Despite months of passionate debate, Pittsburgh City Council quietly struck down a plan that would give city neighborhoods the power to decide whether they wanted inclusionary zoning added to new developments.
In December, Councilman Bob Charland introduced the legislation as a counter to a plan that Mayor Ed Gainey had presented in September, which would make inclusionary zoning mandatory across the city.
Inclusionary zoning already exists in parts of the city, namely Lawrenceville and Bloomfield, and it requires that any development over 20 units make at least 10% of the units affordable to tenants who make at or less than 50% of the area median income, which is about $40,500 for a family of two.
After a 10-hour Planning Commission meeting in January, the commission negatively recommended Mr. Charland’s bill and positively recommended Mr. Gainey’s. Negatively recommending a bill means council shouldn’t approve it.
In a 7-2 vote among council members on Tuesday, only Mr. Charland and Councilman Anthony Coghill supported Mr. Charland’s legislation. Because of the negative recommendation from the planning commission, Mr. Charland’s legislation would have needed seven votes to pass.
The dueling proposals have drawn significant public opinion, much of which came during the competitive mayoral primary race. Mr. Charland supported Mr. Gainey’s opponent, Allegheny County Controller Corey O’Connor, who went on to win the Democratic primary.
Read More
Mr. O’Connor has said he does not support a citywide inclusionary zoning measure.
The goal of Mr. Gainey’s measure — and a large focus of his administration — is to increase the number of affordable housing units in the city.
Arguments made by some opposed to Mr. Gainey’s proposal have said that inclusionary zoning requirements stifle development, though a report recently completed by City Controller Rachael Heisler determined there isn’t enough data to support that argument.
“I believe that we should work together to pass a compromise inclusionary zoning bill that really works,” Councilwoman Erika Strassburger said during a public hearing in June. “I'll note that it's far from the only solution to increase affordable units.”
Others have suggested that the months-long debate — Mr. Gainey introduced his proposal last September — has been stalling current developments.
“Since we are pending approval with the mayor's version of [inclusionary zoning], there is some hesitancy to submit applications to build in Pittsburgh for anything that's 20 units or more,” Councilman Bobby Wilson said last month. “We should definitely keep that in mind and make sure that we have the reversal of that.”
It’s currently unclear when council will bring Mr. Gainey’s proposal back to the table. They begin their summer recess later this month and return in late August.
Mr. Charland’s bill had to be voted on before Mr. Gainey’s could come to council, as council rules prohibit two conflicting bills to be considered at the same time.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.