Race matters in the fiercely competitive 2008 Democratic presidential primary fight. It shouldn't, but it does.

On Wednesday, Geraldine A. Ferraro, the 1984 Democratic vice-presidential candidate, resigned from Sen. Hillary Rodham Clinton's campaign finance committee after she told a newspaper: "If Obama was a white man, he would not be in this position."

Her comments provoked a hailstorm of criticism. Sen. Barack Obama called them "wrongheaded" and "ridiculous." Mrs. Clinton also repudiated them. But some political observers acknowledge that Ms. Ferraro captured an unfortunate reality.

"It's sad that we're still having such a tortured conversation about race, even among progressive thinkers," former Pittsburgh City Councilman Sala Udin said yesterday. "The race of a candidate and the gender of a candidate [are] entirely irrelevant to how they'll perform as president of the United States."

Advertise with us

Just like Mr. Obama, who would be the nation's first black president, Ms. Ferraro is a path breaker. She was the first woman on a major-party presidential ticket, running alongside Walter Mondale.

Mr. Udin, coordinator of Pittsburgh African Americans for Obama, said that Ms. Ferraro's comments were a distraction from real issues, including the Iraq war and health care.

Philadelphia Mayor Michael Nutter, who is black and a Clinton supporter, said, "Race should be a non-issue in this campaign. He's black, she's white. So what?"

Yet race is still an indicator of how some voters perceive the candidates, for better or worse. Exit polls from recent primary elections show a divide.

In Mississippi, which held its primary on Tuesday, more than 90 percent of black Democrats supported Mr. Obama, while 70 percent of white Democrats voted for Mrs. Clinton, according to an exit poll conducted by CNN. In Texas and Ohio, where people voted a week before, the breakdowns were similar.

Advertise with us

The picture becomes less clear when one examines more specific demographic groups. Mrs. Clinton, for example, had a 12-point lead among white Democrats in Virginia's primary election. But Mr. Obama won 58 percent of white college graduates, according to The Washington Post's "Behind the Numbers" blog.

He also has far outperformed Mrs. Clinton in caucuses, which tend to attract more dedicated party activists. They have given Mr. Obama victories in Iowa, Idaho, Maine, Kansas, Alaska and other states with paltry African-American populations.

It was Mr. Obama's strong victory in the first-in-the-nation Iowa caucuses on Jan. 3 that persuaded many black voters to abandon the Clinton camp, said Shelby Steele, a senior fellow at the Hoover Institution at Stanford University. By winning there, Mr. Obama proved his crossover appeal and the viability of his candidacy.

Ms. Ferraro's comment "is true on its face. Race is a huge source of Barack Obama's success," said Mr. Steele, author of "A Bound Man: Why We Are Excited About Obama and Why He Can't Win."

Yet Mr. Obama's efforts to please a broad spectrum of voters have forced him to hide his strong black identity, which he developed as an adult living on Chicago's South Side.

Advertise with us

"I think it is a fatal flaw. In order to reach all these groups, he has to remain invisible," Mr. Steele said. "His rhetoric is amazingly empty. He wants change. Change from what?"

Mr. Udin argued that the message of change, coming at a time of war and intense partisan division, has been a primary draw for Mr. Obama nationwide, not the color of his skin.

"It's worked everywhere else in the country. Why not in Pennsylvania?" Mr. Udin said. "We're getting excited, heated up and ready to go."

Mr. Obama himself scoffed at the idea that his race is a benefit. He told a Chicago news conference on Wednesday: "The notion that it is a great advantage to me to be an African American named Barack Obama and pursue the presidency, I think, is not a view that has been commonly shared by the general public."

Tim Stevens, chairman of the Black Political Empowerment Project, said he had "chills" more than two decades ago when he heard Ms. Ferraro would be on the Democratic ticket.

Advertise with us

"I thought it was a most historic moment in the country," he said.

But he argued that she somewhat owed her own success to her gender and questioned whether she would have been picked if she had been a black woman with the same experience and qualifications.

Mr. Obama's success so far "is an accomplishment no one would have guessed," he said.