In an angry political season, Pat Toomey sometimes seems out of place.

While conservative talk show hosts rage and cry, the Harvard University graduate is a calm, buttoned-down presence, courting votes in a Jack-Webb, just-the-facts-ma'am monotone.

His restrained demeanor may contrast with the often superheated rhetoric of the times, but his unwavering policy prescriptions of lower taxes and less spending may have found their moment.

In years when the phrase "tea party" evoked only a chapter in Revolutionary history, Mr. Toomey was arguing against deficits and the growth of government. A straight policy line extends from his first political involvement to the message that's helped propel him to a polling lead in the Senate race against Rep. Joe Sestak.

Advertise with us

As a member of an elected government study commission in Allentown, he helped push through a requirement for a supermajority to raise taxes. His current stump speech echoes the call for lower taxes, less spending and the need to reverse a tide of federal red ink.

But while arguments against big deficits are consistent, it's less clear how he would be able to reconcile and advance his anti-tax and anti-deficit goals as a member of a new Congress for which he predicts big Republican gains.

Mr. Toomey grew up in East Providence, R.I., one of six children in a Catholic -- and Democratic -- family. A scholarship exam won him a spot at LaSalle Academy. He thrived academically at the Christian Brothers school, paving the way for his admission to Harvard. He recounts that experience in his advocacy of school choice, arguing that his own record demonstrates the worth of alternatives to public schools.

He entered college as Ronald Reagan was capturing the White House. The conservative captured Mr. Toomey's political imagination and helped lure him away from his family's Democratic roots.

From college, he went on to Wall Street, working first at Chemical Bank, then for a British investment banking firm, Morgan Grenfell. His work involved trading in currencies. Later, he worked as a consultant in Hong Kong before returning to the United States and moving from New York City to Pennsylvania.

Advertise with us

The Sestak campaign continues to emphasize Mr. Toomey's financial background, calling him "Wall Street's congressman."

The Republican's team prefers to highlight his Main Street credentials. Mr. Toomey customarily describes himself as a small businessman, pointing to his experience in owning a small chain of restaurants in the early 1990s.

His first run for public office on the local government study commission came in 1994, a year of Republican momentum as the Democrats lost control of Congress for the first time in decades. In 1998, with the retirement of a conservative Democrat, Mr. Toomey emerged from a crowded field to win the Republican nomination for the 15th Congressional District. In the general election, despite the district's Democratic background, he won easily.

His platform contained the core of the policies he continues to advocate. He called for Social Security reform emphasizing private investments and a flat tax of 17 percent -- positions he would continue to embrace and ones he discusses in his 2009 book, "The Road to Prosperity."

One of Mr. Sestak's first ads highlights a television clip in which Mr. Toomey, then president of the Club for Growth, called for the elimination of corporate taxes. Mr. Toomey has complained that the commercial's quote was taken out of context.

Advertise with us

It is clear, however, that he has consistently favored a corporate tax rate set as low as possible. The flat tax proposal he supports would set the corporate rate, like the personal tax rate, at 17 percent. In a recent interview, he suggested that a 25 percent rate would place the country on an even footing with most of its trading partners.

The freshman congressman embraced deregulation of the financial markets. He championed the measure -- signed by President Bill Clinton and supported by many Democrats -- that loosened restrictions on financial institutions by repealing provisions of the Glass-Steagall legislation of the 1930s, which had mandated the separation of traditional banking from the trading of investment banks.

'Stop digging'

The Toomey campaign has complained that Mr. Sestak's ads exaggerate his role in crafting the crucial legislation. But like many lawmakers of both parties, he clearly supported it, along with other measures that loosened restrictions on Wall Street. Some critics blame those laws for loosening oversight of the financial markets and setting the stage for the financial crisis to come.

Mr. Toomey rejects that analysis, assigning the chief blame for the meltdown to the easy money policies of Alan Greenspan's Federal Reserve.

Advertise with us

"In 2003 or so, that's when it became very clear to me that the Fed was keeping interest rates way too low for too long," he said. "We had negative real interest rates ... this almost inevitably will create a credit bubble or an asset bubble.

"That's what creates a bubble; it's monetary policy," he said. "That's exactly what I think kicked this off, and I'm certainly not alone."

While critical of the Federal Reserve's decisions earlier in the decade, the Republican offers cautious approval of some of its post-crash policies. Pointing to decisions to drive down interest rates and increase insurance levels for bank deposits, he said, "I think all of those things were probably necessary and prudent given the circumstances."

