Two years after America voted overwhelmingly for change, polls, analysts and an angry election season suggest its voters are about to do so again.

Amid universal expectations of big Republican gains in Congress, Tuesday's balloting is also likely to tip the scales of power in states across the country, and with them, partisan prospects for the elections of 2012 and the balance of the century's second decade.

In Pennsylvania, the high-profile, high-spending races for governor and senator have been unavoidable to anyone with a television or radio. Both are at the top of the national parties' priorities. But in an election in which the GOP needs 39 seats to wrest the speaker's gavel from Nancy Pelosi, a spotlight has also cast Pennsylvania's U.S. House contests in sharp relief. In a chamber in which 90 percent of incumbents typically win re-election, nearly half of Pennsylvania's seats feature competitive contests.

A few rows below on the state's ballot are the battles for control of the closely divided state House. Those results will dictate the maneuvering room for a new governor, who will confront painful policy choices imposed by the state's bleak budget picture. They will also set the terms of the zero-sum game of congressional redistricting in a state facing the loss of one more congressional seat in a delegation that's been steadily shrinking for decades. Given those stakes, one expert rated the Pennsylvania House as one of the national Republican Party's top three legislative targets.

Advertise with us

The governor is, by most assessments, the most powerful public official in the state. Yet this year's race between Attorney General Tom Corbett and Allegheny County Executive Dan Onorato has often been overshadowed by attention to the battle to succeed Sen. Arlen Specter. When Gov. Ed Rendell and former Gov. Tom Ridge competed for their first terms, there was no Senate race competing for attention.

The winner of this contest will grapple with a state funding gap projected at between $2 billion and $5 billion. But the contenders have largely ceded the opportunity of engaging the public in a debate on the specifics of how they might navigate those fiscal straits. After a primary in which he faced opposition from his right flank from state Rep. Sam Rohrer, Mr. Corbett has ruled out tax increases of any description. Mr. Corbett has said he supports early education funding. Beyond that he has said that he will scrutinize state spending across the board. He branded as "despicable,'' an Onorato charge that that could mean cuts to programs to senior citizens. But his rebuttal did not include a blueprint of where cuts would fall.

Mr. Onorato has been nearly as reticent on his plans to deal with the multi-billion-dollar dilemma. But in one of the central policy differences of the campaign, he has supported a severance tax on natural gas drilling in the state's Marcellus Shale deposits. Mr. Onorato argues that a new levy at a rate competitive with other states is a prudent response to the environmental impact of drilling. Mr. Corbett contends that such a tax would stifle an infant industry.

The pair also disagrees on whether the state can afford more money for basic education. Mr. Corbett says that it cannot, at least for the immediate future. The Democrat contends that to hold the line on education in Harrisburg would inevitably translate to tax increases at the school district level.

With the exception of a brief stint as a township commissioner -- including a tax increase vote that his opponent has sought to exploit -- Mr. Corbett hasn't had to deal with such tough budget issues. His background as a prosecutor has also positioned him to profit from public outrage at Harrisburg. His most high-profile cases through his second term have been the Bonusgate prosecutions of legislative figures accused of misusing public money.

Advertise with us

Mr. Onorato sometimes questioned the timing and motivation of those prosecutions but that line of attack has been muted by his understandable reluctance to appear sympathetic to legislative abuses. Mr. Onorato's campaign rests on a narrative of urban renewal. During his time in office, the Pittsburgh region has rebounded, earning worldwide notice in the run-up to last year's G-20 summit. His county has suffered less than many in the current economic downturn. But its unemployment has increased, if less than other areas, making his campaign story tougher to tell.

The battle between two Allegheny County residents is one of 37 governor's races across the country this year. Currently, Democrats hold a modest edge in the governor's mansions, with 26 incumbents compared to 24 Republicans. GOP officials are optimistic of tipping that balance their way

The Pennsylvania Senate election has lacked the melodrama of so many statewide contests across the nation this year -- no witchcraft, no adultery, no head stomping or idol worship. What it has featured is a clear choice between two ideologically distinct candidates. Rep. Joe Sestak, a retired admiral, seized the Democratic nomination with a come-from-behind upset of Sen. Arlen Specter, the longest-serving senator in the state's history. That came after the candidacy of Pat Toomey, the former Republican congressman, forced Mr. Specter to switch parties.

In the pre-primary months, the current antagonists established an enemy-of-my-enemy-is-my-friend relationship. Their professed bonds of respect have since been strained as each has portrayed the other as an extremist enabler of Wall Street excess. Mr. Sestak incessantly reminds voters of Mr. Toomey's years as an investment banker. Mr. Toomey describes the Democrat as a Pelosi clone who came to Wall Street's aid by voting for the Bush administration's financial rescue plan, and following that with support for Obama initiatives from the stimulus to the health-care overhaul.

Mr. Toomey has tried to soften the packaging, if not the substance of his sharply conservative economic views. He made a point of voicing support for the Supreme Court nomination of Justice Sonia Sotomayor. He's appeared with some of the kinds of moderate Republicans he used to oppose in his days heading the Club for Growth, such as former Gov. Tom Ridge and Maine Sen. Susan Collins.

