MORGANTOWN, W.Va. -- Earl Ray Tomblin, West Virginia's acting governor, gets to drop the "acting" from his title after holding off a challenge from Republican businessman Bill Maloney.
Mr. Tomblin, a 36-year veteran of the Legislature, leveraged his own deep roots in the state's politics along with the support of its business and labor establishments to secure the job he has held since his predecessor, Joe Manchin, resigned to take the Senate seat he won in yet another special election last year.
"Tonight's result is proof that West Virginians appreciate ideas, they value experience and they want our state to continue to move forward," he told supporters in Charleston.
Mr. Tomblin prevailed despite a last minute effort by Republicans to nationalize the race with ads tying the incumbent to President Barack Obama and the administration's health care legislation.
"We all came together to tell outside groups that no one is going to tell us what to do in West Virginia," Mr. Tomblin said shortly after a ritual call of concession from the Morgantown businessman who had closed a double digit polling gap to make it a competitive race.
"West Virginia may be open for business but it's not for sale," Mr. Tomblin said.
Exactly what larger message the numbers contained was far from clear after a race that had, for most of its time, largely focused on state-specific issues and produced a voter turnout far short of what can be expected in a presidential year. And while West Virginia voters give Mr. Obama low approval ratings, that was also true three years ago, when the state bucked the national trend in giving Sen. John McCain its electoral votes in a landslide.
Mr. Tomblin, 59, is a 36-year veteran of the Legislature who succeeded Mr. Manchin after he was elected to fill the balance of the Senate term of the state's late political patriarch, Robert Byrd. He enjoyed the support of a wide array of the state's interest groups, with endorsements from the West Virginia Coal Association, the UMW, the Chamber of Commerce and the AFL-CIO.
Mr. Maloney, 53, a Lehigh University graduate, was making his first run for office. The businessman earned headlines away from politics as an architect of the celebrated 2010 rescue of 33 Chilean miners. He built his campaign on calls to modernize the economy and traditionally lagging income and education statistics.
But the rising price of coal has boosted the state's economy, giving it a lower unemployment rate than the nation at large and allowing Mr. Tomblin to boast of a state budget surplus in contrast to the fiscal straits of some of its neighbors.
For much of the campaign, the rhetoric focused on state issues, but in the final week, Republicans labored to shift the focus to Washington, with ads that portrayed Mr. Tomblin as an ally of Mr. Obama, faulting him in particular for refusing to join the multi-state litigation against the administration's health care legislation.
Mr. Tomblin's ally and predecessor, Mr. Manchin, decried that tactic in a radio interview Tuesday morning.
"The bottom line is that this should be about West Virginia," he told MetroNews. "[State residents] are going to have a chance to vote for or against the president in 2012. That's fine, you'll have that chance."
Whatever the real motivation of voters here, a Maloney victory would almost inevitably have been seen as one more rebuff to the White House after a pair of Democratic defeats in recent U.S. House special elections.
Jay Carney, the White House press secretary, warned against over-interpreting the results in a national context.
"However it comes out, special elections are special, and they're often not indicative of any greater trend," he said, according to a transcript of his regular briefing hours before the polls closed. "And I think a good example of that is the fact that the Democrats won -- I think swept the special elections leading up to the 2010 midterms ... it tends not to mean anything either way. It can be very specific to the state or district, and the fact that turnout is extremely low."
The candidates may not have much time to recover from the campaign as the next race for the state's top job is just a year away and could feature a rematch of yesterday's contenders.
As he accepted congratulations and condolences from supporters, Mr. Maloney said it was too early to think about that possibility.
Three minor party candidates, Bob Henry Baber, Marla Ingels and Harry Bertram, were also on the ballot. Their combined support nearly equaled the margin between the two main contenders, though it is not likely that their presence on the ballot tipped the results.
Mr. Maloney, a political newcomer, faced a 30-point deficit shortly after the spring primary. By last month, according to a survey by Public Policy Polling, he was within six points of the eventual winner and over the weekend had closed the polling gap to a single point. The unusual date for the special election came after the state Supreme Court ruled that a acting governor should not serve for more than a year, as opposed to finishing the balance of Mr. Manchin's original term.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.