a lot of immigrants,” he said. “It’s absolutely not a hotbed of Trump support.”

They were among several loyal Democrats who told the Post-Gazette this week that they, and some of their friends, were mystified to receive the mailers. Some had supported onetime Clinton rival Bernie Sanders, whose backers Mr. Trump has at times reached out to. But others said they hadn’t backed the Vermont senator.

“It seems like a colossal waste of money," said Anne Lynch, manager of operations at Three Rivers Community Foundation, which supports progressive causes.

New York Republican Party officials did not respond to phone calls. But on Friday, two New York papers reported that the committee planned to send mailings to swing states including Ohio and Iowa. The committee is reportedly paying for the mailers through an account that can be used for federal races, as part of an agreement with the Trump campaign and other party organizations.

Advertise with us

Megan Sweeney, a spokeswoman for the Pennsylvania Republican Party, said that “in order to streamline the process [of reaching out to voters], the New York State Party has taken a primary role in helping the Trump-Pence ticket in this area.”

“We’re putting on a full-court press,” said Pennsylvania Republican Party chairman Rob Gleason, who also got a New York mailer.

There’s no law against one party mailing into an adjoining state, said Catherine Hinckley Kelley, state and local reform program director at the nonpartisan Campaign Legal Center. “We all know Pennsylvania is a key state for this election,” she added. “I’m not necessarily surprised that there is money from other states.”

But based on the seemingly wayward targeting, say some political pros, the money may not be getting spent wisely here.

“I would say it was a massive screw-up,” said Don Friedman, a political consultant whose firm, Professional Records, specializes in direct mail. “It just doesn’t make sense to send this from New York. As soon as someone sees where it’s coming from, that’s the question.”

Advertise with us

Consultants who spoke with the Post-Gazette agreed that while targeting infrequent Democratic voters could be a viable strategy, sending letters to faithful Democratic voters in urban bastions made much less sense.

Not that Mr. Friedman, a Democrat, is complaining. “The more money [Republicans] waste,” he said, “the happier I am.”

Chris Potter: cpotter@post-gazette.com or 412-263-2533. Rich Lord contributed.