Advertise with us

In the campaign's final debate, Mr. Toomey launched into an approving analysis of the Constitution's Establishment Clause two days after Christine O'Donnell, the Delaware GOP Senate candidate, had questioned constitutional basis for the separation of church and state. While he seldom invoked Sarah Palin's name on the campaign trail, Politico reported that over the campaign's final weekend he was the beneficiary of robo-calls to social conservatives from the former vice presidential candidate.

Mr. Sestak refers to "the Palin-O'Donnell-Toomey agenda," and the "Toomey-Bush agenda" as he tries to brand his opponent a figure of Republican excess. He has sought to project independence reminding voters of his willingness to run against the party establishment, but unlike some Democrats, he has not tried to distance himself from some of the controversial issues of the Obama administration.

And while he ruffled feathers in his run against Mr. Specter, who was the choice of Democratic leadership, Mr. Sestak has been eager to embrace the current support from party luminaries such as President Barack Obama, first lady Michelle Obama and former President Bill Clinton, who were campaigning for him and other Democratic candidates in and around Philadelphia over this final weekend of the campaign.

Nationally, the Republicans appear to have only an outside chance of gaining the 10 seats they would need to take control of the Senate, and a victory for Mr. Toomey would be essential for that.

While margins have narrowed for both of the statewide races, all but a handful of the many polls have shown leads for the Republican candidates among voters deemed likely to cast a ballot. Pennsylvania has a Democratic registration edge of more than 1.1 million, but the widely mentioned enthusiasm gap between Democrats and Republicans shows up in that data. The Muhlenberg College tracking poll of both races suggests, in fact, that Republicans in Pennsylvania might turn out not just in larger proportions, but also in greater absolute numbers than Democrats.

Advertise with us

"Based on what we are seeing, it suggests a fairly even split or a slight Republican advantage on Election Day,'' said Chris Borick, the Muhlenberg political scientist who directs the poll. "That's slightly astounding when you have a 1.1 million registration difference.''

Terry Madonna, the veteran director of the Franklin & Marshall poll, has found a similar tilt toward Republicans in his poll's assessment of likely voters. He noted the last time that more Republicans than Democrats cast ballots in a Pennsylvania election was in 1994, the first Clinton mid-term year, when Republicans captured not only Congress, but also the majority in Pennsylvania's House.

"They need to move mountains to change that differential,'' Mr. Madonna said of Democratic turnout efforts.

Across the Commonwealth, Democratic activists are working frantically in these final hours to confound the assumptions in those likely voter screens, while Republicans strive to ensure the kind of voters' surge they predict.

While the candidates welcome votes wherever they're found, the most crucial battleground remains Philadelphia and its suburbs -- hence the appearances there Thursday by Mr. Clinton, the return visit from the president Saturday, and Mrs. Obama's plans for an 11th hour appeal for votes there Monday.

Advertise with us

The predicted Republican wave is the reason that such an unusually large number of Democratic House incumbents are in jeopardy Tuesday. Chief among the GOP opportunities are members of the wave of Democratic newcomers swept in during the elections of 2006. In Western Pennsylvania, freshman Rep. Kathy Dahlkemper, D-Erie, faces a difficult battle for a second term against Butler auto dealer Mike Kelly. Rep. Mark Critz, D-Johnstown, won an unexpectedly easy victory over businessman Tim Burns in the May special election for the 12th District seat opened by the death of John P. Murtha. But Mr. Burns has renewed his challenge and infusions of national Republican and Democratic spending testify both sides continue to view it a competitive seat.

No Pennsylvania member of the class of 2006 has done more to distance himself from the Obama administration than Rep. Jason Altmire, D-McCandless, who faces a challenge from Edgeworth attorney Keith Rothfus. Mr. Altmire and Ms. Dahlkemper are members of the Blue Dog caucus of centrist Democrats. Those moderate credentials don't seem to have given them much political insulation, however. Other Pennsylvania Blue Dogs who could face defeat this week include Rep. Chris Carney in the northeastern corner of the state and Rep. Pat Murphy in a district centered in the Philadelphia suburbs of Bucks County. Rep. Paul Kanjorski, a veteran midstate Democrat, is also potentially vulnerable in the face of a repeat challenge from Hazelton Mayor Lou Barletta.

The traditional midterm dynamics lengthening the odds against Democratic congressional candidates apply to legislative races as well. Tim Storey, an analyst at the National Council of State Legislatures, noted that throughout the last century, the party holding the White House has suffered a net loss of state House and Senate seats in every midterm election with only two exceptions -- 1934, in the teeth of the Depression, and 2002, as a post-9/11 mood bolstered public solidarity with the Bush White House.

In Pennsylvania, Republicans are therefore bullish on their chances of reversing the Democrats' narrow majority in the state House.

State Sen. Jane Orie's indictment on charges of using public resources for electioneering has made her race against Democrat Dan DeMarco in the 40th District more competitive than it would otherwise have been. Even if she were to lose, however, the GOP still enjoys a big Senate majority.

Advertise with us

So a Corbett victory for governor, coupled with a GOP House takeover would give Republicans complete control of the next Congressional redistricting, a prospect that would enhance GOP congressional chances in the state for a decade. States across the country display similar pictures. Democrats have complete control of 27 legislatures; Republicans, 14, and eight, like Pennsylvania's, are split between the parties. (Nebraska has a nonpartisan legislature.) Mr. Storey, the NCSL analyst, expects a net gain of between 13 and 17 chambers for the Republicans.

"The Democrats are playing defense in virtually every battleground state," he said.