Nearly every day in U.S. District Court here and in courthouses across the country, judges send drug dealers to the nation’s federal prisons, often for long sentences far from home.
The federal prison population stands at more than 200,000 compared to about 25,000 three decades ago, largely due to tough terms originally mandated to combat the cocaine scourge in the 1980s and ’90s.
But a movement has been afoot in recent years, pushed in part by the Justice Department under former Attorney General Eric Holder, to reduce those numbers and the related costs.
On Thursday it gained traction when a group of bipartisan senators unveiled a bill to reduce federal time for low-level drug offenders.
A deal struck among conservatives and liberals and spearheaded by Sen. Charles Grassley, R-Iowa, chairman of the Senate Judiciary Committee, would give judges more discretion to sentence below the mandatory minimum for “nonviolent” offenders.
Inmates deemed unlikely to re-offend could see their sentences reduced by a quarter of their time if they successfully complete rehabilitation programs.
The bill would also eliminate mandatory life terms for three-time offenders if their crimes did not involve violence.
In announcing the bill, called the Sentencing Reform and Corrections Act, Sen. Grassley said it addresses the problem of “over-incarceration” while still targeting violent criminals and leaders of drug gangs.
He wasn’t available for comment on the specifics, but his communications director, Beth Pellett Levine, said the bill will benefit those inmates who were lower level offenders and “kind of got caught up” in drug prosecutions.
It’s not clear how many defendants fit that category, at least in Western Pennsylvania. The U.S. attorney’s office in Pittsburgh declined comment.
But most drug defendants prosecuted here are typically part of a larger network of traffickers, often with long criminal pasts that include violence or the threat of it. Although some ring members might be couriers without a history of directly hurting anyone, they are still part of gangs that do hurt people. And prosecutors here almost never indict for simple possession unless they are trying to induce someone to cooperate.
Currently judges must honor the mandatory minimums for repeat offenders, but the new bill would allow them to waive it in cases where an inmate faces a mandatory 10-year prison term. Judges could also make exceptions for defendants with a criminal history that is not deemed “serious,” although determining what’s serious and what isn’t would be open for debate.
Another complicating factor that concerns some prosecutors is that major drug dealers are often smart enough not to have criminal records or get caught with a gun precisely because they know the potential federal prison time would be heavy. Under the new bill, it’s possible that a sophisticated dealer with no criminal record might get an unearned break.
Still, civil rights groups who have long championed sentencing reform applauded the measure.
“America is ready and desperately needs a massive overhaul of its criminal justice laws and policies, and Congress has finally decided to show up at the party,” said Anthony Romero, executive director of the American Civil Liberties Union.
Holly Harris, executive director of U.S. Justice Action Network, said the federal system is finally catching up with many states, including Texas, Georgia and South Carolina, that have taken similar measures.
“It’s a really comprehensive bill,” she said. “We can all take a step back today and realize how remarkable it is that we are in this time and place.”
Another group, the Washington-based Leadership Conference on Civil and Human Rights, said the bill will reform 30 years of “tough on crime” sentencing that in its view has created an “unjust system” that imprisons more people, especially blacks and hispanics, than any other country in the world.
The bill would apply only to nonviolent drug offenders. Violent criminals, sex offenders, organized crime figures, white-collar criminals and anyone convicted of terrorism-related charges are not covered.
While the federal justice system handles all manner of crimes, from bank robbery to complex tax fraud, about half of the caseload involves drug dealing of one type or another. Some 95,000 federal inmates were prosecuted under the drug statutes.
Most of the drug cases seen in federal court in Pittsburgh are targeted efforts by the FBI, U.S. Drug Enforcement Administration, IRS and other agencies to pursue large-scale narcotics rings, particularly heroin dealers in recent years. Many of those cases involve dealers bringing drugs here from Detroit, New Jersey and California, and they often involve firearms offenses.
One such case going on for the last week before U.S. District Judge Cathy Bissoon, for example, is a trial of several reputed members of the “Uptown Crew,” a violent drug gang in Homestead supplied from New Jersey. When prosecutors announced the indictments against some 34 ring members in 2013, they said one of the reasons they brought the case was to combat shootings in Homestead and the surrounding area that were attributed to the gang’s drug-dealing.
The law would allow the judge to reduce penalties for some repeat offenders who otherwise would get automatic time. And it would allow inmates who are determined to be at low risk for recidivism to have their sentences cut by 10 days for every 30 days they participate in a rehab program.
Sen. Grassley and his co-sponsors said the bill is not only about more leniency, however.
In some cases, it calls for tougher penalties, including expanded mandatory minimum sentences for some offenses involving guns, and it would create new mandatory minimums for crimes related to terrorism.
Torsten Ove: tove@post-gazette.com.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.