On one stretch of Route 422 in Armstrong County, an eastbound driver goes through the 3rd Congressional District, into the 12th, back into the 3rd and then back into 12th.

"In a span of 10 miles and never leaving one roadway ... you've changed congressional districts four times," Armstrong County's Dave Battaglia complained Thursday at a state hearing on congressional redistricting in Cranberry. "The 12th District is clearly drawn as irregular as any district in the United States."

A picture of the district lines drawn a decade ago for the late Democratic U.S. Rep. John Murtha, which slither across nine counties in southwestern Pennsylvania, could accompany the dictionary definition of "gerrymander." So speakers at the joint hearing called by state House and Senate committees drawing new lines heard repeatedly that the 12th and other districts should be simpler, and not leave parts of communities and counties on different sides.

In Indiana, officials have to work with 9th District U.S. Rep. Bill Shuster, R-Blair, when seeking federal help on the north side of the borough's Main Street, but once they cross the street, have to appeal to 12th District Rep. Mark Critz, D-Johnstown.

Advertise with us

Rodney D. Ruddock, chair of the Indiana County board of commissioners, pleaded with legislators to solve the problem, which he said "creates much confusion with our residents and can create difficulty in developing community grant proposals."

The joint committee hearing -- hosted by state Rep. Daryl Metcalfe, R-Cranberry -- heard similar messages from county commissioners and residents from Butler, Lawrence, Warren, Crawford and Armstrong counties at the two-hour session. This was the second of three joint public hearings by the House and Senate committees, following one in Philadelphia and another scheduled for Tuesday in Harrisburg.

Pennsylvania currently has 19 congressional districts, but after the results of the 2010 census, must cut the number by one. That means carving out 18 districts among the state's 67 counties that as closely as possible share the same number of constituents. The congressional lines are approved through state legislation -- agreed to by the Republican-controlled House and Senate and signed by GOP Gov. Tom Corbett -- so they are inevitably subject to political whims, too.

Mr. Metcalfe said the proposed lines would probably be unveiled at another public hearing in the fall. While some proposed maps have already been generated by redistricting experts, academics and others, Mr. Metcalfe and state Sen. Chuck McIlhinney, R-Bucks County, chair of the Senate government panel, said none had been drawn so far by legislators.

"A lot of criticism has been thrown our way on how we do this effort, but we are truly making an honest effort to be very fair and forthcoming in this process," Mr. McIlhinney said.

Advertise with us

Some speakers, such as Tom Porter, an Armstrong County GOP committeeman and former Post-Gazette reporter, were just as forthcoming with what they wanted -- in his case, not a Democratic congressman. His town of Goheenville fights fires with creek water, and has no streetlights or police. "If a burglar breaks in, we shoot him. If he gets up we shoot him again," Mr. Porter said.

"It would make no sense for an urban, suburban representative like Jason Altmire or Mark Critz to be representing us. We want a rural representative and we want Mike Kelly, and that's the way we want it," he said.

Mr. Porter's comments got the only applause of the two-hour hearing.