On two separate occasions Gisele Baretto Fetterman was the first person to notice that something wasn’t right with husband, U.S. Senator John Fetterman.
The first time was in May 2022, when traveling across Pennsylvania she noticed his mouth droop on just one side, for just a moment. She had insisted — against Mr. Fetterman’s wishes — they go to a hospital, where a doctor told them he had suffered a stroke.
Then later that year, she noticed him acting “less and less like himself.”
Ms. Fetterman recounts these two pivotal moments in the senator’s career and many other moments of their often publicized life in her 240-page new book, “Radical Tenderness, the Value of Vulnerability in an Often Unkind World” released July 8.
In the candid book, Ms. Fetterman opens up about the days after her husband’s recovery from a stroke and his treatment of depression. She also writes about her experience of being an undocumented immigrant as a child, being confused for “the help” on occasion and a close relationship she formed with Connie Schultz, former Ohio Sen. Sherrod Brown’s wife.
It seems, at times, she was the only one who could get through to Mr. Fetterman, the former Pennsylvania lieutenant governor who had just mounted a historic win against daytime television star Dr. Mehmet Oz, winning all 67 counties in Pennsylvania to become the state’s next U.S. senator.
Read More
“I finally told him, ‘John, if something happens and you die tomorrow, the kids are going to remember you as a really sad person. Is that what you want?’” she wrote in her new book.
The next day, Mr. Fetterman checked himself in Walter Reed Medical Center, setting off another flurry of media attention on the family and questions from other lawmakers wondering if Mr. Fetterman was fit to serve.
Popular in her own right after founding and co-founding multiple nonprofits, Ms. Fetterman was no stranger to the news media.
But in the days after her husband checked into treatment, “the media attention was unbearable,” she wrote.
To avoid news crews outside her home in Braddock, Ms. Fetterman packed up their three children and drove to Toronto.
“Coping with mental health challenges in a public setting opened John (and me) up to ridicule and intense criticism,” she wrote. “It was the first time a politician had been so quickly and publicly vulnerable about depression or mental health challenges, so while some media attention was not surprising, I did not expect it to skew toward such cruelty.”
She was criticized for going to Canada, and an ongoing conspiracy theory that she was plotting to steal Mr. Fetterman’s Senate seat persisted despite Ms. Fetterman’s very public opinion that she hates politics.
As the family was viewing Mr. Fetterman’s recovery from his stroke as a success story, he was being mocked and criticized for his speech. He had developed a stutter and an auditory processing disorder following the stroke.
“I had to both process my feelings and respond to questions, requests and criticisms from the public in real time,” Ms. Fetterman wrote. “While I was horrified by how the media was painting both John and me, when we were both doing the best we could, it was also not my most pressing concern.”
She said she didn’t care if she developed a negative reputation for how she responded to those requests and criticisms. Her goal was getting her family through each day.
“Because John is a public figure, we had no choice about whether what our family was going through could remain behind closed doors,” she wrote. “But I did have a choice in the value that I placed on others’ opinions, and it was very little.”
Despite being a self-proclaimed “crybaby,” Ms. Fetterman often takes the critiques in stride. She once was added to a social media poll voting for the “worst wife in America” alongside Jada Pinkett Smith, Meghan Markle and Jill Biden.
To commemorate the poll last year, Ms. Fetterman posted on her social media “feels like yesterday that I was up for this prestigious award.”
But, as she writes in her book, it isn’t always easy to deal with the scrutiny and near-constant criticism that comes from being married to a politician, particularly one who has been the subject of many headlines over the past few years.
Beyond the stroke and his mental health, Mr. Fetterman has made waves for his stance on the war between Israel and Hamas, and even further speculations about his mental fitness to serve after former staffers raised concerns once again about his mental health.
Ms. Fetterman is also a very proud immigrant, which in addition to being a politician’s wife, has put her under even more scrutiny to be, as some people have called her, “one of the good ones,” she wrote in the book. She immigrated to the U.S. from Brazil with her mother as a young girl and after their visitor’s visa expired, they were briefly undocumented immigrants.
Throughout her time in the public eye, Ms. Fetterman has been a staunch supporter of immigrants.
On two separate occasions, Ms. Fetterman was mistaken as part of the catering staff for a party hosted at her home in Braddock, and later a stranger thought she was her own children’s babysitter rather than their mother.
Another time she was confronted by a woman in the grocery store who said Ms. Fetterman had “ruined John’s bloodline.” The woman followed her out of the store, yelling racial slurs.
“In that moment, I didn’t have the energy to think of something witty to say, nor do I think she deserved any response,” Ms. Fetterman wrote in the book. “I was shaken and in shock and sat sobbing in my car for a long time.”
But now, Ms. Fetterman said she no longer feels “the need to correct people” when they make assumptions.
“I have realized and internalized that how other people choose to behave has nothing to do with me,” she wrote.
Mr. Fetterman has jumped to her defense at times, like in February 2020 when he posted a photo of her attending a Brazilian Carnival event in Pittsburgh. The celebration, in addition to parades and dancing, is also known for it’s bright, sparkling and often revealing outfits.
Shortly after his post, many were critical of Ms. Fetterman for her revealing outfit — some of which Mr. Fetterman blocked on Twitter.
But because the social media website is a designated public forum and Mr. Fetterman is an elected official, blocking them was a violation of their freedom of speech.
“Never could I have imagined that my Carnival outfit could lead to a legal crisis,” she wrote in the book. “Something that started out lighthearted quickly became a serious political issue.”
To deal with that problem and many others that have appeared, Ms. Fetterman said she turned to her community service, and when she needed someone who knew what she was going through, she connected with Connie Schultz, former Ohio Sen. Sherrod Brown’s wife.
“We’ve seen how women politicians are lampooned in the media, and the wives of politicians are not exempt from this sort of treatment,” she wrote in the book. “Connie was always a willing and generous listener, someone who could speak from experience about what I was encountering.”






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.