But, he added, referring to the bank bailouts of the last months of the Bush administration, "I draw the line at TARP, and the very ad hoc policy that the Treasury and the Fed followed, where some firms were forced into mergers [and] others were allowed to go bankrupt ... there was no rhyme or reason."

That brings Mr. Toomey to his stock rebuttal to Democratic portrayals of him as a handmaiden of Wall Street. Again and again, he's pointed out that Mr. Sestak supported the bank bailout while, he, as president of the Club for Growth, criticized the steps to prop up financial institutions. He went on to criticize the new administration's steps to combat the crisis -- the auto firm bailouts and the overall $787 billion stimulus bill.

Advertise with us

"When you're in a hole, the first thing you should do is stop digging," he told more than one audience.

But while Mr. Toomey ceaselessly criticizes the Obama administration and his opponent for driving up the federal deficit, the question of exactly how he would stanch the flow of red ink remains open.

He is adamantly opposed to a reversal of the Bush-era tax cuts for taxpayers at any income level. Depending on the performance of the financial markets, the shift to personal investment accounts that he advocates for younger workers could prove beneficial to the individual recipients, but he acknowledges that such a transition would, in fact, increase the need for borrowing to finance benefits in the near term.

His book concedes that the flat tax plan he has long advocated initially could depress federal revenue. And while he devotes a detailed chapter to the changes he seeks for Social Security, neither his book nor his Senate platform offers much guidance on how he would address the soaring costs of Medicare, the other big driver of entitlement spending as the Baby Boomers are poised to retire.

"We have to have a bipartisan consensus," is the best he can do when asked about the deficit implications for Medicare. "I do not have a detailed plan laid out like I do for Social Security."

Advertise with us

But, for Mr. Toomey, there is a philosopher's stone promising to transform such fiscal dilemmas. He sees low tax rates and low spending as the recipe for economic growth that would allow the nation to overcome its budget challenges. His book approvingly cites the concept of the Laffer Curve, popularized during the Reagan administration, that contends that lower tax rates can increase government revenue by spurring private sector growth.

"I've argued that we should rescind the unspent portion of the stimulus bill, that we should eliminate earmarks altogether -- and, by the way, that has benefits that go beyond the value of the earmarks themselves -- in helping to prevent bloated spending bills from passing," he said. "We should look at huge segments of the government where we should have a complete hiring freeze and we should look at programs like Social Security and make fundamental reforms for the future, for young people."

From opposition to embrace

Mr. Toomey left his House seat after three terms to challenge Sen. Arlen Specter in the 2004 Republican primary. He lost narrowly, then moved on to the Club for Growth, the anti-tax lobby that spent heavily for him in the 2004 campaign and has followed the same pattern this year. In the 2004 race, his strong finish came in the face of unified opposition from the Republican establishment, including President George W. Bush and then-Sen. Rick Santorum.

At the Club for Growth, he stirred establishment resentment by crusading and spending heavily against moderate Republicans who he saw as too willing to compromise conservative principles. Last February, the Pennsylvania version of that establishment, the Republican State Committee, came around to embrace him as their endorsed candidate.

Advertise with us

Earlier this month, Mr. Toomey appeared with former Gov. Tom Ridge to accept the endorsement of a figure who had considered running against him at a time when many Republicans dismissed him as a fringe figure, unelectable in a state that President Barack Obama carried in a landslide. Through the summer and early fall, the polls have belied that analysis.

Mr. Toomey's early positive poll numbers have eased the concerns of his former establishment opponents. His record as a budget hawk has allowed him to finesse the establishment-insurgent fissures that have split Republican parties in some other states this primary season.

"What I see in the tea party movement is an organic, indigenous movement of ordinary Americans who believe strongly in limited government, fiscal responsibility and free enterprise," he said. "Now are there people on the fringe who are a little on the edge? Sure -- in both political parties and across the political spectrum, that always happens."

In a separate interview, he dismissed the observation by former Speaker Newt Gingrich that Mr. Obama's actions can be understood only by appreciating his Kenyan anti-colonial world view.

"I'm not a subscriber to that theory, not in the least," he said. "President Obama is a very capable, very smart guy. We disagree on the vast majority of policy matters that he's been very vocal about, [but] I recognize that he has a perfectly legitimate point of view."