A judge has ordered Allegheny County to complete a countywide reassessment — which would be the first in nearly 15 years — to settle a lawsuit a Churchill homeowner filed last year.

Judge Kenneth Valasek ordered a reassessment to be completed by July 2032 after Flavia Laun claimed last year that she was paying more than her fair share of real estate taxes on her Williamsburg Place home due to an “outdated, discriminatory, and non-uniform” county-run assessment system.

The order requires both sides to come together to appoint a “special master” or judge to preside over the reassessment process in the next two months, hold quarterly status conferences to ensure the county complies with the order, and engage with a contractor to begin the reassessment within the next nine months.

“We are pleased that he has provided for an oversight process,” said Ira Weiss, a longtime school district solicitor who also represented Laun in her suit. “We’re also pleased that he approved a very detailed schedule which will keep this process moving.”

Advertise with us

For decades, the debate over reassessments has been one of the most fraught political issues in Allegheny County.

Ever since a backlash to revaluations in the early 2000s helped lead to the ouster of the county’s first executive, Jim Roddey, county leaders have resisted efforts to force them to undertake the complicated process — one that can lead to steep tax increases for some homeowners.

Advocates say the failure to revalue the county’s properties has allowed homeowners in booming, affluent neighborhoods to pay less than their fair share in property taxes, which has shifted more of the cost of funding vital government services onto lower-income residents.

At the same time, many new homeowners have been saddled with higher tax bills than their neighbors. School districts and municipalities often use a new purchase price to appeal a county valuation that can be more than a decade out of date — while the tax assessments of surrounding homes are left untouched.

Laun decided to take action after the Woodland Hills School District appealed a $114,500 assessment on her home in 2022, one year after she had purchased the property for $225,000, according to the complaint.

Advertise with us

The county’s Board of Property Assessment Appeals and Review increased the assessment to $142,9000 in June 2022 and Laun filed an appeal two years later to lower the taxable value.

In the filing, Laun claimed her assessment was “excessive” and “discriminatory” and would force her to pay more than her neighbors in Williamsburg Place, where the 66 residences on her street ranged in assessed value from zero to $214,1000, with the average being $120,994.

The disparity was so “egregious,” it violates the uniformity clause of the state constitution and the equal-protection clauses of the 14th amendment of the U.S. Constitution, the lawsuit stated.

After Valasek issued the order, Laun said she was extremely satisfied with the outcome and the impact her case will have on the county.

“It will only make taxes more fair, and fairness is very important to me and people like me,” she said. “The fact that I used myself as the trigger point for a countrywide reassessment will be helpful to many people in my situation.”

Advertise with us

Every other state mandates regular assessments, except for Pennsylvania — which stopped doing so in the 1970s — leaving the responsibility to county governments.

“While we are still working within an imperfect system, Allegheny County understands today’s court order and will comply in a professional manner with the direction to conduct a countywide reassessment within the next five years and every five years thereafter,” county Executive Sara Innamorato said. “Protecting taxpayers will remain a top priority throughout this process.”

Meanwhile, Valasek said from the bench that Allegheny County Council will continue to move forward on proposed legislation it introduced in March that would require the county to conduct regular countywide reassessments.

Last Week, the Allegheny County Government Commission released a draft report recommending the county adopt a reassessment schedule that would begin the first year of each county executive’s term, creating a “predictable four-year cadence and remove reassessment timing from ordinary political avoidance.”

Mike Suley, chair of Allegheny County’s Board of Property Assessment Appeals, said he believes the most important work County Council has moving forward will be to pass legislation creating a regular reassessment cycle.

Advertise with us

Suley also said removing the politics from the issue by forcing the county to conduct regular reassessments is ultimately a positive development.

“It will create stability and integrity. …The county needs to speak with one voice and work with the judge,” Suley said. “It’s a big deal.”