An evaporating pool of tenured leadership and looming budget constraints could leave Pittsburgh’s next mayor in a difficult spot when it comes to what observers say will be one of the most critical leadership decisions he will face.
“This is one thing the new mayor must get right for the sake of the police department itself,” said David Harris, a University of Pittsburgh law professor who has spent years observing police and policing in Pittsburgh.
Whether the next chief comes from within the bureau or not, he or she will take over a department that, for the last three years, has spent more time with an acting chief than a permanent one.
“You really have to stabilize the organization — put somebody in charge who will bring that kind of solid leadership that people can depend on,” Mr. Harris said.
But whom?
Two of Pittsburgh’s three highest-ranking police officers plan to retire in the coming months, thinning the city’s police brass to an acting chief and a slew of commanders filling in as assistant chiefs, and lieutenants filling in as commanders.
Read More
City Council’s vote last week to extend Martin Devine’s tenure as acting chief gives a short-lived measure of continuity to the bureau and sets the stage for the next mayor to shape police leadership in his own vision.
Acting Chief Devine, sources say, has no desire to take over the role permanently.
And the only other assistant chiefs — Christopher Ragland and Richard Ford — are set to retire this summer.
Years of attrition have thinned the ranks of police leadership in Pittsburgh, which limits the pool of internal candidates available to either Democratic candidate Corey O’Connor or Republican candidate Tony Moreno — whomever wins the November general election.
At the same time, the city will likely see a serious financial squeeze in the coming months and years, leaving little room for luxuries like a nationwide chief search.
“That’s what happens when you don’t pay attention,” said Beth Pittinger, executive director of the Citizen Police Review Board who has spent decades watching the ebbs and flows of the bureau. “It’s a neglect of that whole organization — it’s just too bad.”
“Boy, what a mess it’s going to be,” she said.
There will be internal issues to fix: Police officers are leaving Pittsburgh far faster than the city can recruit them, specialty units have been spread thin, and the city is burning through its public safety overtime pay at a rate that exceeds the budget.
Those issues lead to others, specifically in terms of morale and messaging. There likely isn’t any one thing that’s causing the exodus and hampering recruitment, and it’s certainly not the fault of interim leadership or the lieutenants and sergeants working the streets, Mr. Harris said.
“They’re doing the best they can with what they have and the guidance that they get,” he said. “If you go through five chiefs in three years, it’s going to start to feel like the question every day when you come in is, ‘who’s in charge and where are we going?’”
Scott Schubert, who was appointed chief by former mayor Bill Peduto, bowed out several months into Mayor Ed Gainey’s term.
Thomas Stangrecki was acting chief during the nearly one-year process to bring in Larry Scirotto following a nationwide search.
Mr. Scirotto left amid scrutiny 18 months later, and Mr. Gainey appointed Christopher Ragland acting chief. The job was all but Mr. Ragland’s before he withdrew his nomination because of what he alleged were unethical overtures by some city council members.
The tumult goes beyond the revolving door of leadership: The department has been hemorrhaging officers for years.
That wasn’t abnormal during the early years of the COVID-19 pandemic, when most law enforcement organizations saw more retirements and resignations than recruits. But in many places that tide has slowly begun to turn in recent years or, at the very least, the bleeding has slowed.
That’s not been the case in Pittsburgh, where resignations and retirements in 2023 and 2024 far outpaced even those at the height of the pandemic: 79 in 2021, 75 in 2022, and then 101 in 2023 and 105 in 2024.
Mr. Ragland has been using vacation and other time off until his retirement officially takes effect, and Mr. Ford will retire this summer to become Crafton’s first new police chief in more than a decade.
Three commanders are already serving as acting assistant chiefs, and some lieutenants, too, are filling in as acting commanders. Of the bureau’s 44 commanders and lieutenants, three plan to retire over the summer.
Mr. Harris said violent crime hasn’t increased amid the turmoil.
“We’re not slipping into danger that way, but this is an agency with first-line responsibility for creating public safety for everyone — you can’t let it tread water for too long,” he said.
‘Lean years ahead’
Ms. Pittinger said opening the position for applications without the fanfare of bringing in an expensive search firm to recruit and vet possibilities isn’t a bad thing.
“There’s nothing wrong with just going, ‘OK, we have this job opening, let’s see who applies,’” she said. “You don’t have to go do an $80,000 search — that’s ridiculous. What we saw with the last [nationwide search], with the secret panels? No.”
Indeed, the relatively secretive nature of the last nationwide search left a bad taste in some mouths. The city organized three panels to meet with candidates and report back to the administration: One made up of the mayor’s top advisers, one of police union members, and one of community members.
Community members were named publicly, but they and the police union members were asked to sign non-disclosure agreements regarding the process.
The search itself was carried out by California-based Public Sector Search & Consulting to the tune of $80,000, though that doesn’t include the flights and hotels stays for finalists that the city likely footed the bill for.
At the end of the day, Ms. Pittinger said, the mayor still makes the nomination and council still approves or nixes it, whether a panel has recommended the individual or not.
Mr. O’Connor, for his part, has said he would not “waste taxpayer money on a national search.”
That’s perhaps for the best, as the city is staring down what the current administration calls “lean years ahead” and what the city’s controller has called a dire financial crisis. By either definition, money will be tight.
Mr. O’Connor told supporters after his primary win last month that he would look for “somebody with the knowledge of Pittsburgh that worked here for many years and wants to come back.”
It was a fairly specific pledge that indicated Mr. O’Connor — who is all but assured a November election win in a heavily Democrat city that hasn’t elected a Republican mayor in 96 years — already has someone in mind.
An obvious contender could be Jason Lando, a popular longtime Pittsburgh police commander who has led the Frederick, Md., police since 2021. He was one of three finalists in 2023 for the job that ultimately went to Mr. Scirotto.
Mr. Harris said the next mayor should be talking to relatively recent departures, even if it’s not to try to coax them back to Pittsburgh or out of retirement.
“The best gauge [for what the department needs] is talking to people who have somewhat recently been in the department,” he said, “so you talk to Tom Stangrecki, you talk to Schubert, you talk to Jason Lando, you talk to Ragland.”
— Hallie Lauer contributed to this report






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.