A settlement proposal is on the table between County Council, the office of the Allegheny County Executive and the nonprofit currently running a recently reopened juvenile detention facility in Pittsburgh, and it now faces a council vote Tuesday.
The Highland Detention at Shuman Center — formerly known as the Shuman Juvenile Detention Center — reopened in July after the county reached an agreement with Adelphoi, a Latrobe-based private nonprofit, last year. But County Council sued former county Executive Rich Fitzgerald’s administration and county court officials, stating that entering into a contract to run the facility without council approval violated the county charter.
County Council President Patrick Catena could not immediately be reached for comment. Karyn Pratt, vice president of Marketing & Strategy Development at Adelphoi, declined to comment.
According to settlement proceedings in August, council, Adelphoi and the county had agreed to the composition of a board of advisors established under state law. It would consist of 10 members: the county executive, county controller, three people appointed by the president judge of Allegheny County, four appointed by the county executive and one person chosen by the executive from three finalists selected by County Council.
The board will meet no more than once a month, with the county’s Department of Human Services director or representative and a representative of Adelphoi attending the meetings and providing reports about multiple aspects of facility conditions relating to operations, environmental conditions and health and safety at least a week before those meetings.
The other big part of the proposal is that at the end of the county’s five-year contract with Adelphoi, if the county executive wants to continue the agreement, the executive must get approval from County Council, with 90 days notice before the end of the contract. Adelphoi and county officials also settled their crossclaims related to the case.
Read More
Despite a proposal being reached, there was some disagreement about the overall purpose of the board. Frederick Frank, County Council’s attorney, had wanted bylaws to be drafted, but Rosalyn Guy-McCorkle, the county’s solicitor, did not agree.
But Mr. Catena said that getting the settlement approved could be tricky because establishing a board without members having any clear instructions on their responsibilities was an issue.
“When I'm dealing with 14 other members, to try to get eight members to buy into this without any idea, at least if I go back to them with something and I tell them it looks like a cow and moves like a cow, and we are pretty sure it is a cow,” Mr. Catena said at one point in court. “But if I go back and tell them we are not really sure what this board does, that is not going to go over well with me getting eight votes.”
Judge Katherine B. Emery told Mr. Catena and council that they had gotten certain relief in the settlement proposal regarding the contract and board of advisors. The county’s attorneys and council agreed that the state statute governing the board was general, but Judge Emery said that while it doesn’t have the same “teeth” as an oversight board, it has a purpose.
It’s still unclear what exactly would occur, but Judge Emery said that Adelphoi having exercise time or equipment for juveniles would be under Adelphoi’s management and thus eligible for review. But if someone has special needs and needs special exercise equipment, that wouldn’t be for review, she said.
“Think of driving a car. You are looking ahead,” Judge Emery said. “Anything above the dashboard is an advisory board function. Anything below the dashboard is not for review of that. You want to help where it is going, but you don’t necessarily being [sic] driving to do that.”
The parties agreed that the newly appointed board members would adopt their own bylaws.
A county source said Monday that the settlement proposal largely aligns with state law, but broadly speaking, it offers more specifics on how the board would operate and give council more power over extending the contract. They said it was unclear whether Mr. Catena would be able to get eight votes to approve the settlement.
County Executive Sara Innamorato had submitted five people for consideration for the Juvenile Detention Board of Advisors before settlement discussions occurred in August, but council rejected them at a meeting in July, saying they didn’t have enough notice or information to approve.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.