After days of upheaval over a petition backing a ballot referendum to prevent the city of Pittsburgh from doing business with any entity connected to Israel, the proposal was withdrawn before an assessment of the legal challenges had really begun.

In a brief hearing Monday morning, Court of Common Pleas Judge John T. McVay ruled the petition had been set aside “because it lacks the requisite number of signatures by qualified, registered electors residing within the city of Pittsburgh as mandated” by the home rule charter and state law.

The abrupt withdrawal came after challenges were filed last week by both the city controller and by the Jewish Federation of Greater Pittsburgh. Before Monday’s hearing began, lawyers from the various parties stepped into the judge’s chambers to discuss a “stipulation that has been reached.” Judge McVay issued his order when they returned.

The short but intense battle over the referendum was a dramatic one. City Controller Rachael Heisler’s challenge to the referendum predicted it would force the city to effectively shut down. And as questions were raised over signatures on the petition, Mayor Ed Gainey’s communications director resigned and the mayor himself walked away from questions,

Advertise with us

Jeff Finkelstein, CEO of the Jewish Federation of Greater Pittsburgh, said he and others who challenged the petition were pleased with the outcome.

“It’s simple as in two words: We won,” Mr. Finkelstein said. “That’s the most important thing. And whatever the other side says, or tries to position it [as], we won on the legal basis that our lawyers had laid out.”

Prior to the hearing, the Pittsburgh Democratic Socialists for America had announced on social media that it was withdrawing the petition.

“We have made the difficult but strategic decision to withdraw our petitions so that we can come back stronger, more experienced and fully ready to continue fighting for a free Palestine with all avenues available to us,” the Pittsburgh DSA posted in a long thread on its X account.

Multiple organizers involved with backing the petition held a brief news conference outside the City-County Building after the hearing Monday. Ben Case, one of the speakers, said the Democratic Socialists and other partners did not have the resources to continue the court fight.

Advertise with us

“There’s a gray area of signatures” that the campaign would have had to fight over in court, and it’s unclear whether it would have won, Mr. Case said.

The petition, which sought to change Pittsburgh’s Home Rule Charter, required 12,459 valid signatures to go on the ballot. Documents originally submitted contained 15,253 signatures, and the Allegheny County Board of Elections preliminarily deemed 12,850 of those to be valid.

As part of its challenge, the Jewish Federation conducted a line-by-line analysis of the signatures and maintained that 10,387 should be thrown out for reasons such as legibility, residency, not registered to vote at the address listed, and being signed after the circulation deadline.

The petition effort had been associated with a website, No War Crimes On Our Dime, that indicated it was funded by the Democratic Socialists for America. That website had not been updated Monday morning to include the withdrawal. Instead, the DSA appeared on to be making the decision and posted the explanation.

During the court hearing, Ron Hicks, one of the attorneys for the federation, said they were still aiming to recoup attorneys’ costs from the DSA for bringing forth the case, but it was unclear Monday how much that could be, or when that would be ruled on.

Advertise with us

Judge McVay asked during the hearing whether Chuck Pascal, an attorney representing the organizers of the ballot referendum, had any comment on the agreement. Mr. Pascal declined to comment.

Mr. Finkelstein said the agreement between both sides to withdraw the petition left some aspects of the case untouched, such as whether the petition violated state law.

“There is [anti-Boycott, Divestment, Sanctions] legislation at the state level that our state was smart to put in place a couple of years ago,” he said. “This goes directly against it, this referendum.”

Mr. Case, Addy Lord — another organizer — and others said that if the ballot issue had been put to voters in November, they were confident it would have passed.

Ms. Heisler had said the ballot issue, if passed, could impact city services because it would force the city to cut ties with companies such as Duquesne Light and PNC Bank, and officials would be unable to buy fuel for emergency vehicles or certain life-saving drugs from pharmaceutical companies. The overly broad wording of the petition violated the city charter and state law, she has said.

Advertise with us

Ms. Lord said she and others were simply looking to get the issue on the ballot in November for city voters to decide.

“My personal opinion is I don’t believe that there’s standing of whether an issue needs to be valid to allow people to vote,” she said.

The DSA posted on X: “Our referendum qualification sparked a massive reaction. The City Controller & Jewish Federation took us to court ... They don’t want Pittsburghers to vote on this issue, because they know we’ll win.

“Those who support Israel unconditionally have poured resources into these legal challenges that we simply cannot keep up with.

“This is a strategic withdrawal, and by no means a loss,” the DSA claimed on social media.

Advertise with us

Mr. Case said that if the ballot measure had passed, he and other organizers would have liked to work with city officials to draft corresponding legislation to fulfill the referendum, in a responsible way, regarding city services.

Ms. Heisler called the decision a “victory” for the city and believed her office and other challengers would have won if the case had continued in court.

“I believe the referendum language itself is why they failed to get enough signatures,” she wrote in a statement. “City residents do not want to lose access to the essential drugs our medics and EMTs carry, or the safety equipment that protects our firefighters, or the electricity that keeps the lights on. This is fundamentally bad policy that would not make anyone safer — in Pittsburgh or in Gaza.”

Maria Montano, Mr. Gainey’s former communications director, resigned last week after her signing of the petition became public.

Late Monday afternoon, Mr. Gainey issued a statement saying: “I believe the vast majority of our residents deeply wish for an end to hostilities in Gaza as well as for the return of all hostages, and we continue to pray for better, wiser leadership to emerge so that there can be peace.

“My role in this work is to keep Pittsburgh safe and to make common cause with those who refuse violence and who are actively listening to their neighbors and engaging in meaningful dialogue, as that is the only real path forward.”