Nonprofit organizations, civic groups and some businesses across Pittsburgh were reeling this week after being named in an affidavit for a search warrant alleging that former Mayor Ed Gainey’s administration may have rigged the bidding process for contracts and presented misleading information regarding the city’s finances. 

District Attorney Stephen A. Zappala Jr. served the search warrant on the city in March. Earlier this week, a judge denied an extension request to keep the warrant sealed, revealing to the public for the first time the extent of the accusations. 

Alongside high-ranking members of the Gainey administration, more than a dozen other entities are mentioned in the nine-page document. Some are outright accused of benefiting from alleged bid-rigging, while others are mentioned in passing as groups the DA’s office “should also look at.”

From activist groups like 1Hood Media and Bike Pittsburgh to law firms and longstanding nonprofits like the Pittsburgh Parks Conservancy, the organizations mentioned in the document have moved quickly to try to correct some of the inaccuracies they’ve found in the affidavit and to defend the work they’ve done. 

Advertise with us

“Our work with the city has always been governed by formal agreements, clearly defined scopes of work, established approval and reimbursement processes, and extensive publicly available documentation,” a statement from the parks conservancy said. “We take our responsibility as a steward of public and private resources seriously and remain committed to transparency and accountability in everything we do.” 

Some of those named have called the claims “laughable,” and “untrue” while others said they believe the entire investigation — and their inclusion in it — is racially or politically motivated, or both.

“This was a Black mayor that gave money to Black organizations,” said Jasiri X, a co-founder and the CEO of 1Hood Media, in an interview this week. “That’s what people really have a problem with.”

The affidavit uses the city’s Stop the Violence grant program — designed to decrease gun violence — as an example of a place where the Gainey administration allegedly awarded funds to groups he was close to or that could benefit him politically. 

1Hood is specifically named in the affidavit as benefiting from the no-bid contracts. 

Advertise with us

But according to Jasiri X, 1Hood has never received a no-bid contract from the city. The organization has received multiple grants ranging from $25,000 to $50,000 from the Stop the Violence grant program, all of which had to be applied for.

1Hood Media has been a 501(c)3 nonprofit since 2017. In the years since, Jasiri X said, they’ve never had any issues with any other foundations that they’ve received funding from. 

“Now all of a sudden [accusations] are cast against us that have never been cast before,” he said. 

“Although we have a track record that goes back to 2006, the implication is we couldn’t get these grants, these Black organizations couldn’t get grants on our own merit,” he said. “It had to be some type of kickback. Why would we jeopardize 20 years of work for a kickback on $25,000? That’s ridiculous.”

‘Inaccuracies and insinuations’

Pittsburgh City Councilman Khari Mosley is listed in the affidavit as being the “owner and operator” of 1Hood Media, a nonprofit activist organization. However, Mosley is a founding member of the group and currently serves on its board, which is an unpaid position.  

Advertise with us

Mosley said he had no knowledge that he was mentioned in the DA’s report until it was made public on Monday. 

Despite what Mosley calls the “inaccuracies and insinuations” of the document — which alleges that he, through his position at 1Hood benefitted from no-bid contracts — the affidavit also acknowledges that Mosley has recused himself from council votes involving the nonprofit. 

The document also incorrectly claims that current Mayor Corey O’Connor, while he was a member of council, sponsored the legislation that changed the city’s procurement procedure.

“This change in law removed certain safeguards over the bidding and recording process,” the affidavit said. 

But a review of the city’s legislative record showed O’Connor didn’t sponsor the 2020 legislation. He did vote in favor of the changes.

Advertise with us

Errors like the one misstating Mosley’s role within 1Hood or O’Connor’s involvement in the legislative change have led some people to question the validity of the entire investigation. 

“Stephen Zappala is not new. This man has been DA for over 30 years. I would think he’s seen many warrants in his years as the DA,” Jasiri X said. “So you’re looking at this, and it has all these errors, why release it? Why would you release something that you know is filled with inaccuracies?”

“From our perspective, it seems politically motivated,” he said. 

Zappala said on Friday that the information in the affidavit came from two City Council members and a former council solicitor. 

“Before we took any action, whatever wasn’t accurate as originally relayed is accurate,” Zappala said at a news conference unrelated to the search warrant. “If people want to dispute that, we’ll see at the right time and the right way, we can argue about that.” 

Advertise with us

Zappala also pushed back on claims that this investigation was racially biased. 

“Everybody that thinks they’re a potential target is going to come out and defend themselves, call me names,” he said. “I’m trying to figure out when did I become a racist? I’ve been doing this a long time and this is the first time that somebody has said that to me.”

Future implications

No charges have been filed against anyone in the Gainey administration or any of the groups mentioned, but some organizations are concerned about what even being mentioned could mean for their reputations.

Dan Cohen, whose law firm Cohen Law Group was named in the affidavit, said he’s concerned about how these "completely untrue” allegations could impact the firm’s standing in the public eye. 

The document says Cohen’s firm was hired to do a "telecommunication asset study” for $1.5 million but that the city never received anything in return.

Advertise with us

No study was ever produced, Cohen said, because the firm was never hired. 

“There was no telecommunication asset study,” he said. “I’m not even sure what that is. There absolutely was not a $1.5 million payment.” 

Cohen said his firm, which specializes in representing local governments in negotiations with cable, wireless and broadband providers, worked with Pittsburgh three times in the past, all under former Mayor Bill Peduto’s administration. Each of those jobs was far smaller in the dollar amount than is alleged in the DA’s affidavit. 

The group was hired under a professional services contract, which, according to the Home Rule Charter, would be exempt from the competitive bidding process. Even if it wasn’t exempt, Cohen said, his is the only law firm in the state that does this type of work. 

The document also conflates Cohen Law Group with another law firm in the city, Dentons, Cohen & Grigsby, which does not handle telecommunications law. The affidavit identifies Cohen Law Group using a description from the Dentons, Cohen & Grigsby website. The two law firms are separate businesses.

Advertise with us

More pushback

Other groups mentioned in the affidavit, including the Center that CARES and Operation Better Block, did not respond to requests for comment. The Poise Foundation declined to comment.

For Bike Pittsburgh, which was mentioned as another organization the DA should look into, the mention in the document was unexpected. 

“BikePGH was surprised to see our organization listed in the DA’s search warrant. We are seeking clarification about how and why we came to be incorrectly listed in the warrant, and we are committed to ensuring the public has an accurate understanding of our funding and relationship with the City,” the group said in a statement. “

Tree Pittsburgh, which has partnered with the city of Pittsburgh for more than 20 years, was accused of receiving “millions” from the city but not producing any reporting on how the money was spent. 

The organization pushed back on that claim, saying it has not received millions of dollars from the city. 

Advertise with us

“For 20 years, Tree Pittsburgh has partnered with the City and successive administrations to plant and care for trees,” the group said in a statement. “Throughout that history, we have sought funding through established City processes and followed all applicable contracting, reporting, and documentation requirements. Our work during the Gainey administration was conducted in the same manner as with previous administrations.”

Tree Pittsburgh said the organization plans to fully cooperate with any request for information from the DA’s office and officials there “remain confident in our longstanding practices for managing and accounting for public funds.”

Post-Gazette staff writer Naomi Weiss contributed to this report.