For many months, John Kenstowicz has spoken at jail oversight board and County Council meetings, describing what he sees as the stress and challenges seen by hundreds of correctional officers and medical staff at the Allegheny County Jail.

Now, the decades-long clinical social worker, who has spent countless hours on jail-related issues, wants to use a seldom-known charter provision to get council to act on two issues that could help — some use of the restraint chair and leg shackles, both of which aren’t in place now.

Mr. Kenstowicz said in a recent interview that he is working with county officials and an attorney to gather enough signatures to force council to vote on issues through a charter provision known as an “agenda initiative.”

According to the charter, if a person gathers 500 signatures from registered county voters on petitions on a single subject “germane to County government,” then council must consider the proposed subject within 60 days of receiving it.

Advertise with us

Limited use of the restraint chair and shackles would be two separate petition issues, Mr. Kenstowicz said. The shackles would only be used in medical transports to hospitals, and the restraint chair would be used for that, alongside if inmates are having a mental health crisis and could cause harm to themselves and others, he said.

Those changes would not only help keep medical staff and correctional officers safe during hospital transports and evaluations, but it would also allow for adequate medical evaluations, Ms. Kenstowicz said.

Supporters of the changes, which include the correctional officers’ union president, say they’re needed in order to create a safer work environment. Those opposed believe that it would violate a referendum that county voters passed in May 2021, which banned solitary confinement in most circumstances and also –-- depending on who is asked — the use of the restraint chair and leg shackles.

Opponents say allowing the use of shackles and the restraint chair would violate the will of voters, but Mr. Kenstowicz disputes that, saying the language in the referendum was unclear outside of the solitary confinement question.

He added that inmates need to be restrained in order for proper medical care, even if opponents believe that violates people’s civil liberties. He’s been told that medical staff walk away from certain situations because they feel unsafe.

Advertise with us

“I don't think it's a violation of a person's liberty when they're at risk … and many of these people are in an altered state of mind, where they really need an intervention to correct a situation that could get much worse,” Mr. Kenstowicz said.

It’s unclear when both issues could face a council vote. County Council President Patrick Catena said that the issues are being “actively negotiated” among council members, and declined further comment.

An official in County Executive Sara Innamorato’s administration said there has been no discussions about Mr. Kenstowicz’s proposals. Ms. Innamorato sits on the jail oversight board, and part of her campaign in 2023 focused on improving conditions inside the county jail.

Mr. Kenstowicz’s attempt to use the “agenda initiative” portion of the charter is the first time it’s been used since 2017, according to County Council staff.

The Post-Gazette reported in 2016 and 2017 that residents around Allegheny County were concerned about voting machines. In July 2017, a coalition led by the League of Women Voters and election transparency group Vote Allegheny worked on gathering enough petition signatures to create a 13-person “Voter Process Review Commission” which would have been tasked with reviewing the county’s thousands of voting machines.

Advertise with us

By August 2017, the coalition said they had the 500 signatures to get it on the council agenda, the Post-Gazette reported. Council staff said that petition was presented to council on July 24, 2017, but the county solicitor’s office deemed it was legally insufficient in the following weeks, so it never reached a council vote.

Despite that history and potential opposition, Mr. Kenstowicz said he is confident he will collect enough signatures for both the restraint chair and leg shackles issue.

“Everybody on my end is moving forward with this,” he said.