In yet another blow to Pittsburgh’s precarious finances, some of the city’s key departments have already exceeded their allotted overtime and premium pay by millions of dollars, with months still to go before the year ends.
Driven by critical staffing shortages in public safety — police and emergency medical services in particular — the city spent at least $5.5 million more in overtime through the end of September than officials had predicted for all of 2025, according to a report from City Controller Rachael Heisler.
If that pace continues, the city is on track to spend almost $20 million more than it had planned for employees in the Public Safety and Public Works departments, the report warns.
The millions in excess spending comes as the city is grappling with falling property tax revenue and a recent state Supreme Court decision that eliminated the so-called Jock Tax — a fee levied on visiting athletes and performers that officials were counting on to generate more than $6 million a year.
The dire report from Ms. Heisler, which was shared with city council this week, bears out the concerns raised a year ago by some officials who had warned that Mayor Ed Gainey’s administration was significantly underestimating how much overtime it would have to pay its most essential workers this year.
Mr. Gainey’s office did not immediately respond to a request for comment. Officials in his administration have repeatedly told council members that the city’s financial challenges were manageable without making major changes.
Read More
Earlier this month, Deputy Mayor Jake Pawlak, who also oversees the Office of Management and Budget, said the city’s financial picture “looks strong.”
Despite concerns raised by some on council late last year, city leaders slashed $2 million from the police overtime budget and $425,000 from the fire department.
Through the end of last month, both had blown past the new, lower spending targets, with police $1 million over budget and firefighters more than $850,000 over.
For EMS, which has struggled in recent years to fill all of the positions it needs to be fully staffed, the spending is even further off. Despite an overtime budget of less than $3.6 million, the bureau has spent more than $6 million so far this year.
In Public Works, the department responsible for crucial infrastructure and maintenance projects across the city, overtime payments are already nearly $2.3 million more than officials had planned to spend.
For months, alarm had been growing about the city’s ability to live within its budget.
As far back as April, Councilwoman Erika Strassburger warned of a “full-blown crisis” and “imminent financial disaster” driven by the overtime spending. This summer, Ms. Heisler said the city’s spending was outpacing its revenue at an “unsustainable” rate.
And last year, a Post-Gazette investigation into the mayor’s spending plan found that the city was facing imminent threats to its finances that could lead to a fiscal crisis it had not seen in a generation.
The city was already planning to spend more than $100 million from its reserve fund over the next five years — even if it had hit all of its revenue and spending targets.
As the financial picture has worsened, some lawmakers are already looking for ways to stabilize the city’s finances with just a week to go before voters choose the city’s next mayor.
Councilwoman Theresa Kail-Smith said she planned to introduce legislation that would call for partial hiring and spending freezes to avoid raising taxes to balance the budget.
“I don’t know how we could possibly raise taxes ... on the people who have had their county taxes increase, school district taxes increase, and we’re delivering less services,” she said.
The proposal would halt the hiring of current vacant and newly vacant positions except under certain circumstances, and freeze all non-essential purchases.
The plan also seeks to pause future grants to nonprofits, restrict non-essential travel outside the city, curb non-essential overtime except for certain departments including Public Safety and Public Works, and limit the use of city procurement cards to select departments, including Parks and Recreation, Public Safety, and Public Works. Ms. Kail-Smith noted Tuesday that the pause to grants would not impact the Stop the Violence fund or the Food Justice Fund.
”I think it would be great if our nonprofits announced that they see Pittsburgh struggling and that they’re going to come up with some way to help us through this,” she said. “They’ve been very great partners in many ways and delivered a lot of things to our community. But it would be great if both our nonprofit and our corporate world would come together.”
The city was previously on track to be over budget by about $20 million. This summer, there was about $200 million in the city’s reserve fund. But Ms. Heisler said at the time that those funds should be used for emergencies, not general operations.
The city’s trust fund spending — often for reimbursable activities, grants or restricted-use programs where spending is authorized when revenue is available — is almost $1.7 million past its $8.4 million overtime budget. The major bulk of trust fund overtime budget, almost $7.5 million, is for secondary duties for police; as of the end of the third quarter, that total is at 88% of the year’s budgeted overtime.
But trust fund spending so far includes tens or hundreds of thousands of dollars in unbudgeted overtime for parks, senior programs, EMS for events and more. The city noted that some trust fund spending may “appear as ‘unbudgeted’ or lack a direct budget comparison, even though the expenditures are expected and permissible within the scope of each fund’s purpose.”
City officials have also warned that the draft of the 2026 budget severely underestimates spending on overtime for the Public Safety and Public Works departments. Mr. Gainey will introduce his preliminary budget next month and council will have until the end of the year to make adjustments and give their final approval.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.