As executive orders from President Donald Trump and rulings from the U.S. Supreme Court roll back protections for members of the LGBTQ+ community, Pittsburgh lawmakers and activists are looking to preemptively codify anti-discrimination measures.
New legislation introduced Tuesday morning by Pittsburgh City Council member Barb Warwick seeks to classify the refusal or denial of medical care based on a person’s gender identity or expression as discrimination.
In the spring, UPMC, the city’s largest medical care provider, canceled surgeries scheduled for young trans patients and confirmed that they would be winding down much of the gender affirming care they were providing.
To comply with recent federal directives, UPMC will have major cuts to gender affirming care starting June 30.
While the new legislation won’t give the city any power to force UPMC to resume care, it does give patients impacted a venue to have a discrimination case adjudicated. The city’s Commission on Human Rights is charged with handling all discrimination allegations.
“I would encourage anyone who’s experiencing that [discrimination] individually to reach out to us,” Rachel Shepherd, the executive director of the commission, said during a news conference Tuesday morning.
Read More
UPMC did not immediately respond to requests for comment regarding the proposed legislation.
Ms. Shepherd said that since November, when Trump was elected into office, the commission has seen record numbers of discrimination inquiries on the basis of gender identity.
“Federal actions have local consequences, and now our neighbors are facing cuts to critical services that jeopardize their well being,” she said. “Today, with the support of city council and local advocates, we are making it abundantly clear it is discriminatory in the city of Pittsburgh to deny medical services to someone based on real or perceived gender identity or gender expression.”
Pittsburgh has historically been on the forefront of protecting marginalized groups. The city passed legislation that added gender identity and gender expression as protected statuses in 2014 — six years before the Supreme Court made those protections on the federal level.
Ms. Warwick introduced two other pieces of legislation on Tuesday morning to add protections to marginalized groups. The first would de-prioritize the enforcement of any state or federal level laws that criminalize actions on the basis of a person’s identity rather than the action itself.
“In other words, if no one is coming to arrest me for doing something as a cisgender woman, then no one should be coming to arrest me for doing it as a trans person,” Ms. Warwick said.
This, if passed by council, would act as a shield law, in case the state or federal government passes restrictive laws in the future.
“We should not live in a world where we need this ordinance,” said Nicky Ripley, an attorney and community advocate that helped craft the legislation. “But given the ongoing efforts to erode our civil rights and the rule of law, it is essential that the city of Pittsburgh guarantee its citizens sanctuary from the unconstitutional attacks on our rights to love who we love and be our authentic selves.”
The final piece of legislation would reduce the penalty for sex work in the city from a misdemeanor to a summary violation. That would reduce the legal sentence from jail time and a fine to just a lesser fine or community service.
The new legislation would “empower law enforcement to focus on protecting people rather than punishing them, and it allows workers to not have their lives severely impacted by criminal charges which can result in issues with custody, finding housing, obtaining different types of employment and more,” said Theresa Nightingale, the executive director of the Pittsburgh Coalition for Safer Sex Work.
Ms. Nightingale also said this ordinance could free up the city’s police officers to “concentrate on addressing real crime” rather than punishing those who participate in consensual sex work.
The three new ordinances will be up for discussion among council next week.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.