As the race for the next mayor of Pittsburgh enters the pivotal time period ahead of the May Democratic primary, the winner stands to inherit the keys to the city — and some of the problems plaguing it.

Mayor Ed Gainey announced in early September that he would be running for re-election. In December, Allegheny County Controller Corey O’Connor made his candidacy announcement, setting the men up for a competitive primary election.

No other Democrats and no Republicans have said they would run yet.

Issues such as the dwindling budget reserves and getting nonprofits to contribute monetarily to the city have already been talking points for both campaigns. That theme is likely to continue through the spring.

Advertise with us

A balanced budget

Whoever wins this year will have to manage at least a few years with a lean budget. As a result of the expiration of federal pandemic relief funding, increased debt service payments and decreases in revenue sources like property taxes, the city’s coffers are looking thin in 2025 and beyond.

Five year budget projections show the city’s reserve fund balance dipping to about $72 million in 2029. Last year, the fund balance was about $177.4 million, according to city budgets.

In an effort to reduce spending, the administration has cut overtime spending from key public safety departments, including police.

Throughout budget discussions in 2024, city officials noted the need to start exploring alternative revenue sources. Projections for 2025 expect the city to bring in $8 million less than in 2024 in real estate taxes. Over the past year, multiple large buildings Downtown have seen assessed property values plummet drastically, leading to a decrease in the city’s tax revenue.

The 2025 budget did avoid layoffs and a tax increase, but it’s unclear how long that pattern will hold with dwindling revenues.

Advertise with us

The nonprofit question

The question of how to get the city’s large nonprofit community to pay into city services has plagued mayors for years and whoever wins this year’s mayoral election will be faced with the same problem.

Part of Mr. Gainey’s 2021 campaign included the mantra of making the big five local nonprofits — UPMC, Allegheny Health Network, the University of Pittsburgh, Carnegie Mellon University and Duquesne University — to “pay their fair share.” During his administration, Mr. Gainey has filed two rounds of challenges to the tax exempt status of properties owned by the big five and other local nonprofit organizations.

The first round in 2023 resulted in just 12 of the 27 challenges being returned to the tax rolls. Two of those properties were parking garages owned by the University of Pittsburgh and Carnegie Mellon University.

Among the 2024 challenges were Allegheny General Hospital on the North Side and UPMC Children’s Hospital in Oakland. Of the 104 challenges in 2024, just 17 of them were returned to the tax rolls, bringing in an estimated $92,800 based on 2024 tax assessments. Tax experts previously warned that this method of getting the nonprofits to pay into city services was unlikely to be successful. Other cities, including Erie, have payment in lieu of taxes programs set up with UPMC and AHN where the healthcare giants pay half of what they would pay in property taxes to the city.

Former Mayor Bill Peduto helped create OnePGH, which was intended to be an agreement between the city, local nonprofits and foundations where they would pay into a fund that was separate from the city’s finances, but would be used for various initiatives to better the city, like affordable housing or social and health services.

Advertise with us

Mr. Gainey disbanded the program early on in his administration and during budget discussions in the fall, Jake Pawlak, the director of the Office of Management and Budget, explained that decision was made because it was an entity outside of city control. City council would not have been able to approve the spending and the city controller wouldn’t have been able to audit it, he said.

In announcing his candidacy, Mr. O’Connor indicated that working out some kind of deal, whether it be a pilot program or otherwise, was a priority of his, should he win.

Zoning

In an effort to increase the city’s housing supply and bring down costs, Mr. Gainey proposed sweeping changes to the city’s zoning code in September. He proposed making inclusionary zoning a citywide mandate, removing parking requirements for new developments and permit accessory dwelling units — sometimes called granny flats — on residential property.

But the package of changes has stalled at the planning commission as conflicting legislation from city council members and outcry from residents delay the mayor’s efforts.

Prior to Mr. Gainey’s package being introduced at council, Councilwoman Theresa Kail-Smith had introduced legislation that would require the development of smaller community homes to be approved by council and be subject to a public hearing where residents can speak about the project.

Advertise with us

Mr. Gainey’s legislation, in an effort to reduce barriers to development, looks to allow group homes of up to 10 residents to be allowed “by right,” which would mean they would not be subject to a public hearing if they meet certain criteria.

Both bills are under review with the planning commission.

Mr. Gainey’s goals of expanding inclusionary zoning — which would require all new developments to have some units set aside for low-income residents — has also been met with competing legislation from city council.

While Mr. Gainey intends to make inclusionary zoning a city-wide zoning mandate, Councilman Bob Charland introduced legislation that would leave it up to individual neighborhoods whether they want to be part of it.

Despite being dubbed a “political stunt” by other council members, Mr. Charland’s legislation was referred to the Planning Commission.

Advertise with us

At the heart of the zoning debates, and something the majority of officials agree on, is that Pittsburgh needs more housing, particularly for low-income residents. Many aspects of the city’s zoning code date back to the 1920s, when redlining ran rampant in zoning codes, particularly in Pittsburgh.

Some estimates also show the city is short nearly 9,000 affordable units for low-income renters and about 40% of all renters in the city are cost-burdened, meaning they spend more than 30% of their income on housing.

A well-known challenger

Mr. Gainey is facing a very specific challenge this spring and that’s going up against a well-known opponent.

Mr. O'Connor is not new to Pittsburgh politics. He joked during his campaign announcement speech how some people claim city politics is “in his blood.”

The son of beloved Mayor Bob O’Connor, who died just nine months into his administration in 2005 from a rare form of brain cancer, Mr. O’Connor has the familial history that appeals to some in Pittsburgh who remember the elder O’Connor.

Advertise with us

He also served on Pittsburgh City Council for a decade, including during the expiration of state financial oversight and the 2018 synagogue shooting. In 2022, he was appointed as the Allegheny County Controller by then-Gov. Tom Wolf. He won a full-term in 2023.

Mr. Gainey and Mr. O’Connor have shared support from similar labor unions, like the Service Employees International Union. However, Mr. Gainey was part of the progressive wave that was sweeping Allegheny County, along with the election of U.S. Rep. Summer Lee and County Executive Sara Innamorato. Mr. O’Connor represents, for some, a return to the more moderate types of Democrats that have historically occupied City Hall.

Mr. O’Connor has never faced an intensively competitive primary, like the one he is bound to see this spring. And it has historically been difficult to unseat an incumbent in the mayor’s office. Mr. Gainey was the first do so in modern history when he defeated Mr. Peduto in 2021.