It has been almost 30 years since the Senate rejected a nominee to the U.S. Supreme Court, but with President Barack Obama promising to nominate a replacement for the late Justice Antonin Scalia, Republicans may be spoiling for a fight.
Of the 160 individuals who have been nominated to the Supreme Court, only 12 have been rejected by the Senate, which has the constitutional role of approving the president’s choice. In the past 86 years, only four nominees have been turned away. However, in the last three of those four, the president was a Republican and the Senate was controlled by the Democrats.
This year, as Mr. Obama prepares to send a nomination to the Republican-controlled Senate, those roles are reversed, and the stage is set for some contentious payback.
‘’The Republicans should go through the interview process and move to a vote,’’ said James Roddey, chairman of the Allegheny County Republican Party. ‘’The Democrats showed the way in putting nominees through torture. It’s hypocritical for them to say the president should have whomever he wants on the Court. Perhaps the nominee will be someone the Republicans will like. But the Democrats have shown that rejection is part of the process. They’ve legitimized that.’’
Like so many bitter arguments, it’s hard to tell who started it. Some observers trace the acrimonious process back to 1968 when Republican senators thwarted, via a Senate filibuster, President Lyndon B. Johnson’s lame-duck attempt to appoint his friend, Associate Justice Abe Fortas, as the court’s chief justice.
In the next two years, after Mr. Fortas stepped down because of a financial scandal, the Democrats in the Senate rejected two of President Richard M. Nixon’s nominees to replace him — Clement Haynsworth Jr. and G. Harrold Carswell.
Read More
Mr. Haynsworth and Mr. Carswell were both judges from the South with spotty records on labor and race-related rulings. Mr. Haynsworth, of South Carolina, also was targeted for financial conflict of interest charges as the Senate rejected him on a vote of 55-45 on Nov. 21, 1969.
Mr. Nixon then nominated Mr. Carswell of Florida, who had the additional burden of being targeted by women’s groups for some of his past rulings. His competency also was criticized. It didn’t help when Sen. Roman Hruska, a Nebraska Republican, tried to defend him by famously saying, “Even if he is mediocre, there are a lot of mediocre judges and people and lawyers. They are entitled to a little representation, aren’t they, and a little chance?”
After Mr. Carswell was rejected by a 51-45 vote on April 8,1970, Senate Republican Leader Hugh Scott, of Pennsylvania, said Mr. Carswell was a racist and that his support of him had been “a damn fool thing” to do.
‘Borked’
Regardless of how the back-and-forth started, it was the Democratic Senate of 1987, led by Sen. Edward M. Kennedy of Massachusetts, that turned confrontational vetting into a martial art with the historic take-down of Robert H. Bork, who grew up in Squirrel Hill.
Nominated by President Ronald Reagan, the ultra-conservative Mr. Bork was a controversial choice because of his role as acting Attorney General in the famed “Saturday Night Massacre” late in the Nixon administration. He also had a judicial legacy of endorsing the president’s executive authority, which did little to sway the senators considering him.
Within hours of his nomination, Mr. Kennedy took to the floor of the Senate, where he denounced Mr. Bork for opposing the Civil Rights Act of 1964 and his “Neanderthal” views.
“Robert Bork’s America,” he said, “is a land in which women would be forced into back-alley abortions, blacks would sit at segregated lunch counters, rogue police could break down citizens’ doors in midnight raids, and schoolchildren could not be taught about evolution, writers and artists could be censored at the whim of government, and the doors of the federal courts would be shut on the fingers of millions of citizens for whom the judiciary is — and is often the only — protector of the individual rights that are at the heart of our democracy.”
Mr. Bork, who watched the speech in a White House office, called it ”an assault more violent than any against a judicial nominee in our country’s history.”
Mr. Kennedy’s attacks on Mr. Bork proved effective, sparking a letter-writing campaign and protest rallies across the country, including an August 1987 rally in Downtown Pittsburgh in which speakers challenged Mr. Bork’s competence and character.
