Just three days away from the final budget vote, City Council members seem to be at an impasse on how exactly to achieve their goals and balance a budget proposed by the mayor that they have deemed unusable.
While some members are in staunch opposition to a property tax increase, others have submitted amendments that increase spending and can only be achieved if more revenue is added to the budget.
For hours Thursday afternoon, members debated the minutia of the city budget: where to make cuts, where to increase spending and how to do so in the least painful manner.
None of the amendments considered Thursday are legally binding and can still be changed on Sunday ahead of council’s final vote on the budget. However, they do signal where council sees the budget heading. Very few amendments received the support of all nine members — while most had a handful abstaining or opposing them outright.
Some of the amendments seek to cover what council has said are major problems with the Mayor Ed Gainey’s proposed spending levels for overtime and utilities.
Council members Dan Lavelle and Erika Strassburger sponsored amendments that moved to increase the police overtime budget by $8 million and utility payments by $6.5 million. To offset that, the pair also proposed a series of cuts that were a direct result of a memo sent by Council President Dan Lavelle, who requested that each department prepare a report detailing what a 5% cut would look like.
Read More
“We discovered just how bare bones our departments are already,” Mr. Lavelle said Thursday. “The vast majority of them we did not touch because it would affect core services to our residents.”
Cuts included eliminating positions, further cutting spending to the mounted police unit and decreasing allocations for computer upgrades.
Members signaled that they would be willing to vote in favor of those cuts. A sticking point for all of them was a proposed cut to the cost-of-living wage increase that non-union employees get each year. It’s typically 3%, but in a money-saving effort, an amendment to lower that to 2% was introduced but quickly shot down.
Throughout the nearly four-hour long meeting, members often appeared frustrated over the significant cuts that they felt they had to support.
“These cuts all feel ...,” Councilwoman Barb Warwick said, trailing off and shaking her head. “Cuts for the sake of cuts doesn’t seem wise. We’ve seen that at the federal level, just slash and burn to make people feel better.”
“Everything we see here, everything we’re going through, this is what you get when you don’t have people who run departments effectively, when an honest budget doesn’t come over and we’re trying to make it work,” Councilman Bobby Wilson said.
Councilwoman Deb Gross once questioned whether the cuts they were moving to support were actually trimming the fat or if they were “cutting meat and bones.”
But the chair of the Finance and Law Committee, Councilwoman Erika Strassburger, said the reductions were necessary.
“When we are asking the people of Pittsburgh to help us dig ourselves out of the budgetary hole we’re in, I think it’s only fair that we take a look at every single department and every single program that we have,” she said.
She said that the cuts were the “responsible thing to do, in addition to raising revenue for the city.”
At the same time, Ms. Warwick also proposed using an additional $10 million to repair and replace vehicles in the city’s aging fleet, and suggested adding new positions in various departments that the department heads said were “urgent” employment moves.
“I feel voting for this puts us in a box where we’re forced to raise taxes,” Councilman Anthony Coghill said of the additional fleet allocation. “I haven’t come to terms with that yet.”
In total, the amendments that were given the OK on Thursday would increase the city’s spending by millions and could only be offset by a revenue increase, which will likely come through a property tax hike.
A 30% property tax increase is on the table, and while there was no direct conversation about that proposal on Thursday, the possibility of additional revenue underpinned much of the discussion.
Council cannot deliberate the millage increase until after Saturday’s public hearing on the proposal.
A 30% increase would bring in about $41 million in extra revenue, which would allow for more spending on the city’s fleet and the additional positions requested by leaders of Public Works and the Department of Mobility and Infrastructure. But members could opt for a smaller tax increase Sunday before the final vote, or choose to not increase taxes at all.
It’s unclear what the budget will look like come the final vote, and Thursday’s meeting left many on council with unanswered questions.
Borrowing an old adage from former Mayor Bill Peduto’s first chief of staff, Kevin Acklin, council Budget Director Pete McDevitt said, “We’re building the plane while we fly it.”






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.