In what appears to be a direct effort to block an ongoing attempt to require the city of Pittsburgh to divest from Israel, city council members introduced two referendum questions Wednesday that could nullify the divest efforts if everything is approved by voters.

Not on Our Dime, a coalition of local volunteers has been collecting signatures to add a question to the ballot that asks voters if the Home Rule Charter should be amended to require the city to divest from any country “engaged in genocide and apartheid — such as the state of Israel — and corporations doing business with them.”

Organizers have said their overarching goal is to align the city’s finances with its “moral standards.”

The question is similar to one raised last summer that ultimately never made it on the ballot after challenges were filed.

Advertise with us

During Wednesday morning’s city council meeting, members introduced legislation that would direct the Allegheny County Board of Elections to add two additional questions to the ballot. The first would be to prohibit amendments to the charter from adding “duties or obligations beyond the lawful scope of the city’s authority.” The second would be to add anti-discrimination language that would prevent the city from doing business with a person or entity based on a number of demographics including national origin or affiliation with any foreign nation.

A major criticism of the divest efforts in Pittsburgh are in regards to Pennsylvania’s anti-boycott, divestment and sanctions law. Enacted in 2016, the law bans any business that does work with or for the state from working with a company that boycotts Israel for political reasons.

Should residents pass the divestment referendum, the city could be in violation of this law, opponents have argued. Beyond that, state entities like the Department of Transportation would not be permitted to contract with the city.

“Certain far-reaching ballot initiative efforts, if successful, would amend the Home Rule Charter to add functions or duties that exceed the limits imposed upon the City by the Constitution of the United States, the Pennsylvania Constitution, and the laws of Pennsylvania,” the newly introduced legislation says. “For practical and legal reasons, it is in the best interests of the City of Pittsburgh to avoid the adoption of inherently unlawful proposals.”

The second referendum question asks city residents if the charter should be amended to prohibit “the discrimination on the basis of race, religion, national origin or association or affiliation with any nation or foreign state in conducting business of the City.”

Advertise with us

This referendum question seems to directly address the details of the divestment proposal that seeks to stop city investment from going to any city participating in genocide or ethnic cleansing.

The legislation notes that the city “lacks the immense time and resources required to evaluate the activities of all foreign governments that City vendors or contractors interact with.”

Though the divestment proposal indicates that this would only apply to future contracts and not be retroactive, major companies the city does business with like PNC Bank or Dell computers have ties to Israel.

The legislation does note that should this referendum pass, the city “will not refuse to do business with, or otherwise discriminate against any person or entity based on race, religion, national origin, real or perceived, or connection, association or affiliation with any nation or foreign state.”

However, it does not prohibit the city from following any order from the federal or state government preventing governments from doing business with foreign states.

Advertise with us

Both referendums were co-sponsored by council members Erika Strassburger, Daniel Lavelle, Bob Charland, Anthony Coghill and Bobby Wilson. Councilwoman Theresa Kail-Smith called for a public hearing to be scheduled regarding the proposed referendums. It’s currently unclear when that will be scheduled for.

Further discussion regarding the ballot referendums is anticipated during next week’s council meeting and a final vote could come as early as the first week of February. Council members first have to vote on the directive before the county can add the questions to the ballot.

The Not on Our Dime campaign has until Feb. 18 to collect 12,500 valid signatures to get their question on the ballot. Council is able to direct the Allegheny County Board of Elections to add ballot questions without going through the signature collection process because of a separate measure in the Home Rule Charter.

It’s a rarely-used provision in the charter, in the last decade it’s only been used a handful of times, most recently in 2020 to expand the powers of the city’s independent Citizen Police Review Board.

Last year’s efforts were challenged in court by City Controller Rachael Heisler and the Jewish Federation of Greater Pittsburgh. The federation has already indicated that they are exploring “all avenues” including a potential challenge this year.

The primary election is May 20.