Sen. Joseph R. Biden Jr. of Delaware, then chairman of the Senate Judiciary Committee, was running for president at the time and, despite having once said he could support Mr. Bork, changed his tone.
In remarks that might now be considered prophetic, Mr. Biden said, ”We are once again confronted with a popular president’s determined attempt to bend the Supreme Court to his political ends. No one should dispute his right to try. But no one should dispute the Senate’s duty to respond.”
Mr. Bork was blocked by a bipartisan vote of 58-42 on Oct. 23, 1987, and the speed and intensity of the defeat gave rise to the expression of being “Borked.”
“Bork was a turning point,” said Michael Comiskey, an associate professor of political science at Penn State University Fayette and author of the book “Seeking Justices: The Judging of Supreme Court Nominees.”
“We had seen partisan politics before, but not in so bald a form. That was a case where the president threw down the gauntlet, where he challenged the Senate. He made that nomination knowing that he faced a Democratic Senate and that there would be a firestorm. He provoked the Senate.”
The changing tone
Justice Clarence Thomas, nominated to the top court in 1991 by President George H.W. Bush, endured a bitter and brutal confirmation process involving accusations of sexual harassment. Mindful of the treatment of Mr. Bork, he resisted detailed answers to senators’ questions and called the proceedings “a circus.”
“It’s a national disgrace,” he said, describing the experience as “a high-tech lynching.” Still, he was confirmed 52-48, the closest margin in more than a century.
Since then, nominees put forth by Republican and Democratic presidents alike have gone before the Senate prepared for a grilling. They are careful, concise and courteous in their answers. Perhaps it’s no coincidence that it’s been almost three decades since a nominee was rejected. And only once in the last 86 years, when Republican President Herbert Hoover nominated John J. Parker to the Supreme Court, did the Senate reject their own party’s nominee.
Mr. Comiskey said he has no problem with the contentious vetting of nominees, providing that the scrutiny is legitimate. The 21st-century Senate is not limited to considering only whether a judge is fair and capable. A nominee’s ideology is fair game, he said.
“Presidents consider ideology, so why shouldn’t the senators?” he said. “If they don’t do that, they can’t check and balance the president, as they’re supposed to. I don’t see anything wrong with it. It’s a big fight, and they have a right to wage that fight. If there’s a problem, it’s better to find out sooner rather than later.”
Ken Gormley, dean of the Duquesne School of Law and president-in-waiting at the university, said it is unlikely that Mr. Obama’s nominee will experience anything so grueling.
“Robert Bork is not an apt example,” he said. “By all accounts, he was an extremely conservative, polarizing figure, whether you liked him or didn’t like him. The better lesson to be learned from that experience is that President Reagan eventually appointed Anthony Kennedy, who was a centrist. That tells us more.
“President Obama tends to be measured. He’s taking this seriously, he’s going to care about this. He knows the best chance of getting a confirmation is by sticking to the middle. Even though he gives up something by doing that, it’s a good solution, given that it’s his last year in office.”
Nancy Mills, chairwoman of the Allegheny County Democratic Party, said she wouldn’t be surprised to see the hearings devolve into bloodsport. “It’s going to be up to [the Senate],” she said. “But I look at what they’ve done to President Obama throughout his whole term, and I would expect it to be contentious and ugly. ... I look at the current atmosphere in Washington, not based on history but based on what I’ve seen, and I think it could be an unattractive procedure.”
Mr. Comiskey, however, predicted Mr. Obama’s choice is unlikely to be too controversial.
“I don’t think we’re likely to see a nominee with a highly questionable past here. Obama will be very careful who he nominates,” he said. “And I think the current political considerations will outweigh any desire the Senate may have for payback, however real that may be. … Everyone has a strong incentive to behave smartly and credibly.”
Dan Majors: dmajors@post-gazette.com and 412-263-1456.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.