On a night of vindication for Arizona Sen. John S. McCain, a resurgent New York Sen. Hillary Rodham Clinton defeated Illinois Sen. Barack Obama in the key states of Ohio and Texas.
Even before the full returns were counted, the day had produced yet another dramatic turn in their historic, unpredictable struggle for the Democratic nomination.
While the delegate numbers remained uncertain, a day that had threatened to end Mrs. Clinton's bid for the White House gave her new hope and a ticket to later primaries, including Pennsylvania's April 22 contest, which now figures to be the last big-state showdown before the Democrats' Denver convention.
"We're going on. We're going strong, and we're going all the way," Mrs. Clinton told jubilant supporters in Columbus, Ohio.
Mr. Obama, speaking last night in San Antonio before the Texas results were final, said, "No matter what happens tonight, we have nearly the same delegate lead we had this morning, and we are on the way to winning the nomination."
The results dictated that no Democrat would have a last stand last night. Rather, a contest that started earlier than any presidential election in memory is now likely to go on for weeks longer.
As expected, Mr. McCain seized the Republican nomination, as he swept the four states that voted yesterday to surpass the 1,191 delegates needed to put him over the top. Promising to do what he could to unite the GOP, former Arkansas Gov. Mike Huckabee conceded the evening and the nomination to Mr. McCain shortly after the polls closed.
The victory was a remarkable turnaround for the Arizona senator, whose second bid for the White House seemed all but dead last summer. A financial meltdown within his campaign forced him to lay off senior staffers and return to a retail strategy. He concentrated on New Hampshire and leveraged a come-from-behind win there to win the GOP nomination -- "an accomplishment that once seemed, to more than a few doubters, unlikely," he observed.
The former naval aviator accepted his now-certain nomination with an appeal to patriotism. "I owe my country every opportunity that I have ever had," Mr. McCain said, speaking under a banner emblazoned, "1191."
"I owe her the meaning that service to America has given my life. And the sense that I am part of something greater then myself, part of a kinship of ideals that have always represented the last, best hope of mankind."
Mr. Obama called Mr. McCain to offer his congratulations early in the evening, but the results raised a question mark about whether those two would, in fact, face off in the fall.
Mr. Obama was the projected winner in Vermont shortly after the polls closed, while Mrs. Clinton prevailed in Rhode Island. But those were just the previews for the big-state battle.
Mrs. Clinton jumped out to an early lead in Ohio, but Mr. Obama was out in front, albeit by a smaller margin, in the first Texas tallies. With about 25 percent of the Texas primary vote counted, Mrs. Clinton had edged ahead of her rival, although the results were still close enough that no wire service or network called that race until early this morning.
Counting was slow in both states. And in Texas, the primary was followed by caucuses across the state that would determine roughly a third of the delegates to be awarded.
Overall, 370 Democratic delegates were available in the four states. But adding to the Democratic muddle, the party's delegate selection rules made it difficult for either candidate to pile up big relative gains, meaning that Mr. Obama's overall lead in pledged delegates appeared secure, despite Mrs. Clinton's strength in the Ohio popular vote and the close Texas primary contest.
Mr. Obama began the evening with the overall delegate lead, 1,389 to 1,276, according to the Associated Press tally. Among pledged delegates elected by primary and caucus voters, he was ahead 1,187-1,035. The balance represented superdelegates, the party and elected officials automatically seated at the convention. The former first lady had an advantage among superdelegates, but Obama picked up three during the day, narrowing her advantage to 241-202.
The delegate math made it unlikely, though not impossible, that Mrs. Clinton could overcome the Obama lead, even with a string of strong showings in Pennsylvania and other subsequent primaries. But by the same token -- as the Clinton campaign has pointed out repeatedly in recent weeks -- neither Democrat was in a position to capture the nomination on the strength of pledged delegates alone
Mrs. Clinton hoped that her showing last night would allow her to make the case to the superdelegates that their party had reached a point of "buyers' remorse" over her Illinois rival, and that, despite her deficit in pledged delegates, she would be the stronger nominee against Mr. McCain.
Mrs. Clinton's aides, along with her husband, former President Bill Clinton, had previously acknowledged that she needed to win both of the big states to keep her nomination hopes alive. In recent days, however, Clinton aides had tried to dial back those expectations, insisting that only a four-state sweep by Mr. Obama could be considered a definitive win. A split between the two states would dictate difficult decisions for the Clinton campaign.
One ominous exit-poll result for Mr. Obama was that late-deciding voters were breaking overwhelmingly in Mrs. Clinton's favor, even in Texas, where he grabbed the early lead on the strength of votes cast before election day, and in Vermont, which he won overwhelmingly.
The economy was cited as the top issue by a strong majority of Ohio Democrats, who were also overwhelmingly inclined to blame international trade for a loss of American jobs. Trade was underscored as an issue in the competition there, as Mr. Obama tried to put Mrs. Clinton on the defensive with rhetoric and extensive mailings that blamed Mr. Clinton for enactment of the North American Free trade Agreement.
The issue came back to bite Mr. Obama, however, after Canadian television reported that one of his economic advisers had assured a diplomat that the Obama rhetoric should be seen as political posturing, rather than as a serious plan to shift the U.S. position on trade.
The Obama campaign denied first that such a conversation took place. Then, after a Canadian memo describing the conversation emerged, the campaign said one of its advisers, University of Chicago professor Austan Goolsbee, had been quoted incorrectly. But the incident stepped on the Obama message in the crucial final days before the latest balloting.
The timing of the news cycle also may have hurt the Illinois senator as the Chicago trial of a longtime associate, Tony Rezko, began the day before the primaries. While Mr. Obama has not been implicated in the influence-peddling charges against Mr. Rezko, the publicity could hardly have come at a worse time.
According to exit polls conducted by the Associated Press and the television networks, Mrs. Clinton was doing a better job of holding onto the votes of constituencies that had supported her in the round of Super Tuesday primaries and caucuses Feb. 5, but had drifted toward Mr. Obama through the contests later in February.
Mrs. Clinton won the support of more than two-thirds of white women and of older voters. She won among white men in Ohio, in contrast to her showings in earlier-voting states, such as Virginia and Wisconsin.
Mr. Obama did well among more educated and affluent voters and won African-Americans overwhelmingly.



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.