Thursday, April 10, 2008

The radio ad: "FILL"

Candidate: Sen. Barack Obama

Link:my.barackobama.com/page/-/Press/ads-radio/Fill-PA_BU-08-122R_Bcast.mp3

Advertise with us

Time: 60 seconds

Audio: "Across Pennsylvania, we're living the problems. An economy in shambles. Families struggling. Gas prices close to four dollars a gallon. What's Hillary Clinton's answer? Misleading negative ads. Here's the truth. While she's played political games, it's Barack Obama who's taken on the oil companies, demanding higher gas mileage standards and a larger investment in alternative energy. It's Obama who's worked to strip tax breaks from the oil giants as they roll up record profits. And he's the only candidate who doesn't take a dime from oil company PACs or lobbyists. The only one.

"The Federal Election Commission reports that Clinton's taken more from Big Oil and other PACs and lobbyists than any other candidate, Democrat or Republican. The same old Washington politics isn't going to lift our economy or bring down gas prices. So if you've had your fill of that, vote for change we can believe in, Barack Obama for president."

Analysis: First, the Obama camp has been running a TV spot in which the candidate says he does not "take money from oil companies or Washington lobbyists." Then the Clinton camp followed with a radio spot -- the first negative ad of the Pennsylvania campaign -- pointing out that companies are barred from donating to campaigns and noting Mr. Obama voted for the industry-perk-filled Bush Cheney energy bill. "It's time for president who takes on the oil companies in real life, not just on TV," the Clinton spot says.

With this ad, the Obama camp is responding to the Clinton camp charges.

Advertise with us

The heart of the Clinton criticism comes from the Annenberg Public Policy Center's factcheck.org, which picks apart both candidates' stances on long-debated energy matters. Neither smells like roses in either of these ads.

According to factcheck.org, Mr. Obama stretched the truth: He may not have taken money from oil companies -- or from PACs, as his campaign noted later -- but he has taken more than $200,000 from individual oil industry officials and their spouses. (Clinton has taken more than $300,000.)

But Annenberg has also said Clinton's energy bill criticisms are "misleading," as the legislation raised both taxes on those industries and gas mileage standards.

The first part of new Obama radio ad touts accomplishments of the energy bill. The second part repeats his questionable claims on oil industry campaign funding, but also corrects his first ad. ("Oil companies" is replaced with "oil company PACs.") The last part zings Clinton for her own oil industry financing.

-- Tim McNulty