A recent Pennsylvania Supreme Court ruling has forced the city of Pittsburgh into a mad dash to approve a new tax that primarily targets skill games before state legislators create their own regulations.
The state Supreme Court ruled this week that those long-debated skill games, often found in corner stores and gas stations, qualify as slot machines. The ruling has opened the door for the state to craft new regulations around the easy-to-access gambling devices.
But before that, City Councilman Anthony Coghill is hoping to pass legislation he introduced last month levying a tax on mechanical amusement devices — which includes the video gambling machines, but also pool tables, jukeboxes, dart boards and claw machines — in an effort to add a new revenue stream worth potentially millions of dollars.
“We wanted to factor this in for next year’s budget. In order to do that, we had to be on a warp speed timeline,” Coghill said. “Now I’m glad we’re on that pace, if it becomes a race between us and the state.”
Coghill’s concern is that any regulation the state implements would prohibit local governments from collecting a secondary tax on the gaming devices.
“We still don’t know how [the ruling] might affect my legislation,” he said, but added that he plans to keep moving forward with the proposal.
Read More
At the earliest, the tax could be up for a final vote on June 30 — the same day the state budget is due.
For years, state lawmakers have struggled over how to regulate the video gambling machines and create a new revenue source for the commonwealth.
But now, with the Supreme Court weighing in, Democratic and Republican leadership at the state level have agreed that these ordinances — and the revenue the new rules will likely bring in – will be a key component of this year’s budget.
“We are encouraged that Senate Republicans may now be ready to proceed on bipartisan legislation to regulate skill games, and we look forward to seeing what they can pass in bipartisan fashion in their chamber,” Democratic House leadership said in a joint statement earlier this week.

Democrats and Republicans have long been locked in a stalemate on exactly how high the tax should be on these games. But after the skill game lobbyist groups spent $1.4 million in an unsuccessful effort to oust three Republican state senators in this year’s primary election, lawmakers on both sides of the aisle have said they are more motivated than ever to crack down on the growing industry.
But Pittsburgh leadership is hoping to pass the new tax before the state makes any decisions, to ensure that the city would be grandfathered into keeping their tax on the books, Coghill said.
“We have a lot of work and research and hours into the entire thing,” Coghill said. “So we don’t want that to go to waste.”
The hope, Coghill said, is that even if the state decides to tax the revenue from the skill games, they’ll allow any municipality that had already been collecting a tax off of them to continue doing so.
If not, Pittsburgh will likely have to ax the entire idea. The relatively small fees he is proposing for bars with pool tables and dartboards or arcades wouldn’t bring in enough to offset the cost of enforcement, Coghill said.
The real moneymaker for the city would be the far higher rates charged for gaming terminals, he said.
Businesses that operate those machines would have to pay $1,000 per terminal under the proposed framework. Games where users win prizes, like a claw machine, would be taxed at $100 per device, and others such as pinball and darts would pay $10 per machine.
“If the state, whatever they come up with, supersedes us and says we can’t put a tax on skill games, then we’ll be forced to abandon it,” Coghill said. “The skill games are what the money motivator here is.”

Staring down what could be a $24.4 million deficit at the end of this year, Coghill proposed the new tax as an alternative revenue source that doesn’t put an additional burden on most taxpayers. At the end of last year, City Council raised property tax rates 20%. On top of that, both the county and the school district have increased taxes in recent years.
Coghill said he started pursuing the mechanical amusement device tax last year, before the reality of the city’s finances came to light, as an alternative to having to raise property taxes. Coghill voted against the 2025 tax hike.
“We have to be creative and we have to think of other ways of raising revenue,” he said.
Looking at six municipalities in Allegheny County that already have a similar tax on mechanical gaming devices in place, Coghill’s office said it put together a “conservative estimate” that this could bring in $2 million or $3 million for Pittsburgh.
Up until 2022, businesses that operated these types of games and entertainment machines had to pay $150 for an annual license to operate in the city. In the 10 years before council repealed the license, the city only brought in about $1 million.
Four years ago, council members, including Coghill, voted unanimously to remove the mechanical amusement device license among a handful of other business licenses in an effort to remove red tape.

In the city of Philadelphia, which has nearly five times the population of Pittsburgh, the mechanical amusement tax brought in only $82,000 last year, Philadelphia Deputy Revenue Commissioner Rebecca Lopez Kriss said.
Part of the problem in Pittsburgh and across the state is, because the video gambling machines have been unregulated for so long, it’s difficult to know exactly how many there are. The state has estimated that across the commonwealth there are 70,000 skill games.
“There’s still a lot of unanswered questions,” Coghill said. “But at this point, we’ve decided to just continue down that road.”






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.