The city of Pittsburgh overspent on its 2025 budget by tens of millions of dollars, leaving the city in a “delicate” financial position after years of what City Controller Rachael Heisler has said were questionable budgeting practices.

“I think we need to be vigilant about where things are headed,” Ms. Heisler said Friday during a news conference in which she released the city’s final 2025 financial report. “A problem we can see is a problem we can fix.”

The city overspent its budget by nearly $45 million last year, she said, far exceeding the roughly $9 million deficit previous reviews had shown.

The large discrepancy stems from quarterly reports that measure only money spent during that time. But the annual financial report includes expenses that were accrued but not paid off until 2026, such as the city’s 2025 water bills and legal settlements.

Advertise with us

Ms. Heisler has been sounding the alarm on the city’s budgeting habits for years.

Her report came just over a week after City Council approved more than 70 budget changes initiated by Mayor Corey O’Connor’s administration. Mr. O’Connor’s changes aimed to rightsize the budget, which undercounted for expenses the administration knew they would incur over the next seven months. The new budget cut money City Council had believed should go toward the Food Justice Fund and added spending to retiree healthcare payments and overtime, among other things.

Mr. O’Connor’s changes increased the city’s expected 2026 expenditures by about $30 million, which means officials will have to dip into the rainy day fund to avoid going into a deficit.

The city last year also brought in less money from interest earnings than in 2024 because of the loss of federal COVID-19 relief funds, which had helped buoy the city’s operating budget for several years.

Without the federal dollars, the city would’ve ended 2023 and 2024 in a deficit, Ms. Heisler said.

Advertise with us

“This is the reality we’ve been warning about for the past two years,” Ms. Heisler said. “We’re still spending like we have millions of federal dollars sitting in the bank.”

Digging out of a hole

Ms. Heisler said there are some bright spots from the 2025 review.

The city last year brought in more revenue from earned income and deed transfer taxes than anticipated. Parking and amusement taxes also stabilized and already appear to be higher than they were at this time in 2025.

Some of the short-term work to bolster the city’s financial situation, such as raising the property tax rate by 20%, have already helped generate $20 million more in revenue compared to this time last year.

To keep fixing the city’s budgetary woes, “we need to focus on growth,” Ms. Heisler said.

“We need to focus on core city services,” she said. “We need to make sure we are focused very squarely on delivering our public safety, public works and anything beyond that is a separate conversation we need to have.”