Just 10 days after being sworn into office, Pittsburgh Mayor Corey O’Connor received an alarming notice from the city’s bank.
The account the city uses to pay health care costs for thousands of current and retired employees had been overdrawn by $165,000.
It would prove to be an early warning sign to the new mayor that the state of city finances — long known to be in a precarious position — was even worse than he thought. A decade ago, when O’Connor was on City Council, that account had carried a balance of $10 million.
As the new administration delved deeper into Pittsburgh’s budget over the next nine months, it would find a staggering gap between what former Mayor Ed Gainey had claimed about the city’s financial picture and what the numbers actually showed — a chasm that amounted to $250 million over the next five years, far more than the city could cover with its reserves.
Piece by piece, the mayor’s team would find dozens of small expenses and false budget projections that, together, added up to a looming crisis.
Money had been set aside for a new police academy class – a much needed effort to bolster the understaffed department – but there was nothing to pay for their uniforms.
Read More
When the police bureau needed to shift to a new record-management system, at a cost of half a million dollars, the contract was signed, but the increase was never added to the budget.
The Gainey administration had predicted that the city would spend almost $7 million less on utility payments in 2026 than it did in 2025, even though both Duquesne Light and Pittsburgh Water had increased their rates.
“I’m not sure how they got some of those numbers,” O’Connor said in an interview with the Post-Gazette.
Now, as O’Connor and City Council begin the arduous process of crafting a new budget, they find themselves grappling with key questions about how this happened and how to prevent it in the future.
Hidden perils
City officials have long known that Pittsburgh would have to tighten its belt in coming years, as federal COVID-19 relief funds ran out and delayed debt payments came due.
By the time Gainey’s team constructed its first budget in 2023, it had been well-established that 2025 and 2026 would be what many called “lean financial years.”
As Gainey’s term went on, the pressure on the government finances steadily worsened. Massive reductions in property assessments for Downtown skyscrapers slashed the tax revenue from the city’s most valuable real estate. Rising inflation raised the cost of everything from fuel to office supplies.
By Gainey’s third year in office, financial watchdogs, led by City Controller Rachael Heisler, warned that without major changes, Pittsburgh was in danger of depleting its reserve account in just a few years.
Still, Gainey and his budget director, Jake Pawlak, continued to assure the public that the city was on solid financial footing.
The numbers they presented showed the city spending down its rainy day fund over the coming years, but not to dangerously low levels, even as the alarms raised by Heisler and others grew. The fund now contains about $130 million.
By the time Gainey presented his final budget proposal in November, City Council, which had approved all of his previous spending plans, pushed back.
“We suspected that something might have been off when we had almost a too-perfect budget that gave no room for failure,” said Councilwoman Erika Strassburger, chair of council’s finance committee.
Even then, however, Strassburger and her colleagues couldn’t see the full picture.
Budget documents presented to them showed broad estimates of what the Gainey administration said it would spend on expenses such as salaries, equipment and contracts.
But the details were buried deep inside the administration’s own computer systems.
While council members and the public could see that the Bureau of Police had an allocation of $119.8 million, they wouldn’t see how much of that, if any, was set aside for uniforms and technology upgrades.
“Many of these things aren’t even in the document. You have to dig down in our enterprise software system to really look at it,” O’Connor’s chief of staff, Dan Gilman, told the Post-Gazette.
“Council members don’t have access to some of those systems,” said Gilman, who also has served on City Council.
Heisler’s office similarly does not have access to the budgetary software, and requests for read-only access were denied by Pawlak, according to documents recently reviewed by the Post-Gazette.
O’Connor and Gilman wouldn’t say whether they believed these decisions were made deliberately by the prior administration or were a result of a series of oversights. Neither Gainey nor Pawlak responded to requests for comment.
Council members said their role isn’t to manage day-to-day spending, but instead to deal with the larger questions of which services need to take priority in the annual spending plan, Strassburger said.
“If we’re questioning whether the minutia is correct, there’s a failure somewhere else,” she said.
Without greater access to city systems, council members have to put their faith in the mayor’s office, Councilman Bob Charland said.
“At some level there is a trust you have to have that the budget office is giving us the best information and not willingly misleading you, which I believe is what happened,” Charland said. “One of the legacies the Gainey administration is creating is a mistrust between council and the administration.”
That mistrust didn’t happen overnight. For years, council members sparred publicly and privately with the former mayor.
There were frequent complaints that the Gainey administration did not communicate effectively with council – including on how it planned to spend $8 million in federal funds to address homelessness and affordable housing – and by the end of his term, the majority of council decided to back O’Connor in the contentious primary election last year.
Councilman Bobby Wilson, one of three members to vote against last year’s property tax increase, said he did so because he didn’t trust the numbers they were seeing.
“I felt like we were just shooting in the dark,” Wilson said. “I wanted to know how bad it is before we take these steps. The problem was, I didn’t know.”
Finding a path forward
City officials said that getting Pittsburgh back on solid financial ground will be difficult and require tough decisions. But it’s not an insurmountable challenge.
“We have a lot of work to do, but I'm confident that with this administration we can get this done,” Wilson said.
The goal, according to O’Connor and his team, is to refocus on core services, take a hard look at some of the “extras” the city has been providing, and focus on strategies for long-term growth.
How exactly they get there will be the focus of debate among the nine members of council and the mayoral staff.
“There are certain items that are just givens that we cannot compromise on,” Strassburger said. “We cannot lay off staff. We cannot enact a pay freeze. Those, to me, are just non-negotiables.”
She also suggested that trimming expenses likely wouldn’t include “full cancellations of any one program,” but rather scaling back or finding outside sources of funding.
At the same time, growing economic uncertainty, fueled by international trade disputes and the war in Iran, only adds to the urgency to stabilize the city’s finances and begin to put money back into its dwindling savings account.
“We know there's going to be shocks to the system. We don't know what they are. No one could have predicted COVID, as an extreme,” Gilman said. “That's why you have a rainy day fund — for when it rains.”






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.