PG Politics is written by Hallie Lauer, the Post-Gazette's city government and politics reporter. Each Wednesday, she'll take readers inside the halls of Grant Street and deliver unparalleled reporting on Pittsburgh City Council and the race for Pittsburgh mayor. You'll also see dispatches from our reporting teams all across Western Pennsylvania, Harrisburg and Capitol Hill in Washington, D.C.

To get this content exclusively a day earlier, use this link to subscribe to the newsletter.

In an effort to contrast President Donald Trump’s explosion of executive orders, Pittsburgh Mayor Ed Gainey signed two of his own orders last week focused on fighting housing discrimination.

“Trump and the MAGA machine are using executive orders to move fast and break the federal government and produce an enormous amount of human suffering in the process,” Mr. Gainey, a Democrat up for re-election, said last week. “I’m using the executive orders to strengthen our own safety nets and protect our civil rights.”

Advertise with us

Executive orders are rare among Pittsburgh mayors, and while Mr. Gainey might have been attempting to show the benefit of the orders, he may have some things in common with Trump’s orders: the potential for legal pushback.

One of the orders Mr. Gainey signed Friday is very similar to legislation City Council in 2015. The Pennsylvania Supreme Court ultimately struck that down.

The order in question prohibits landlords and developers who receive public funds from rejecting tenants based on their source of income. It specifically targets discrimination some tenants face when they use Housing Choice Vouchers, otherwise known as Section 8, which are vouchers that allow low-income tenants to pay a portion of their rent while federal subsidies pay the rest.

Councilman Dan Lavelle was a co-sponsor on the 2015 legislation which sought to do the same thing, with two key differences. Mr. Lavelle’s legislation didn’t include developers and it applied to all landlords, not just those that received public funds.

The city argued in court that the goal was to combat greater racial discrimination in the city by reducing housing-voucher discrimination. But the Apartment Association of Metropolitan Pittsburgh argued that it placed an excessive burden on the landlords by forcing them to accept vouchers, and they then would also have to comply with other regulations like using specific lease agreements and inspection requirements.

Advertise with us

State law says that municipalities under a home rule charter, like Pittsburgh, cannot place “duties, responsibilities or requirements” on businesses. They are, though, allowed to expand anti-discrimination protections beyond what is protected at the state level, something city officials have done a number of times.

Mr. Lavelle, who is also the vice chair of the Urban Redevelopment Board, seemed confident last week that adding the stipulation of receiving public money will be enough to protect from future lawsuits.

We passed legislation to protect voucher holders, and the courts struck it down,” he said Friday. “Today’s announcement makes sure those protections are back — at least where we still have control: local investments.”

This is also already a policy within the URA for landlords receiving funding assistance. Further, now that Mr. Gainey has signed it into law, developers risk losing future public funds and possibly having to return the funds they received to the city.

Legal concerns aside, there’s a touch of Pittsburgh political deja vu in this. While the initial lawsuit against Mr. Lavelle’s legislation was filed in early 2016, the state Supreme Court started hearing the case in April 2021 — when the city was similarly caught up in a competitive Democratic mayoral primary race.

Advertise with us

Affordable housing and protecting tenants were key parts of Mr. Gainey’s campaign then and remain so now.

Mr. Gainey has focused much of his campaign on fighting back against Trump and the “MAGA machine.” But at a time when universities, federal offices and medical facilities are shying away from diversity, equity and inclusion efforts, Mr. Gainey’s efforts to double down on protections for Pittsburgh residents might earn him some much-needed votes.

Fetterman legislation proposes improved access to contraceptives

WASHINGTON — U.S. Sen. John Fetterman is pressing Congress to improve access to contraceptives, introducing legislation this week that would let those covered by private health insurance receive up to a year’s supply under their plans.

The cost of the contraceptives would be required to be covered by private health insurance plans under the bill, which Mr. Fetterman, D-Pa., introduced in the Senate Tuesday and Rep. Lauren Underwood, a Democrat from Illinois, introduced in the House.

The senator’s office noted that many states already adopted this practice, but most contraceptive users still receive only a three-month supply or less, “needlessly wasting personal time while adding unnecessary paperwork.”

Advertise with us

The Convenient Contraception Act comes as Democrats seek to blunt the U.S. Supreme Court’s Dobbs decision that overturned longstanding abortion rights under Roe v. Wade.

Many Republican-led states since Dobbs have aimed to restrict abortion and contraceptive access, but Democratic lawmakers say Mr. Fetterman’s legislation would lower the burdens for patients and decrease the chances of “gaps in protection,” the senator’s office said.

“I will always fight to protect a woman’s right to make her own health care decisions,” Mr. Fetterman said in a statement. “This bill would allow patients to pick up their full prescriptions at once, improving access to contraception by simply making it more convenient.

The proposed bill faces an uphill battle with the GOP controlling both chambers of Congress.

But it is supported so far by almost two dozen Democrats across the Senate and House, along with the American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists, Catholics for Choice, National Women’s Law Center, Reproductive Freedom for All and other advocacy groups.

Advertise with us

— Benjamin Kail

This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.