Pittsburgh is slightly ahead of other cities when it comes to having federal COVID-19 relief funds under contract, but the city still has millions of dollars to obligate before the end-of-year deadline.
Pittsburgh received about $335 million from the federal government as part of the American Rescue Plan Act, designed to help cities and other municipalities deal with the financial challenges of the pandemic.
The city has until the end of 2026 to spend the money, but it all must be under contract — “obligated” — by the end of this year, leaving about four months for Mayor Ed Gainey’s administration to nail down contracts for the nearly $24 million that has yet to be obligated.
Any money not under contract by the end of this year has to be returned to the federal government. As of the end of June, the city had contracted about $311.4 million, according to compliance reports that had to be filed with the federal government.
Pittsburgh was “slightly ahead of other large local governments … in terms of the amount of money obligated,” said Glencora Haskins, a research associate and applied research manager at the Brookings Institute, where she helped to create and maintain the institute’s Local Government ARPA Investment Tracker.
The tracker, created in conjunction with the National League of Cities, monitors how much money cities are allocating toward different categories such as infrastructure, housing and community needs.
Read More
“[Pittsburgh is] a couple of percentage points ahead of the curve,” she said. “Not monumentally ahead, but not behind.”
The tracker is based on reports filed at the end of 2023 and has not yet been updated with information from the first and second quarter of 2024, but it seemed unlikely that Pittsburgh would have fallen behind in that timeframe, Ms. Haskins said.

Across the country, the average percentage of funds obligated is about 70%. Pittsburgh has obligated about 77% of its funds. In cities of similar size, Cleveland, which received about $509 million, has contracted 99% of its funds, while St. Louis has contracted about 54% of the $498 million it received.
Peter McDevitt, Pittsburgh City Council’s budget director, said he was not concerned about the city having to return any of the money.
“The last thing we want to do is have to give any of it back,” he said. “Everybody’s working together to make sure that doesn’t happen.”
More than half of the money was quickly contracted and spent after it was awarded. About $112.9 million went directly to making sure that no city employees were laid off during the early lockdown stages of the pandemic. Another large chunk — about $64.9 million — went to restoring and supplementing the city’s operating budget so that regular city services could continue as they had pre-pandemic.
Since then, city officials have been moving money around to fund capital projects such as repairing the Davis Avenue pedestrian bridge, paving streets, and creating new programs including the Food Justice Fund.
With less than five months left, though, Ms. Haskins advised local governments to take a hard look at their investment strategies.
“It's not necessarily time to ring the fire alarm yet,” she said. “But it is time to start thinking about turning investments into categories that can be expended quicker.”
That’s something the city has begun.
Just before City Council went on its summer recess at the end of July, it approved a slew of bills that reallocated about $8.7 million of the federal funds. The reallocation moved the money away from projects that likely wouldn’t be under contract by the end of the year and placed them in projects that were already under contract.
The projects that had funds removed, such as upgrades to the Thaddeus Stevens School, will be completed, the Office of Management and Budget’s director, Jake Pawlak, assured members; they would just be done with bond funds instead.
A large part of the federal dollars were moved to a line item for street paving and to the construction of the Department of Public Works fourth division facility in Knoxville.
These transfers were done “in an abundance of caution,” Mr. Pawlak told council members.
He said the administration “fully expects” all of the projects to be under contract by the end of the year, but “in the event that something in the opening of the bids causes a delay, we just don’t want to miss the ARPA deadline.”
Councilman Bob Charland noted at a council meeting in July that he’d like to see the relief money go toward projects the city “wouldn’t otherwise be able to” undertake, such as bridge work.
But the time to plan new projects had passed, according to Mr. Pawlak.
“I would agree with you in general and principle,” he said then. “We’re really working on the margins here.”
But the changes did include two new allocation line items: one for a mobile public restroom project and one to create a partnership with the county to manage lead remediation programs.

Each project is receiving $600,000 in ARPA funds, according to city documents. The public restroom program is scheduled to place 10 mobile restrooms around the city, the documents said, though little other information has been made available.
Mr. Gainey’s office declined to comment on the ARPA spending or the specifics of the mobile restroom program.
Mr. McDevitt said that if need be, there is still “time to pivot one last time” to make sure all the money is obligated by the end of the year.
That would likely look similar to what the city did in July, by switching capital projects that were not yet under contract to being funded by bonds and moving the federal dollars into projects already under contract.
“I think everybody understands that at this point, we just need to make sure that we’re spending it all in a thoughtful manner,” Mr. McDevitt said.
This type of restructuring hasn’t been uncommon among other cities, Ms. Haskins said, particularly among infrastructure projects.
“Some of these things just can take a long time to get out the door,” she said. “Public sector procurement can take a very, very long time … so when you see projects that have been slower to get things obligated and spent, it’s more of a product of that than it is a desire to wait until the last minute to maximize returns.”
Having the ARPA funds in the city’s bank account has helped bolster the budget in more ways than one: interest income for the city has largely increased as a result of the federal aid.
In 2019, the city’s budget estimated it would bring in $2.2 million in interest income. The 2024 budget, with the help of ARPA funds, is estimating the city will make $16.5 million from interest alone, according to city budgets.
As the money is spent over the next two years, that interest will dramatically decrease and city officials are already projecting financially lean years ahead with increased debt payments and a decrease in property taxes.
Others have raised concerns about the sustainability of some of the ARPA-funded programs, like the Food Justice Fund, that don’t currently have an alternate funding source for when the federal money runs out.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.