WASHINGTON -- There's a storyline in professional wrestling that gets recycled every few years: Two best friends, often tag-team partners, are forced to fight each other in the ring.

This week, Democratic Congressmen and good friends Jason Altmire and Mark Critz could face the political equivalent. Their two districts are likely to be redrawn into one, forcing the duo to battle over one Congressional seat in next year's election.

A population shift will cost Pennsylvania a Congressional seat in 2012. Republicans in control of the state government get to draw the district map, and the result could force one of the two Democrats out of office, as in 2002 when Republicans pitted Democratic Reps. Frank Mascara and John Murtha against each other. Mr. Murtha defeated Mr. Mascara in the primary.

"We're friends," said Mr. Altmire, whose McCandless district neighbors Mr. Critz's turf in Johnstown. "We've known for a year this is going to happen. It was pretty obvious that Western PA is where the seat was going to be lost."

Advertise with us

Mr. Altmire helped Mr. Critz campaign for office in last year's special election to replace the late Mr. Murtha. The pair went on the campaign trail together, including a visit to Mr. Altmire's hometown of Lower Burrell, located in Mr. Critz's district.

But voters in the 2012 election might see the two stumping against each other, instead. Legislators in Harrisburg are expected to release the new district map this week.

"We're always thinking about it," said Mr. Critz. "But you can't get hung up on it because you can't get any control of the process. I haven't really been doing anything concerning possibly running against Jason, just because I'm still hopeful that it may not come to pass."

Both moderates sided against Democrats to extend the Patriot Act and to pass the 2011 budget. Mr. Altmire voted against President Barack Obama's health care bill, and Mr. Critz said he would have voted against it had he been in office at the time.

But it's their differences, not similarities, that will determine the winner in a primary election, said G. Terry Madonna, director of the Center for Politics and Public Policy at Franklin and Marshall College in Lancaster.

Advertise with us

"The question they face is how do they remain traditional blue dogs but differentiate themselves from each other -- that's the key. They must do that," he said. "Eventually, they're going to have to make an argument as to what extent they support the president's agenda."

The duo will have plenty of chances over the next 11 months to show where they stand on the most polarizing parts of the White House agenda. Congress will likely vote on provisions from Mr. Obama's jobs bill, the extension of unemployment benefits and a Social Security tax cut.

"This year's going to be filled with those kinds of issues," Mr. Madonna said. "This year, there's no middle ground to run to."

Mr. Critz said he hasn't planned for the 2012 election yet, but hinted that he might look for another Congressional district to avoid a confrontation with Mr. Altmire.

"Hopefully when the maps come out, a decision will be easy to make and we can avert a Democratic primary election," Mr. Critz said. "We'll have to sit down to figure out what the best plan of attack is to represent the constituents we've been representing and take it from there."

Advertise with us

Mr. Critz's hope to avoid an election against his friend might also have to do with his war chest. Mr. Altmire has nearly twice as much cash-on-hand as his colleague, according to Federal Election Commission data. Mr. Altmire has $736,939 cash and no debt; Mr. Critz has $422,616 cash on hand and a $15,736 debt.

If a primary contest does occur, however, both candidates are prepared to court the region's moderate Democrats. Among all 435 members of Congress, only one voted with his party less often than Mr. Altmire, who sided with Democrats 56 percent of the time.

Only 16 Democrats broke party lines to vote with Republicans more often than Mr. Critz, who sided with his Democrats 74 percent of the time.

On hot-button votes, the Congressmen have disagreed on two occasions. Mr. Critz voted with Republicans against the repeal of Don't Ask, Don't Tell, while Mr. Altmire supported reform. Conversely, Mr. Altmire sided with Republicans to support a balanced budget amendment, while Mr. Critz voted to block it.

"The election will come down to pointing out their differences," Mr. Madonna said. "They have to do this."

Advertise with us

If the district map is drawn the way both candidates expect -- and fear -- then the candidates will endure a struggle between their desire for re-election and their affection toward each other.

"I think Mark feels the same way about this: I am not going to talk about Mark's record," Mr. Altmire said. "I'm just going to continue, in the campaign, to reinforce the things I've done and what my vision is for the future, and I would expect Mark would take a similar approach. I'm not going try to distinguish who I am from who he is."