Dozens of Pittsburghers spent their Saturday morning telling City Council members something they likely already knew — residents don’t support a tax increase and they don’t want reductions in critical services.
“This amount seems unreasonable to me, to put all the burden on the property owners of the city of Pittsburgh to balance your budget,” said Chris Parzyck, who said he lived in the city’s 31st Ward, of which Lincoln Place is the largest neighborhood.
Council will vote Sunday on a 2026 budget originally set at $680 million. But that could change based on a vote to increase property taxes. Trying to fill what council members have described as a $20 million to $30 million hole in the budget, Councilwoman Barb Warwick has introduced legislation to increase the city’s property tax by 30%.
That increase could bring in an additional $41 million for the city, and for homeowners whose property is assessed at $100,000, it amounts to about a $20 monthly increase, or $240 a year.
Council members are split on the tax increase, with a number of them already indicating they won’t support a 30% hike and are on the fence about supporting any increase.
Ms. Warwick said Saturday that the actual number will “probably be lower” than 30%.
Read More
“On my way out the door, the last thing I want to do is raise taxes on people already hurting,” said Councilwoman Theresa Kail-Smith, who is retiring at the end of the year. “I will not vote for a 30% increase.”
Many of the residents who turned out for the public hearing Saturday noted that the increase would disproportionately affect lower-income city residents.
“There are households hanging on by their fingernails that don’t have an extra $5 a week,” said Mia Sorada, of East Liberty. “I won’t mince words — a 30% property tax hike for people is disastrous. … This bill takes roofs from over the heads of the most financially vulnerable homeowners and hands the houses to the banks.”
Instead, many of the residents argued, the city should more aggressively pursue an agreement with the large, tax-exempt nonprofit organizations that pay little or no city property taxes.
“I understand we need money for various services — as we’ve seen with these last two snowstorms — but we are putting all this on us, while we are sitting on so many untaxed organizations,” said Mount Washington resident Faith Muse. “We as the working class in the city are always constantly footing every increase the city has.”
For more than a decade, Pittsburgh has been at odds with the Big Five nonprofits — UPMC, Highmark Health, University of Pittsburgh, Carnegie Mellon University and Duquesne University — over ways to pay into city services.
“If they were not exempt by law from almost all of their property taxes in recent years, they would have paid well over $30 million.” Ms. Sorada said.
UPMC alone, if paying property taxes, would pay about $14 million a year, according to a report completed by the city and county controllers’ offices in 2022.
Mayor Ed Gainey made it one of his campaign promises in 2021 to get the nonprofits to “pay their fair share,” but he has had minimal success in legally challenging the tax-exempt status of some of the nonprofit-owned parcels of land.
Incoming Mayor-elect Corey O’Connor has similarly promised to work with the nonprofits but has said he will pursue an agreement with them in which the city makes direct asks that pertain to the nonprofit missions — such as having them pay for new ambulances.
Not everyone at the hearing, however, was staunchly opposed to a tax hike.
“Even though many of us are not rich and don’t have a lot of disposable income, we are people who care about our city,” said Laura Chu Wiens, a Park Place resident.
Ms. Chu Wiens said she and some of her neighbors support a tax increase to fully fund the budget and avoid service cuts.
“I don’t think we can sustain a city of cuts,” she said.
Council members will likely have to approve a tax increase as well as some cuts.
“This isn’t a situation we can cut our way out of,” said council’s budget director, Pete McDevitt.
Council President Dan Lavelle, who has assisted in exploring various cuts the city could make, said he didn’t see a way to balance the budget without raising the millage rate.
Ms. Warwick, at the end of the hearing, acknowledged that raising taxes is not a popular thing to do. In an effort to “take the politics out of it,” she said she was interested in looking into the possibility of creating a mandatory 1% or 2% yearly tax increase.
She also said she plans to look into a capital gains tax, which would tax income made on selling investments such as stocks.
Various community groups also came out to defend and advocate for the allocations they typically receive from the city.
Some wanted to ensure the Food Justice Fund continued to receive support from the city, while others defended the violence prevention work of groups receiving grants from the Stop the Violence Trust Fund and housing assistance from the Housing Opportunity Fund.
In considering possible amendments to the budget on Thursday, Ms. Warwick also suggested allocating another $10 million to repair and replace the city’s vehicle fleet. Without additional revenue, that allocation cannot happen.
While money toward the fleet is needed, Ralph Sicuro, president of Pittsburgh Firefighters Local 1, said his union wants assurances that the additional revenue would “translate into real, measurable improvements” in the fleet.
“Given the city’s history of deferred fleet investment, it is reasonable to ask what processes, safeguards and funding structure will be put in place to ensure any additional, unrestricted revenue results in a reliable fire apparatus,” he said.
Council will hold its final vote on the budget Sunday afternoon. After that, Mr. Gainey has 10 days to either sign or veto the budget. If he vetoes it, council needs six votes to overturn it.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.