Despite clear aggravation over the process, Pittsburgh City Council passed a measure to reduce the minimum lot sizes in an effort to increase the city’s housing supply and lower development costs.

The change, which passed with eight votes on Tuesday, would allow developers to build on lots smaller than currently allowed by city code in each of the five density levels: very low, low, moderate, high and very high.

The bill to reduce the minimum lot sizes was part of Mayor Ed Gainey’s package to overhaul the city’s zoning code and some council members balked at the idea of it being taken separately, without the rest of the legislation.

Though Mr. Gainey presented the bills as a package, City Council still has to discuss and vote on each one individually.

Advertise with us

During the preliminary vote last week, Councilwoman Deb Gross voted against the legislation and council members Barb Warwick and Dan Lavelle abstained from the vote. All three said they supported the language of the legislation, but wanted to see it as part of the package, particularly with the bill to expand inclusionary zoning.

“This bill, in isolation, will not have the impact as it would have as part of the larger package,” Ms. Gross said Tuesday morning. “I encourage council to take up all of the other reforms, including expanding inclusionary zoning … so that we can talk about how to increase affordability coherently.”

Mr. Gainey’s inclusionary zoning bill, which would mandate citywide that any development over 20 units set aside 10% of them to be priced at or below 50% the area median income, or $40,500 a year for a family of two, has been hotly contested and become a focal point of his re-election campaign.

Councilman Bob Charland — who has endorsed Mr. Gainey’s opponent Allegheny County Controller Corey O’Connor — has introduced his own competing IZ bill that would leave the option of the zoning change to the individual neighborhoods.

Ms. Warwick said last week that she wanted to wait to vote on the minimum lot sizes bill so that it could be considered with Mr. Gainey’s inclusionary zoning bill. She said that the change to the minimum lot sizes was supposed to act as an incentive to get housing developers on board with the IZ legislation.

Advertise with us

“If we pass this first before we do IZ, given the votes on this council … to me it just feels like IZ is dead,” she said during a council meeting last week. “There will be no motivation for anybody.”

Councilman Bobby Wilson, the sponsor of the legislation, brought it forward for council’s consideration.

“This bill decreases the cost of housing without costing the city anything,” he said, adding that he thought some of the arguments for taking this bill with IZ was misleading.

“The public is being misled that this is a campaign to hold developers accountable and force them to do something they don’t want to do,” he said. “Developers just want to build.”

Mr. Wilson has also endorsed Mr. O’Connor, who does not support a citywide IZ mandate.

Advertise with us

Mr. Lavelle said he is supportive of the bill but he wanted a broader conversation about the housing package, which he believed couldn’t be done until Mr. Charland’s opposing IZ bill was “dealt with.”

Mr. Charland’s bill is up for discussion during this Wednesday’s standing committee meeting.

Councilwoman Erika Strassburger though, said that she would like to see — and has heard from constituents that they would also like — to have each bill discussed fully one by one.

“This process has been flawed from the beginning,” she said last week, adding that by trying to take the multiple bills as a package it has actually “diluted the amount the community has had to weigh in on the bill.”

She also noted that many of the developers she spoke with said that for them to be on board with IZ, they needed more gap funding sources to help cover the costs.