JOHNSTOWN, Pa. -- Democrat Mark Critz, a political neophyte and policy wonk, won a special election Tuesday night to succeed his dead boss, John P. Murtha, the one-man economy whose largesse with earmarks sustained the struggling 12th District.
Handed the mantle of a legendary political insider, Mr. Critz overcame a roiling anti-Washington mood among the voters and defeated Republican newcomer Tim Burns. Mr. Burns, a self-made millionaire, mounted an impressive bid to fill Mr. Murtha's seat, drawing a large contingent of socially conservative Democrats in a failed effort to overcome a 2-to-1 Democratic registration edge.
"We did it, didn't we?" Mr. Critz told a cheering throng at the Holiday Inn here shortly before 11 p.m.
"Tonight the voters of this district rejected the false attacks and partisan divisions," he said. "We kept our focus on Western Pennsylvania and bringing jobs to the people of this district."
He spoke of "the extraordinary honor" of following Mr. Murtha.
Prior to his speech, Mr. Critz said he received a telephone call from Mr. Burns.
"It was very cordial and we said we looked forward to seeing each other the rest of this year and in November," Mr. Critz said.
With millions spent and both national parties likely to turn their attention to other races nationwide in the fall, the question arose whether Mr. Critz now had an incumbent's edge that made him more likely to carry the general election against Mr. Burns.
"I don't know if it's going to be easier or harder, but I'm just going to run like I always have," he said.
The men will face off in November. Mr. Critz handily won his party's primary for the rights to seek a full congressional term in the November election. Mr. Burns won a tighter contest with retired Army officer William Russell, who raised millions for a second try at the seat. Trends last night suggested Mr. Burns would ultimately capture the Republican nomination.
It was an unusual political moment inside the Grand Ballroom of the George Washington Hotel in Washington, Pa., when Mr. Burns, a candidate who had just won his party's nomination for the fall election, stood beneath a net of balloons that never dropped, speaking to supporters, some of them weeping.
"Would you believe I didn't even prepare a concession speech?" Mr. Burns said. "The biggest lessons learned aren't necessary from success, but from failure."
He promised to continue the fight into November and reverse Tuesday night's loss.
"There are a lot of lessons to be learned here. We will learn them, we will get better, we will figure out what to do and we will improve," he said. "The good news here is that the conservative movement across this country is alive and well and this race proved it. We got support from all over the country, all 50 states. That's the good news."
The contest in the 12th attracted national attention, elicited millions in outside political dollars and triggered a mudslide of accusations by each side that, at points, threatened to obscure the candidates' messages as national parties sought to turn the contest into a referendum on the Obama administration.
The contest attracted analysis from across the country and across the political spectrum, from academics and think-tank directors to the likes of Jon Bauman, better known as Bowzer, the bassist in the rock-and-roll revival group Sha Na Na.
"This is the race that will set the tone for November," said Mr. Bauman, who traveled to Johnstown from his home in California to campaign for Mr. Critz.
U.S. Rep. Chris Van Hollen, chairman of the Democratic Congressional Campaign Committee, which spent more than $1 million on behalf of Mr. Critz, called Tuesday night's vote a rejection of the Republican message for 2010.
"For all of their bluster about building a national wave this year, including RNC Chairman Michael Steele's guarantee of victory for Tim Burns, Republican policies were once again rejected when it came time to face the voters," Mr. Van Hollen said.
Mr. Steele, for his part, spoke of the Burns run as an uphill struggle from the start.
"Republican Tim Burns ran an excellent campaign in one of the bluest of congressional districts," Mr. Steele said in a statement Tuesday night. "Despite the fact that Pennsylvania's 12th District has been a Democratic stronghold for more than 30 years and Democratic voters outnumber Republicans by more than 2 to 1, Republican Tim Burns pushed his Democratic opponent to the wire."
While much of the anti-incumbency sentiment turned on rising public anger over defense earmarks -- the customized federal contracts directed to land federal dollars in a member's district -- the issue did not gain traction in the 12th.
In large part, that appears to be because the district, which struggled after the collapse of the steel industry, saw a level of prosperity from the defense contractors Mr. Murtha pushed into the 12th District.
"The one lesson that's been coming out of this is that the appropriators who bring back earmarks have been getting whacked, and yet in this district that's not what the R and the D are talking about," said Grover Norquist, a longtime conservative anti-tax activist.
Tuesday night's surprisingly strong win by Mr. Critz suggests that the November election might now be an even more difficult effort for the Republicans. And, if it is to be a harbinger, at least one independent observer has his doubts that it bodes well for the Republicans who, miscalculated on bringing national issues into a uniquely idiosyncratic region.
"Candidly, I think this whole area thought about the negative stuff from both sides and they just reeled back and went normal," said James Alexander, a professor of political science at the University of Pittsburgh at Johnstown.
Dr. Alexander said he now wonders whether many of the expected crossover votes from Democrats trending conservative -- the same ones that gave the district to Republican John McCain in the 2008 presidential election -- ever materialized.
"It's just an old Democratic district going back Democratic," he said.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.