Trailing in the polls, behind in fundraising and little-known. In this topsy-turvy political year, that may be just the recipe for getting elected.
Congressional underdogs from both parties campaigned around Pittsburgh Tuesday, bringing in national names to make the case that they can knock out entrenched incumbents during this anti-Washington year. On the Senate side, Rep. Joe Sestak -- who became a big part of that anti-incumbent trend in the Democratic primary, kicking Arlen Specter off Capitol Hill after 30 years -- tried to make the case that he, too, is an outsider, in a speech at Carnegie Mellon University.
The traditional post-Labor Day sprint toward November began with a fundraiser headed by a top Republican leader in the House, Mike Pence, for Edgeworth lawyer Keith Rothfus, who is looking to unseat 4th District Democrat Jason Altmire.
"Democrats around the country know they have to hold onto conservative districts like this one if they have any hope of holding onto power," Mr. Pence, R-Indiana, said of the district north of Pittsburgh. "When I saw a conservative of this caliber who is a first-tier candidate in every respect, I wanted to be here on what I think essentially is day one of the fall political season -- this is event one, day one, for me."
A few hours later, former U.S. Rep. Patricia Schroeder headlined another fundraiser attended largely by women and union leaders for Democrat Dan Connolly, who is challenging four-term incumbent Tim Murphy, R-Upper St. Clair. The main purpose was to criticize Mr. Murphy for his 2009 vote against the Lilly Ledbetter Fair Pay Act, which changed the statute of limitations for equal pay lawsuits, but it underscored Mr. Connolly's larger strategy against the incumbent.
"There is such a disconnect between what [Murphy] says in Washington, Pa., and what he does in Washington, D.C. The people of this district deserve somebody to get out there and talk to them about that disconnect and make sure they know what his voting record actually is," said Mr. Connolly, a South Park lawyer.
To Mr. Pence, the chair of the House Republican Conference, the battle north in the 4th District is about holding Mr. Altmire accountable for House Speaker Nancy Pelosi. "We might not fire Nancy Pelosi unless we hire Keith Rothfus. This race is that important," he said.
Mr. Altmire, like Mr. Murphy, has a massive lead over his challenger in fundraising. The Democrat's campaign also released poll numbers Tuesday claiming a 27-point lead in the race.
But Mr. Rothfus shocked the political cognoscenti when he defeated Mary Beth Buchanan in the spring, and is counting on doing the same in eight weeks.
"It's districts like this that are in play across the country. It's districts like this that we lost in 2006 and 2008," Mr. Rothfus said. "We lost those districts not because there was a mandate for big government and big spending and big programs. There was a mandate for good government and the Democrats betrayed that."
Though he will be campaigning with President Barack Obama later this month, Mr. Sestak has done his best to project the image of an outsider since he bucked his party's leaders in capturing the Democratic Senate nomination.
On Tuesday, he tried to sway perceptions on who's inside and who's outside in an ailing economy. Mr. Sestak reinforced his populist portrayal of the Senate contest as he told Carnegie Mellon students that his GOP opponent, former Rep. Pat Toomey, "seems to miss the human cost of his callous policies."
In his speech, the Delaware County Democrat once again assailed the Republican nominee for his embrace of Bush-era proposals to revamp Social Security. He also characterized Mr. Toomey as a handmaiden of Wall Street who would reduce the tax burden on corporations while increasing taxes on individuals.
"At its core, this is a question not just of policy but of values," Mr. Sestak said on a day when the Republican released new television ads, one of which was designed to counter the Democrat's repeated references to Mr. Toomey's background as an investment banker.
During a half-hour speech before an audience of about 75, Mr. Sestak repeated proposals that he said would produce jobs in small businesses by providing new tax credits for investments in such firms, a 15 percent payroll tax credit for small business and loan guarantees for community bank loans to smaller firms.
He contrasted those measures to what he called the Wall Street approach of his opponent and blamed that approach for the economic ills that are now battering the candidacies of Democratic candidates up and down the ballot.
"Those reckless polices were too much for our system to bear, and finally about two years ago, the whole house of cards came tumbling down," he said. "That is Congressman Toomey's unfortunate legacy."
Reacting to the speech, Toomey communications director Nachama Soloveichik hit back at the Democrat's support for a variety of Obama administration initiatives.
"In Washington, Sestak has supported an extreme agenda that has prevented us from creating jobs and having an economic recovery.
"These votes include supporting record spending and debt, hundreds of billions of dollars in higher taxes and a government health care takeover. And Joe Sestak voted to give Wall Street the biggest gift it ever got from Washington when he strongly supported the Wall Street bailout," she said in a statement that reinforced the message of the campaign's new ads.



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.