District Attorney Stephen A. Zappala Jr. is suing Allegheny County and its retirement board, alleging that the pension fund is headed toward insolvency, jeopardizing the benefits owed to thousands of workers.
“The [retirement] system is severely underfunded and presents a long-term risk for current and former county employees if not remediated,” the lawsuit says. “The board and the county cannot remain passive; the situation is so dire that significant affirmative action must be taken to avoid the presently inevitable insolvency of the system.”
The lawsuit, filed Wednesday in Allegheny County Common Pleas Court, alleges that the county’s retirement fund will “become insolvent in approximately fifteen years,” based on an actuarial report that was submitted to the retirement board Nov. 6, according to the lawsuit.
“This means that when the average County employee, who is currently 46.4 years of age with 11.3 years of past service, becomes eligible to retire with a County pension, the plan assets will be depleted,” the lawsuit alleges. Typically, a county employee must be 60 years old with 25 years of service to qualify for a pension.
Mr. Zappala wants a judge to declare that the pension fund is not actuarily sound and order the county to develop a plan to fund the pension at a 100% rate.
Mr. Zappala is suing on behalf of the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania and Rebecca Spangler, his chief of staff, in her personal capacity as someone who has been contributing to the retirement fund since 1995. Mr. Zappala is being represented by the Philadelphia law firm of Dilworth Paxon and the Pittsburgh firm of Brucker and Porter.
The lawsuit stems from an investigation the DA’s office began on a complaint from a member of the retirement board, Mr. Zappala said in a statement. That person’s name has not been released. That complaint alleges “a conspiracy to defraud the Allegheny County Employees’ Retirement System.” The investigation is ongoing.
The seven-member retirement board, which oversees the fund, includes top people in county government: County Executive Sara Innamorato, County Treasurer Erica Rocchi Brusselars and County Controller Corey O’Connor, who announced his candidacy for Pittsburgh mayor just a day before Mr. Zappala filed the lawsuit.
Mr. O’Connor, the county’s financial watchdog, called out the fund’s “poor financial condition” in August and sought a court order to end the practice of including bonuses in pension calculations — one of the practices he said was “bankrupting the fund.”
“Bonuses are not the problem — they are just not pensionable,” he said in a news release. “The bonuses we’re seeing are discretionary, exceed the contributions and benefits of most other County employees, and exacerbate the Pension Fund’s insolvency.”
He also noted that not including bonuses in pension calculations would “not fix everything,” but it would be the “first step.”
At the time, Mr. O’Connor said the system was only 31% funded.
Generally, government agencies and trade associations say having a retirement fund 80% funded is a benchmark for a healthy pension plan. As of Jan. 1, the county’s pension account was funded at about 43% – a decrease from the 59.5% funded level the system had in 2013, according to Mr. Zappala’s lawsuit, which noted the actuarial report showed “an unfunded liability of $1.27 billion, using an aggressive 7.75% assumed investment rate of return.”

The lawsuit notes that using such a high rate of return results in the reports “actually understating the extent of the System’s crisis.”
“Doing business as usual is unacceptable,” Mr. O’Connor said in August. “Credit rating agencies have already flagged our pension as a potential reason to downgrade our credit rating, which would have significant downstream effects on our County’s economic, development, and fiscal operations. Simply put, we cannot afford to make a serious problem worse.”
Mr. O’Connor’s filing is still pending a court decision, but is likely to be resolved by next week.
In his lawsuit, Mr. Zappala says the problem isn’t employee contributions, which are already higher than most other public pension funds in the country. County government’s contribution rate, however, is among the lowest, Mr. Zappala said.
Since 2013, about 12,000 county employees and retirees either contribute to or receive benefits from the retirement fund. County employees and the county itself pay into the fund.
The board sets the employee contribution rate for the year, and the county is required to match the contributions of county employees. For 2024, the employees paid 11% and the county matched that, totaling 22% or about $91 million added to the fund.
“The System is already extracting contributions from County employees … significantly higher than most systems in the United States, while the contributions made by the County (i.e. plan sponsor) are significantly lower than most systems,” the lawsuit states.
Mr. Zappala claims that “for over a decade” the system hasn’t met the 80% benchmark, “let alone the ultimate goal of a 100% funded status.”
“Any further delay in remedying the problem will make solutions far more draconian in the future,” the lawsuit says.
Mr. Zappala also alleged that “despite these clear and well-known warning signs,” the retirement board has “continuously failed to develop a plan to counteract the diminishing funded status.”
There previously were plans to increase the employee’s contribution to 14.5% from 11%. Mr. Zappala, in the lawsuit, called that a “flawed strategy” that would lead to employees leaving for other jobs, further cutting into the payments made into the teetering fund.
Mr. Zappala’s lawsuit asks a judge to “issue a writ of mandamus directing the County and the Retirement Board to take such action as is necessary to place the System into an actuarially sound condition,” declare the system is not actuarially sound in violation of the County Code and Pennsylvania Constitution, “and/or restrain Defendants’ deceptive and unlawful conduct under the Unfair Trade Practices and Consumer Protection Law.”
It also asks that the county create a plan to bring the system to 100% funding “in a reasonable period of time.”
Allegheny County spokeswoman Abigail Gardner declined to comment on the lawsuit.
“Allegheny County is facing one of the most serious unfunded pension crises in the history” of the state, Mr. Zappala said. “It is my hope that all parties will work together to ensure that the benefits earned by the System’s participants will be paid as promised.”
While Mr. Zappala contends it’s “incumbent on the county” to fix the underfunding problem, county government faces its own precarious financial situation. Last week, County Council and Ms. Innamorato approved a 36% property tax increase — the first in more than a decade — that Ms. Innamorato warned was necessary to stave off layoffs and steep service cuts.
Sheila Weinberg the founder and CEO of Truth in Accounting, a nonprofit based in Illinois that examines government finances and pension funds, said “it’s not going to be pretty” for the county to get out of this situation.
“There’s really only two options,” she said. “Raise taxes or cut benefits.”
While the 43% funding level the county is sitting at is “pretty low,” according to Ms. Weinberg, she is aware of other places, including Chicago, that have lower funding levels.
“Not saying that’s a good thing,” she added. “If [governments] are going to offer guaranteed benefits, they should fund them fully.”
She also warned that if the stock market “takes a dump” the percentage at which the pension is funded will decrease, worsening the situation.
Allegheny County has a legal requirement to present a balanced budget, but Ms. Weinberg said that if the pensions are being underfunded, it’s not technically balanced.
“By not funding the pensions, [governments] are able to overspend and not raise taxes,” she said.
The lawsuit will not affect current benefit recipients’ payments, Mr. Zappala said in a statement. “There is no immediate risk of nonpayment of retirement benefits.”






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.